ordered these in a 10.5 wide. Couldn’t get my foot in them. These run extremely narrow. At a wide I shoulda been able to get on. They are however really cute boots and seemed to be well made. Will have to return simply because I couldn’t get them on.
Zappos Reviewer on July 31, 2021
The shoes were nice looking but a full size too big. Unfortunately I returned them and found another shoe on Zappos.
Brenda from Conway on May 16, 2021
My husband loves these boots and was happy to find them in his size. He wore a version of these years ago and remembered how good they felt. I believe these will be the same way.
Zappos Reviewer from Saint Joe on April 05, 2021
Something terribly wrong with this boot. Some part of leather is deformed and the fold causes painful blister across top of metatarsals.
Justin from pleasant hill on March 12, 2021
Justin’s never let me down
Zappos Reviewer from Fort Lauderdale, FL on February 27, 2021
I have return this item , but I have not get my money banck
Ileana from Houston on December 30, 2020
I have a wide foot and a high instep. Loved the boots but could not get them on. No fault of the boot.
Ron on September 17, 2020
Really cute, super light. The ‘foam’ sole was not my style. Thus the 4-star. Needed something more functional. These are great fashion cowboy boots though. Very easy on and off. Chocolate brown is very pretty.
Zappos Reviewer on May 21, 2020
These look better than the pictures.
Zappos Reviewer on May 18, 2020
I loved these shoe but couldn't get my foot into the shoe. I know I have a wide foot so not blaming the shoe. I was disappointed they didn't fit. I wish they made the shoe in a wider size.
Nedra from CA on May 07, 2020
I LOVE these boots. I’ve ordered and returned more than a dozen pairs trying to find the perfect cowboy boots while stuck at home. These are perfect. So comfortable and more traction that I expected. And they are simply gorgeous!! Note on sizing: I wear an 8 in everything except pull-on boots, when I wear a 7.5 or 7. (Something about having narrow feet.). So I ordered these in a 7, and they fit perfectly.
Zappos Reviewer on April 18, 2020
Very comfortable shoe. Ordered 9 1/2 because it does run a half size large. But I am not wearing socks with these shoes. They are quick to throw on to walk the dog. Love them.
Zappos Reviewer on April 08, 2020
This is a great looking boot, unfortunately, I could not even get it over my arch and I don't have a high arch and I have M width feet. I'll be returning them but have no way of knowing whether they fit in length or width, just that I couldn't get the boot past my arch. I don't know if they're comfortable since I couldn't get it on.
Zappos Reviewer on March 08, 2020
My first pair of cowboy boots and they are DIVINE. I was unsure of fit, so I ordered my true size and they are perfect. There is a little room, but you need that to slip them on and off. Call me weird, but I love to breathe in the authentic leather smell. I haven’t worn these yet but at first try-on they seem to be vertical comfortable. I ordered a different brand for comparison and the quality of these was above and beyond the other. So glad I ordered these!
Zappos Reviewer on February 16, 2020
boots looked and felt great. leather had strong odor and product made with toxic substance.
Zappos Reviewer on February 11, 2020
I guess I'll be the first to review this shoe. I just got them an hour ago and Im wearing them around the house, not sure if I will keep them. They run a half size small, I usually wear 9.5 in shoes these are a 10 and they fit fine, they are cushioned and comfortable, a cross between a moccasin and sneaker. I thought they were cute because they are different looking, problem is they make my feet look big.
Zappos Reviewer on February 05, 2020
Big disappointment. My street shoe size is 9 medium. I ordered these in 10.5 wide and they were too tight; I could barley get them off after a night of dancing. I can't return them because it was my second purchase (first boots were 9.5 wide, too tight to get on) and was told I would not get a refund for the second pair after the exchange. Justin boots used to fit me so comfortably. I am stuck with a $130 pair of boots.
Zappos Reviewer on February 04, 2020
I had read reviews that said that these run large. I'm a pretty solid 7, but can at times go up/down 1/2 size, so I ordered a 6.5. This was too small. A 7 would have fit perfectly. They were very stiff, I think it would take time to break them in and they probably wouldn't have been "all day" boots for me, but I'm on my feet a fair share. They were very cute. And the dark is definitely a dark green with a bluish (not olive) tint.
Zappos Reviewer on January 29, 2020
The leather is soft and shines well, nice workmanship. nice looking heels and soles.
James on January 23, 2020
My first--but not going to be my last--women's cowboy boots. Extremely comfortable. Orderd up a half size. Perfect fit and comfort since day 1. Very happy with my Justine Callimero selection!
Kathleen from Galesburg MI on January 08, 2020
Love love these boots! They are my second pair from the Gypsy line. I initially bought my old boots in size 11 but had to return them for a 10 because they were much too large. I normally wear a 10-1/2 (when I can find it) or 11. So I went down a full size for those to fit my feet properly. When buying these boots I decided to order the size 10 first because of my past experience, and I'm glad I did because they fit really well. They're a little narrower across the ball of the foot than the other boots but they are not too tight. (My old pair is probably a bit too wide because I have a relatively narrow feet.) All in all, these boots fit better than my old pair does. I really like the way they feel on my feet. I wore them all day today for the first time and they're very comfortable. Kudos to Justin for improving on their proportions in the sizing. Love the look of these with the 2 tone. They uppers are not black, they are dark green. Justin calls it teal, according to the packaging, but looks more green than blue to me.
Margaret from Portland OR on January 07, 2020
These are too cute, unfortunately they were not comfortable around my ankles. Also, information shows heels are 1 1/2”...they are 3”. Too high which is what they appear in photos. But I was being hopeful.
Zappos Reviewer on January 01, 2020
These boots appear to be well made of good quality materials. They run slightly large, but are about 1/16 shorter in the toe than the last ones I bought.
Dr. from Amelia Island, FL on December 12, 2019
I was surprised at how much I liked these. The stitching on the side is nice and they are really really comfortable. I have wide feet and need the room in the toe.
Zappos Reviewer on December 08, 2019
They were comfortable the first time I put them on.A little stiff but that's because they were brand new.now a week later they slide on and off with ease and man do they feel good! You most definitely have a return customer.
John from Detroit Mi on December 04, 2019