Spring sandals that keep up with your plans.Shop Now

Johnston & Murphy
Mcguffey 2 Plain Toe
Men's

Name: Mcguffey 2 Plain Toe
Brand: Johnston & Murphy
SKU: 9993204
Price: 154.95 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4 (8 reviews)

(8)

FREEupgraded shipping & returns with

Made of a padded tongue, collar, and heel, the Johnston & Murphy® Mcguffey 2 Plain Toe shoes pair perfectly with most outfits and styles. The full-grain leather upper features a lace-up closure for a secure fit. They are designed with a leather and textile lining and high-rebound, ultra-comfortable XC Foam footbed and midsole for added comfort.
Round toe shape.
Rubber outsole.
Imported.
Product measurements were taken using size 9, width M (D). Please note that measurements may vary by size.
Measurements:
- Weight: 12 oz
SKU 9993204

Customer Questions

Was this page helpful?

Show how you wore it!

Be the first to add your Mcguffey 2 Plain Toe outfit to this gallery!

Share Your Outfit

Customer Reviews

Johnston & Murphy Mcguffey 2 Plain Toe

Write A Review

8 total reviews

62%Rated 5 stars out of 5

25%Rated 4 stars out of 5

0%Rated 3 stars out of 5

0%Rated 2 stars out of 5

12%Rated 1 star out of 5

63%"Felt true to size"

88%"Felt true to width"

63%"Moderate arch support"

63%True to size

88% Felt true to width

63% Moderate arch support

Free Shipping and Free Returns

If you are unsatisfied with your purchase from Zappos you may return it in its original condition for a full refund to your original form of payment within 60 days of purchase.

Learn more about our free shipping and free returns policy

Free Shipping and Free Returns

If you are unsatisfied with your purchase from Zappos you may return it in its original condition for a full refund to your original form of payment within 60 days of purchase.

Learn more about our free shipping and free returns policy

Show how you wore it!

Be the first to add your Mcguffey 2 Plain Toe outfit to this gallery!

Share Your Outfit

This fits true to size.

Customer Reviews

Johnston & Murphy Mcguffey 2 Plain Toe

8 total reviews

62%Rated 5 stars out of 5

25%Rated 4 stars out of 5

0%Rated 3 stars out of 5

0%Rated 2 stars out of 5

12%Rated 1 star out of 5

63%"Felt true to size"

88%"Felt true to width"

63%"Moderate arch support"

63%True to size

88% Felt true to width

63% Moderate arch support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Great fit, great construction, solid quality and details. I bought three similar shoes and chose these because they offered the most support in a light soft soul which is unusual. I only hesitation is that I’m not sure whether the tread will last but we will see. They looked and felt noticeably better than the others.

Also recommend

Noat, Ecco

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, May 18, 2025

2 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Very comfortable soft leather. Looks great. Went 1/2" size smaller than I normally wear. Felt tight the first 1-hour of wearing. Then softened up and are very comfortable now. Great shoe.

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, March 30, 2025

1 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Review for Zappos VIP Points (What's this?)

Comfortable and versatile.

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, September 15, 2025

0 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Husband loved:)

Rhonda, Zappos Customer, March 20, 2025

0 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Good fit and feel. Casual with no socks and shorts. Fine with pants for a little dressier look. Very versatile. Comfortable.

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, January 21, 2025

0 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Read Additional 3 Customer Reviews

Overall

Comfort

Style

Also recommend

Noat, Ecco

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, May 18, 2025

2 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Very comfortable soft leather. Looks great. Went 1/2" size smaller than I normally wear. Felt tight the first 1-hour of wearing. Then softened up and are very comfortable now. Great shoe.

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, March 30, 2025

1 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Review for Zappos VIP Points (What's this?)

Comfortable and versatile.

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, September 15, 2025

0 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Husband loved:)

Rhonda, Zappos Customer, March 20, 2025

0 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Good fit and feel. Casual with no socks and shorts. Fine with pants for a little dressier look. Very versatile. Comfortable.

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, January 21, 2025

0 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Read Additional 3 Customer Reviews

Johnston & Murphy
Mcguffey 2 Plain Toe
Men's

Customer Questions

Show how you wore it!

Customer Reviews

Free Shipping and Free Returns

About Zappos

Customer Service

Resources

Explore Zappos

Customer Questions

Free Shipping and Free Returns

Show how you wore it!

Customer Reviews

Johnston & MurphyMcguffey 2 Plain ToeMen's

Product Information

Size Chart

Customer Questions

Show how you wore it!

Customer Reviews

Rating Summary:

Review Breakdown:

Customer Fit Survey:

Free Shipping and Free Returns

Customer Questions

Free Shipping and Free Returns

Show how you wore it!

Customer Reviews

Rating Summary:

Review Breakdown:

Customer Fit Survey:

Johnston & Murphy
Mcguffey 2 Plain Toe
Men's