Thomas & Vine

This is a nice looking shoe but the sizes (I tried three!) run large.

Wish this came in a truer size or larger size so I didn't have to return them

The dark brown strip that holds the stitching around the bottom, the one on the top - IS STICKY! Like, sticky tape, glue sticky. Not just a little, significantly, and on both shoes. That strip will collect every piece of dirt, cat hair, mud whatever. I have no idea what that was all about. I returned the shoes

Really nice looking shoe. But impossible to get my foot in, even with the shoehorn, without undoing the top buckle. Maybe I was hoping for too much, but beware.

The first pair I ordered was 1/2 size too large. Zappos has the best return policy of any company. I returned the large size and got the next half size smaller. I never saw a pair of Mens Wingtip shoes with a woven mid section. I thought they looked good in the picture. I have had many compliments. I never got a compliment with shoes before. Thank you.

these fit small, but the leather may have some give over time

This is my 3rd pair of Thomas & Vine. I wear either a 12m or 12w. In this case I ordered a 12m. The shoe is incredibly tight. Sending them back after 30minutes on my foot.

They actually look better in person, which is a good sign. Recently ordered these & have worn them twice. Just to 'cut to the chase' I'm already ordering exact shoe in a different color !

Love the look of these but the soles separated from the shoe the very first time worn. It’s too bad because I liked the look.

I'm sorry to say I don't recommend these. They look great but they are not comfortable to walk in. They look like plastic even though they are leather. They're just a bit of a disappointment. I hope others have a better opinion of them than I do. Live and learn. Oh well.

These boots fit me pretty well, not perfectly but I have weird feet (extra wide and high arches)...I think once they're fully broken in they'll be pretty comfortable. I really like the look of them and shipping was fast.

Comfortable right out of the box. My go to for work. I get compliments every time I wear them.

These feel like very cheap boots -- the sole is not actually hard rubber, feels spongey and insubstantial. Overall they feel like someone made something that looks good in a photo, but they're cheap and won't last. I'm sending my pair back.

they were quite worn--they were returned and were scuffed

Wear dress shoes daily for work; usually Johnston & Murphy. Wore these one day which led to a massive heal blister that led to raw skin. Will go back to Johnston & Murphy dress shoes.

They fit great and are very comfortable The zipper on the right one has issue about half way up and the pull tab is broken already after about a week

Sizing really depends on brand and model. I where a 9.5 in my current dress shoes, but these ran a 1/2 size bigger. I bought a 9.5 but exchanged for a 9. Fits good, feels comfortable as far as dress shoes go. Zappos exchange/return policy is great!!! It make shopping here easy, even if you are not sure what may or may not work.

they fit great - comfortable - I really like them the right one has a zipper issue at the bend-I have broken the pull tab after one week of wear, I tried inside and lubed it has a bad bend in the zipper?

Looks great BUT is incredibly uncomfortable. My husband has slim feet narrow width and the shoes rubbed the top of his feet AND the heel was low and rubbed midway on his heel. The shoe size is correct, the fit was off. Unfortunately, did not notice until worn for the day. Worse part was the shoe still hurt his feet when he tried again knowing he’d be sitting in a car all day. Oh well, too bad because they look great! Would not recommend.

Good looking shoe. However, once I started walking in them it was a terrible shoe. The heel/sole made you walk with a flop of your shoe. Would NOT buy again.

The shoes don’t look as pictured . So I returned them.

The shoe has a comfortable cushioned insole. The leather was a bit rigid but the style was just what I wanted. Unfortunately, the shoe come damaged.

It’s a good shoe but definitely take the time to break it in before doing any long days in them. They start out a little stiff and the cushion is also very stiff but after a few hours here and a few hours there they feel so much better. I’m a professional wedding photographer and spend a lot of time in good looking but uncomfortable shoes just to look nice so if I can chase a couple for 10 hours in these they must be pretty decent. Overall they look great but I could totally go for something another level higher in comfort which would make for a 5 star shoe.

It’s a good shoe. Definitely spend a day in them and let them naturally break in as they start a little stiff and it definitely begins to fit your feet. I’m a wedding photographer and spend way too many hours on my feet chasing happy couples and I’m always in need of a semi comfortable but looking shoe and this fits the bill so far.

Unfortunately, my son found these shoes very uncomfortable