Overall I really like the shoes. When the shoes arrived however they had obviously been worn previously. There was significant scuffing on the soles and some minor blemishes on the sides. Initially I was going to return them but decided that, given the price, I would keep them. I like the style of Magnanni shoes and will buy them again.
Zappos Reviewer on March 15, 2019
These are really nice. You can see and feel the quality, and they (red) go with everything. I really like the dark “patina” that gives them such a rich and distinct look. Magnanni is new to me, but I’ll definitely keep my eye on them. One unfortunate note is they didn’t have a size 12, so I went with 11.5 (based on other reviewers remark), and I would appreciate more room, but I expect they will stretch or I may have them stretched a bit. That said, they’re still comfortable.
Keith from Minneapolis on March 11, 2019
This shoes are amazing. Definitely can tell that this a $400+ shoe; received a lot of complements. I normally wear a size 10 in sneakers and 9.5 in dress shoes and the 9.5 fit perfectly. No puckering around the collar of the shoes and minimal ceasing after 6 hrs of wear/driving.
Skipp from Baltimore, MD on March 10, 2019
Well made stylish sport shoe
Zappos Reviewer on February 22, 2019
Beautiful shoe, however too long of a toe as is current design trend. Not my style to wear jester shoes. Returned for more traditional style and better fit.
Scott on February 18, 2019
Very nice clean elegant shoe
Zappos Reviewer on February 16, 2019
i have the Lorenzo model, very happy with it, and used it to compare with the Peyton model. Sole, support and padding, i was not so pleased with peyton. the Fairfax just came back in stock for my size, ordered it, and it looks like it has better, thicker sole.
Zappos Reviewer from New York on February 16, 2019
I purchased a pair of Magnanni Men's Patton grey boots in size 12 M from Zappos on on November 23rd 2018 for $398 for my boyfriend, as a holiday gift. Up until this weekend we were very impressed with the style and quality of these boots. Yesterday, on Sunday February 11th 2019, we were shocked to see that the sole of 1 of the shoes has completely disconnected and fallen off!! How can this be possible with shoes that are less than 3 months old??? I purposely paid more for quality boots. $400 is quite a lot for boots, in my opinion, and I expected a quality product that would last for several years, not something that would literally fall apart within months. I am severely disappointed. It seems the sole is only attached with teeny tiny little nails that just fell out. Additionally, the shoe laces are in shreds. What a total waste of $400 :( Also every time I try to attach pictures to this review, Zappos gives me an error message.
Natalee from Philadelphia on February 11, 2019
Beautiful shoe but returned due to small size.
Zappos Reviewer on February 10, 2019
Way to big for me. I already compensate by ordering size 8 M for Oxfords Magnanni. Rather often a size 7.5M is better for me. Their styles are gorgeous but the ill fitting is a malady. I returned the item. There was no other way for me. They were already big brand new so after broken in they would have been even bigger. Perhaps next time.
PERNJO from PHILADELPHIA PA on February 09, 2019
Beautiful shoe; supple leather with sturdy construction.
Zappos Reviewer on February 05, 2019
Like all of my Magnannis, this are beautiful, stylish, pimpping!!!! Complements and more complements. The four stars is about the sizing. I have learned to correct with Magnanni sizes but at times find the slightest size bigger than expected. I am a true 8.5 M in everything else so for Magnanni Oxfords I have to order 8M and even 7.5M depending style some fit too long in front. For monk straps I have to order 8M. This pair is Ok but I wish it was a dash smaller (7.75M????) . I have learned to live with it. I love my shoes!!!
Pete from Philadelphia PA on January 28, 2019
The shoe fits like a slipper and is an everyday shoe!
Zappos Reviewer on January 25, 2019
Make sure that you purchase a half size smaller than your normal size. These shoes are my forever shoes. A timeless classic!
Mike from Apex on January 23, 2019
Perfect quality. Good shoes don’t have to be “broken in”. I love these and this brand is consistent. Worth every cent!
Zappos Reviewer on January 16, 2019
Love it, it is a lovely product.
Zappos Reviewer on January 13, 2019
Love the look and feel of these shoes. Looks good with dress pants or jeans. I wear them at work 8 plus hours at a time. Very comfortable. Buy it. You won’t regret it.
Levan on January 13, 2019
The shoes look very nice but they are way too small. The build quality seems nice and I wish they fit because the styling is sharp.
Paul from Raleigh, NC on January 11, 2019
Zappos Reviewer on January 03, 2019
Fit was absolutely terrible. Unwearable! The leather is extremely stiff. Not sure what to do to repair the issue.
Zappos Reviewer on December 28, 2018
Amazing. Great price too.
Zappos Reviewer on December 27, 2018
Beautiful. Bought a half size down and wearing with thicker wool socks. If wearing dress socks i would have purchased a full size down
Zappos Reviewer on December 18, 2018
I LOVE THIS STYLE, IT IS A PERFECT FIT. MY FEET ARE VERY COMFORTABLE IN THESE SHOES.LIKE WALKING AIR.
BOBBY from COPPERAS COVE on December 18, 2018
They look good and fit well, but they make a loud popping sound when walking. When I take a step the leather around my toes bends, and then when I remove the pressure to take another step, the leather unbends and makes a loud popping sound. It's really annoying and I'm really disappointed with these shoes because they're weirdly loud. I had Ferragamo loafers before this and never had this problem. I liked the look of these shoes, but they ended up being a bad purchase.
Zappos Reviewer on December 11, 2018
These boots look and fit fantastic. I order these boots a half size smaller like recommended. Just for comparison I’m a size 9 in Frye boots and ordered a 8.5 with these Magnanni boots and they fit perfect.
Zappos Reviewer on November 28, 2018