They were at least a half size too large if not more. I really can't answer as to comfort since I'm returning them, but Zappos insists I rate them so I did.
Zappos Reviewer on July 13, 2020
These shoes fit like a DREAM. I’m a teacher and I wear them all day teaching and feel great. My only request is that the heel was higher. I feel like these would be a 12/10 if they had a chunky heel.
Zappos Reviewer on July 12, 2020
I'd like these shoes if they weren't slipping off. I'll try a smaller size.
Zappos Reviewer on July 10, 2020
I loved these shoes when I first got them. So comfortable out of the box! However, after less than 6 months of light/medium wear, the sole is already almost completely torn/unglued from the upper. Extremely disappointing quality.
Julie from Pittsburgh on July 10, 2020
I love them! They fit perfectly. The second I put them on I knew I was keeping them. There is plenty of room in the toe box (no squishing), there is no toe cleavage (I hate toe cleavage!!), and I have zero complaints about them. I am a true 8.5 medium width, and that's what I ordered. They are not super fancy, or expensive (got them on sale). They are no frills, cute, comfortable ballet flats that don't do anything weird or annoying, and I'm very happy with them.
Jade from Bay Area, CA on July 10, 2020
These are so comfortable and cute! I want to get a pair in every color now.
Zappos Reviewer on July 05, 2020
Dr Scholls used to be comfortable! There are so stretch at all to the strap over the forefoot. The footbed was slightly padded but that was it. It feels like a cheap shoe and I am just done with this brand. If you have no foot problems this may be an option for you. I have a neuropathy so a little give and padding is a must for me. These are going back, sad.
Zappos Reviewer on July 03, 2020
Wore these once and had to return they cut my ankles so badly
Danielle from CT on July 02, 2020
Really cute and super comfortable. They definitely need some breaking in around the ankle and over the toe. I stand for 8 hours at work and I can wear these all day! I bought them in black and I’m getting the brown too! Perfect price point for amazing quality.
Zappos Reviewer on July 01, 2020
Comfortable and pretty. I wish it was a little less bulky - esp since I’m a size 11, but overall great brand and value for what I paid for (got it on sale).
Ana on June 29, 2020
The perfect shoe! The gray color is neutral and the heel height is just right. They are very light and soooo comfortable right out of the box. Highly recommend!!
Zappos Reviewer on June 28, 2020
Cute boots, but I ended up going with a pair of Frye combat boots that were a little more stylish and feminine and the same price (on sale). These are definitely comfortable, and the insole is removable so I suspect you could easily fit an orthotic in it. Like I said, cute, but after seeing the Frye pair these went back.
Melle from NYC on June 28, 2020
These are very comfortable shoes. Unfortunately, they are too wide. Luckily my mom has a bunion and they fit her and she is very happy in then.
NAC from New Jersey on June 26, 2020
Love these! Fit like a glove right out of the box. Wore them all day and night and the next day! Perfect!
Zappos Reviewer on June 26, 2020
Sadly, the buckles hit me on the ankles. Ouch!
Kimbee on June 25, 2020
The shoe was damaged when it arrived. Saddened me greatly bc I bought this one and another pair for work bc this brand is amazingly comfortable.
Zappos Reviewer on June 24, 2020
These are so cute! I cannot wait to wear them this Summer. I ordered my regular size, but returned them for a full size smaller.
Pam from Parkville on June 24, 2020
It is too heavy
Sardar from Downers Grove on June 20, 2020
Blisters beware. They are quite stiff in the back and took a while to soften up. Slightly narrow through the toe but they are comfortable enough with a thin sock. Very cute shoe. Love the style.
Zappos Reviewer on June 20, 2020
These are very comfortable and very stylish, I love them! But I had to return them for a smaller size. Get them, but buy a smaller size, You won't be disappointed!
Zappos Reviewer on June 19, 2020
I need a 9 1/2...just hoped the 10 would fit. This is a beautiful shoe...I wish it fit!
Barbara on June 17, 2020
I have a relatively narrow foot and the medium proved to be too wide. The shoe wouldn't stay on my foot.
Zappos Reviewer on June 16, 2020
The soles of these shoes are super comfy. Like wearing a pair of soft, contoured, ultra-light running shoes.
GO on June 16, 2020
Unfortunately very uncomfortable and was surprised because I thought they were made for people who needed extra feet love as I have flat feet. Too tight on the pinky toe, the ankle design was too constraining on the heel. Very sad I had to return
Zappos Reviewer on June 16, 2020
The sole of this shoe is so thick, stiff and flat that the heel comes off with every step. There is no give to the sole and I had blisters within an hour. I tried several times to wear them for short periods to break them in and also bending the sole with my hand but nothing worked. Since I wore them outside I did not return them. Waste of money.
Zappos Reviewer on June 15, 2020