Perfect picks for every name on your list.Shop Now

Johnston & Murphy
Gavney Plain Toe
Men's

Name: Gavney Plain Toe
Brand: Johnston & Murphy
SKU: 9823286
Price: 158.95 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 5 (15 reviews)

(15)

Free delivery - Select a size to see delivery date

Deliver to

Make a modish statement wherever you go wearing the Johnston & Murphy® Gavney Plain Toe Oxfords.
Patent leather upper.
Leather lining and cushioned leather footbed.
Traditional lace-up closure.
Almond toe silhouette.
Leather and rubber outsole.
Imported.
Measurements:Single Shoe Weight: 1 Oz.
SKU 9823286

Customer Questions

Was this page helpful?

Show how you wore it!

Be the first to add your Gavney Plain Toe outfit to this gallery!

Share Your Outfit

Customer Reviews

Johnston & Murphy Gavney Plain Toe

Write A Review

15 total reviews

87%Rated 5 stars out of 5

13%Rated 4 stars out of 5

0%Rated 3 stars out of 5

0%Rated 2 stars out of 5

0%Rated 1 star out of 5

67%"Felt true to size"

100%"Felt true to width"

100%"Moderate arch support"

67%True to size

100% Felt true to width

100% Moderate arch support

Free Shipping and Free Returns

If you are unsatisfied with your purchase from Zappos you may return it in its original condition for a full refund to your original form of payment within 60 days of purchase.

Learn more about our free shipping and free returns policy

Free Shipping and Free Returns

If you are unsatisfied with your purchase from Zappos you may return it in its original condition for a full refund to your original form of payment within 60 days of purchase.

Learn more about our free shipping and free returns policy

Customer Reviews

Johnston & Murphy Gavney Plain Toe

15 total reviews

87%Rated 5 stars out of 5

13%Rated 4 stars out of 5

0%Rated 3 stars out of 5

0%Rated 2 stars out of 5

0%Rated 1 star out of 5

67%"Felt true to size"

100%"Felt true to width"

100%"Moderate arch support"

67%True to size

100% Felt true to width

100% Moderate arch support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Review for Zappos VIP Points (What's this?)

These definitely run small! I wear a 10 in just about every brand but these. I even have an older pair of J&M dress shoes I bought a their brick and mortar store that are a 9W. These 10s are so tight they’re unwearable for me. I’ll be returning this pair and reordering in size 11. They are nice looking patent leather shoes and appear to be well constructed. I ordered a pair of Florsheim patent leather shoes at the same time for comparison. J&M clearly has superior construction (genuine leather sole, all-leather interior, suede heel piece to prevent foot slippage), so I’ll be going with the J&Ms just in a larger size.

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, April 6, 2026

0 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Reviewed at Johnston Murphy

Perfect for HOCO and Prom: Bought these for my sons homecoming dance and they were perfect!

Kodi, September 22, 2025

0 Found this review helpful.

Overall

Comfort

Style

It fit to size and it feel comfortable on my feet.

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, May 26, 2025

0 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Reviewed at Johnston & Murphy

This shoe has a beautiful high polish and fits true to size, 9. 5M. although I am not a big fan for the barrel - shape shoe laces, the only other detraction is the man made footbed. I give this 4 stars,

Peter, December 8, 2024

0 Found this review helpful.

Overall

Reviewed at Johnston & Murphy

So far, one of the most comfortable dress shoes I've ever owned. Think I'll get all my shoes from Johnston and Murphy.

David, November 6, 2024

0 Found this review helpful.

Read Additional 10 Customer Reviews

Fits true to size for most. Consider a 1/2 size down if you have narrow feet.

Show how you wore it!

Be the first to add your Gavney Plain Toe outfit to this gallery!

Share Your Outfit

Overall

Comfort

Style

Review for Zappos VIP Points (What's this?)

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, April 6, 2026

0 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Reviewed at Johnston Murphy

Perfect for HOCO and Prom: Bought these for my sons homecoming dance and they were perfect!

Kodi, September 22, 2025

0 Found this review helpful.

Overall

Comfort

Style

It fit to size and it feel comfortable on my feet.

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, May 26, 2025

0 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Reviewed at Johnston & Murphy

Peter, December 8, 2024

0 Found this review helpful.

Overall

Reviewed at Johnston & Murphy

So far, one of the most comfortable dress shoes I've ever owned. Think I'll get all my shoes from Johnston and Murphy.

David, November 6, 2024

0 Found this review helpful.

Read Additional 10 Customer Reviews

Johnston & Murphy
Gavney Plain Toe
Men's

Customer Questions

Show how you wore it!

Customer Reviews

Free Shipping and Free Returns

About Zappos

Customer Service

Resources

Explore Zappos

Free Shipping and Free Returns

Customer Reviews

Customer Questions

Show how you wore it!

Johnston & MurphyGavney Plain ToeMen's

Product Information

Size Chart

Customer Questions

Show how you wore it!

Customer Reviews

Rating Summary:

Review Breakdown:

Customer Fit Survey:

Free Shipping and Free Returns

Free Shipping and Free Returns

Customer Reviews

Rating Summary:

Review Breakdown:

Customer Fit Survey:

Customer Questions

Show how you wore it!

Johnston & Murphy
Gavney Plain Toe
Men's