Name: Pinch Penny
Brand: Cole Haan
SKU: 7322473
Price: 168.00 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4 (174 reviews)

Reviews

4.0

(174)

Write A Review

Customers Say

Customers praise these penny loafers for their beautiful workmanship, soft leather, and excellent shine, with one customer noting they dress up well with charcoal gray pants, blazer, and bow tie. Customers find them extremely comfortable and consider them good value for money. The fit and durability receive mixed feedback - while some find the width perfect, others say they're too large, and while some say they hold up well to wear, others report they don't last as long as expected.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews.

Select To Learn More

82%True to size

84% Felt true to width

86% Moderate arch support

Sort by:

Overall

Comfort

Style

A low quality shoe. The color has rubbed off the toes and parts of the heels. I wore these primarily in my home, so it was disappointing. The soles wore out in 8-9 months and had to be repaired. Frankly, I expected this to happen. I've owned the same shoe style for 25+ years and they used to be okay way back when. They are truly junk, now, but they still look good at first and remain a style I like but can no longer continue to buy due to low quality.

Also recommend

don't know

Richard R, Zappos Customer, May 25, 2011

23 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Verified Purchase

Normally I don’t take the time to write reviews. But this time I felt inclined to share my experiences. This was the 2nd pair of the same type of Cole Haan shoes (Pinch Penny in burgundy) I’ve ordered in the past 3 weeks from 2 different retailers. Dye was very splotchy over several areas on both shoes - each blotch was the size of a postage stamp (see pictures). Have worn Cole Hahn’s for over 20 years. The quality seems to be going down as the production was moved from the US to Mexico and now to India. I’m moving on to another brand of shoe. Not sure which brand but definitely NOT Cole Haan. Do yourself a favor and move on to another brand as well.

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, November 26, 2019

10 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Ordered my third pair of Cole Haan Pinch penny shoes. They are very good looking and well made. Zappos is an excellent company and I'm glad I found them. Their return policy and service is the best in the web based industry.

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, December 22, 2010

5 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Awesome quality and even better customer service. Zappos have found a life long shopper. I am extremely difficult to please as I have a very discriminating taste and Zappos meets and exceeds all expectations. I can not say enough superlatives to express the total quality satisfaction with Zappos. Do yourself a favor and give them a try!\r\n\r\nRegards,\r\n\r\nOne very satisfied customer

Also recommend

Mezlan

Leonard W, Zappos Customer, August 5, 2009

5 Found this review helpful.

Overall

Comfort

Style

Verified Purchase

Outstanding Value, Fit, and Style - My first order from Zappos.com, the Cole Haan Pinch Penny was a resounding success. I frequently order shoes online since I wear a size 15. My previous experiences have been plagued with long waits, out of stock items, and poor customer service... until I found Zappos.com. The ordering process was simple and straightforward with a confirmation email immediately following the sale. The price was competitive and the order was received NEXT DAY! Simply remarkable. The shoes were factory fresh, appearing as if they had just come off the line. The fit was what I expected, perhaps a fraction longer at the back, and the medium width felt like a generous medium for my E feet. I was glad I decided against a wider size. The penny slot is not sewn over so you can indeed place a coin there if you are into the tradition. I am a wedding DJ so I place a silver sixpence there and present it to the bride as a gift on her wedding day. "Something Old, Something New, Something Borrowed, Something Blue, And A Silver Sixpence In Her Shoe." The last line, often forgotten, is immediately recalled when the sixpence is presented (and my shoes noticed and complimented when I retrieve it!). Zappos.com has won a lifelong customer.

Also recommend

Nunn Bush

Ken W, Zappos Customer, December 14, 2008

4 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Read Additional 169 Customer Reviews

Customer Photos and Videos

Sort by:

Overall

Comfort

Style

Also recommend

don't know

Richard R, Zappos Customer, May 25, 2011

23 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Verified Purchase

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, November 26, 2019

10 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, December 22, 2010

5 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Also recommend

Mezlan

Leonard W, Zappos Customer, August 5, 2009

5 Found this review helpful.

Overall

Comfort

Style

Verified Purchase

Also recommend

Nunn Bush

Ken W, Zappos Customer, December 14, 2008

4 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Read Additional 169 Customer Reviews

Cole Haan
Pinch Penny
Men's

Customer Questions

Show how you wore it!

Reviews

Customers Say

Customer Photos and Videos

Free Shipping and Free Returns

About Zappos

Customer Service

Resources

Explore Zappos

Free Shipping and Free Returns

Show how you wore it!

Customer Questions

Reviews

Customers Say

Customer Photos and Videos

Cole HaanPinch PennyMen's

Product Information

Size Chart

Customer Questions

Show how you wore it!

Reviews

Customers Say

Customer Photos and Videos

Free Shipping and Free Returns

Free Shipping and Free Returns

Show how you wore it!

Customer Questions

Reviews

Customers Say

Customer Photos and Videos

Cole Haan
Pinch Penny
Men's