Got a pair for cheap and won't buy a different boot again. Only need a new pair after 2 years because I started wearing them to do concrete and leather doesn't hold up to concrete. Normally wear a 10 EE but 10 1/2 D fit much better than any Ariats I've had.
Zappos Reviewer on January 19, 2019
super hard to get your foot into - had to return - i have a medium width foot but higher arch - don't even try these if you have a higher arch!
Zappos Reviewer on January 17, 2019
I’m updating from a similar Justin Gypsy boot, but this pair didn’t quite fit correctly. They felt oddly slippy on the left. They are also a little more snub nosed in the front; I was wanting more square. My current pair of Gypsies are several years old, so I believe these to be a good buy usually. (I am keeping a different model that came with this order.)
Zappos Reviewer on January 16, 2019
Ordered a 13D, which is way I generally wear, but had to return them. The length was perfect and they fit in the toes, but the heel and shaft were way too wide - I could literally shake the boots off my feet.
Zappos Reviewer from Steamboat Springs, CO on January 16, 2019
Bought for my grandson. He loves them!. They will work well for this season, but his foot is still growing so bigger size next year.
Zappos Reviewer on January 13, 2019
I wear a 10 in athletic shoes and a 9.5 in dressier shoes I wasn't quite sure what to order these in so I ordered them in a 10 and they were perfect. I find them to be comfortable it did take a little bit to break them in and kept my feet nice and dry after spending some time sloshing around in the muck and mud.Great boots.
Zappos Reviewer on January 12, 2019
These were my first ever pair of boots and since I have big calves, a wide foot, and a high instep, I was worried these wouldn’t work out! They totally did!!! I wore them to a rodeo/concert and was on my feet for 7 hours without having broken them in yet and they were fantastic!!! :) I only wish there were other color options so I could get a second pair.
Zappos Reviewer on January 08, 2019
Did not have any chemical smell at all in the pair I received. Simple design. Nice snip toe. Floral Rubber sole, box says. Vert comfortable.
DWA20 on January 07, 2019
First time purchasing boots. I normally wear a size 10, but had read that going a half size smaller on boots was recommended. So that's what I did and the fit was perfect -- snug but not tight. Very comfortable even after several hours of wear. Could use some more arch support but I suppose that's probably the case with most western boots. Really like the style and the quality is very nice. The leather and construction look great. Very happy with this purchase.
Chris from KY on January 05, 2019
I ordered the Justin Elina in Redstone size 10. It is a beautiful boot, sturdy and well made and I was looking for a red western boot with a walking heel (under 2”). It does look long as most pointed toe western boots do especially on anyone with a long foot but, realistically, who can use that 3” pointy width at the end anyway? My foot problem was that it doesn’t come wider than a medium therefore it was too tight at the bunion joint and I am at the age that I now put comfort over “style.” So I am probably going to go with the Durango Red boot with the narrow wide/square toe which may not look as much as a traditional western style, but more comfortable. The shaft is 2” shorter and the leather much softer and the boot is more cushiony that this boot with its rubber sole. Plus it has the lower heel I am looking for.
Debbie from Tucson, AZ on January 03, 2019
Love these! The style is just what I was wanting. I'm glad I ordered a 1/2 size larger than usual. My regular size would have been too small and tight.
RP from Denver on January 02, 2019
I get a pair of Justin’s every year. I wear steel toe to work 50-60 hrs /week and they have to be comfortable! I haven’t found another brand of slip on work boots that give my toes enough room to move. And they are SO cute:)
Lauren from San Francisco on December 31, 2018
The shaft was somewhat soft, however I could not get my foot into the boot to tell if it was supportive. I ordered my regular shoe size 8.5 along with the Ariat Fatbaby. The Ariat fit better but looked huge on my feet. I returned both pairs in hopes of later finding exactly what I want.
Zappos Reviewer on December 29, 2018
Boot fits well and love the color. Not the most comfortable boot in the world but overall happy.
Chad from N Charleston sc. on December 25, 2018
I was skeptical to order as I read a review that they were stiff and rubbed. I have complicated feet with a very high arch and a bone that protrudes on top of foot. I have owned very few boots I could go straight into wearing them all day. And driving an hour into town and hour back sometimes hurts my protruding bone on top of foot. These boots were comfy enough and soft enough on the foot to wear all day straight out of the box! I love the distress look. Great boots! I would order again in a heartbeat!!
Amy from Augusta, MT on December 23, 2018
They are what they are... pull on boot, semi Western style, walking heels, all leather. Require a little break in, then quite comfortable, expected to continue being more comfortable as time and wear go on.
Zappos Reviewer on December 20, 2018
Fit really good and comfortable. Style was great.
Chad from N Charleston on December 20, 2018
I normally wear size 7 but as recommended I chose size 6.5. It fits beautifully. The circumference of the top of the boot is just right, after trying too many boots that were made to fit an elephants leg!!! Lucky me, at age 74 my legs are still slender and shapely,lol! I love my Justin’s and will be getting the black as soon as they are back in stock. Thanks ZAPPOS for the great service! Jane and her wacky sidekick Lola, the Boston TerriJane
Jane from Willimantic, CT on December 16, 2018
Feels comfortable the first time I wear it, soft leather and light. I like it. I just bought the black.
Joey on December 12, 2018
The first couple of times I put these on, it was a bit of a squeeze to get my foot in, but they fit great, and the toe box is roomy and comfortable. i'm surprised how much I like the look of these shoes--initially, I thought they looked a bit Herman Munsterish. Not so.
Joe from Solana Beach on December 12, 2018
These were cute boots but not quite what I was looking for.
Zappos Reviewer on December 08, 2018
Love them.. just what I wanted
Zappos Reviewer on December 06, 2018
I'm normally a size 5- 5 1/2 wide. But, no one seems to make cute boots anymore for wide feet. I ordered the 6 as I typically do. One foot was slightly tight. But, they stretched out some the first time wearing them. Got some compliments on how cute they were also. I've been buying/ wearing Justin boots for many years and are my go to boot company!
Shannon from Tampa Bay on December 04, 2018
The boot fit perfectly. Spent two hours walking around the mall in total comfort. A very good looking comfortable fit.
Zappos Reviewer on December 04, 2018
This is the third time I’ve bought this exact pair of boots. No other boots last as long as Justin’s do at my job. Plus I always keep a pair for casual wear that replace the work boots when it’s time. Got 2 and a half years out of my first pair. Longest I’ve got out of any other brand was about 6 months
Zappos Reviewer on December 03, 2018