Based on others' reviews, I ordered a half-size down. Mistake! I returned them, and waited for my regular size to come back in stock. It did! They fit fine. I am normally a size 8, and in these shoes I am also a size 8.
Zappos Reviewer from New York, NY on November 17, 2018
Based on other reviews I ordered a half size smaller than my usual size. The shoes fit in the length but were too narrow! I think my regular size plus an orthotic would have been the better bet. However, they are not stocked in my size (8), so I will never know. Sending back the 7-1/2. Other reviewers said the shoes stretched over the course of the day, but I never find that to be the case. If they feel too small when I try them on, they feel much worse after I've been wearing them for a couple of hours!
Zappos Reviewer from New York on November 14, 2018
These were a bit more narrow than I thought, so unfortunately returning. They cut into my pinky toes a bit too much for my liking. Love the style and price though, if you have narrow feet and are on a budget, this could be a great shoe for you!
Zappos Reviewer on November 13, 2018
These are beautiful boots, but I implore you to order a FULL size up, not a half size. I ordered both, and the half-up still crunched my toes. The larger ones fit great and are very comfortable.
Zappos Reviewer on November 10, 2018
I have been in a long search for a beautiful cognac leather bootie. The search is finally over. These are buttery soft and beautiful color. They do run a half size bigger. I’m normally a 61/2 the 6 fit perfectly. If I had a complaint it would be the heel height. I wish they were a little lower.
Zappos Reviewer on November 10, 2018
I love these! I was in the hunt for a pair of booties that would go with a lot but weren’t black and these are perfect. They definitely run a half size big so I did size down. They also felt a little narrow when I first had them on, but by the end of the day they had already broken in and felt great!
Amanda from Portland, ME on November 08, 2018
Ordered these in size 10. I have a narrow foot, but the toe is very pointy, and makes my feet look longer than they are. They feel a bit tight in the toebox. I ordered the Pikalinos and I like the fit and look much better. Returning these.
Shel29 from Brooklyn, NY on November 06, 2018
Sorry Zappos I want to love these but my feet had suffered enough. I'm afraid taking one step outside in these would damage my feet. They were tight in the toe box and the sole is made of a hard material which doesn't allow the feet to bend. Here I go, back to the drawing board.
Zappos Reviewer on November 06, 2018
I love these boots! I am ordering them in brown too!
Zappos Reviewer on October 30, 2018
The leather on the upper was not the same color as the leather on the toe. The style felt a bit frumpy.
Zappos Reviewer on October 27, 2018
I purchased a size bigger than I needed to allow for thick socks so it feels a bit large. The boot is so comfortable, the leather is beautiful and soft around the feet. I love the laces which add a beautiful classy touch to the style. It works with most things and the color is just as in the photo. The perfect flat boot which adds class to any outfit. I love it so much!!
Kiki from West orange on October 20, 2018
LOVE!! These shoes have a low heel and a lot of attitude. I can wear them all night long with no discomfort. I would buy these in every single color Zappos offered! Love!
Megan from New Orleans on October 16, 2018
Nice pointy toe, but shoes were way too snug in the toe box area. I wish a wide width option was available, if I went a half is larger I would slip right out of them.
Zappos Reviewer on October 16, 2018
Real nice leather,,, very soft! The booties are really sharp!, but... they are extremely tight at the point. So if you have wide feet- these will not work. Unfortunately I have to return them despite how nice they look.
Zappos Reviewer on October 15, 2018
They look better in picture. Barely wear them, they are a bit too snugged and I have a very thin foot.
Zappos Reviewer on October 13, 2018
I have narrow feet, and my middle toe is longer than my big toe, so pointy toed shoes are generally quite comfortable. These are very comfortable, if you have narrow feet. They have minimal cushioning, and no arch support, but they are fine in an office or professional setting. I would not mind walking a mile or two in these shoes, but I would not want to walk farther than that. I purchased in black and in brown and love both. The brown leather shows water spots very readily- I treated mine with a water repellent spray to prevent this. The color darkened very slightly from the spray treatment but it now does not change color at all when it gets wet.
T. from Sacramento, CA on October 12, 2018
These are beautiful boots. I wanted them to fit so badly. My foot is somewhat wider, but I decided to try them. No luck.
CLB from St Louis on October 08, 2018
These boots are beautiful, buttery soft leather. They were reasonably comfortable given the heel height (I have plantar fasciatis, so I generally stay under 2.5 inches). I didn't keep them because the other pair I ordered were a bit more comfy.
Zappos Reviewer on October 06, 2018
These boots are beautiful. The leather on these boots is buttery soft, and break in and stretch very quickly. The boots run big and I had to return for a half-size smaller. The width is a little tight for my slightly wide foot, but I'd say the width is average. The heel height is perfect--not too tall, comfortable to walk in.
Zappos Reviewer on October 05, 2018
Really like this boot. They’re going to go with so many outfits.
Zappos Reviewer on October 04, 2018
When I first put these on, the pointy toe was far too severe for me. But after just a few minutes i really started to like them! The insole is very well padded, they're a nice soft leather and very comfortable. I love a good mary jane, and this is a fun twist on the shoe. They do run VERY small. I had to return twice for a larger size and ended up 1-1.5 full sizes larger than i usually wear. I've worn them for two full days now with no discomfort.
Zappos Reviewer from San Francisco Bay Area on October 03, 2018
One of the best pair of shoes I’ve bought in a long time. They match so many things, and they are so comfortable.
Zappos Reviewer on September 29, 2018
Excellent shoe for work. Dressy and comfortable!
Zappos Reviewer on September 16, 2018
really lovely shoe, not really any support, but lovely soft, snuggly leather and pretty ballet flat. But it runs really small. I almost always take an 8--in disbelief I only ordered an 8 1/2 on my second try, and realized when I tried that one on that my toes were still jammed. The 9 fits just right.
Dana from Nashville on September 11, 2018
I ordered an 8 in these (my normal size), but the box, despite being marked as 8, contained a pair of 7.5s. They were way way too small-- could not even get my foot in. I'm going to try to exchange them for a 9 and maybe that will be big enough. I have very narrow feet and they seem quite narrow. The leather seems very soft, so I am optimistic.
Zappos Reviewer on September 09, 2018