6" Waterproof Composite Toe CA3536 & CA3537
6" Waterproof Composite Toe CA3536 & CA3537
6" Waterproof Composite Toe CA3536 & CA3537
Foreman Engineer Steel Toe CA3522
8" Waterproof Composite Toe Logger CA1435
Elm Logger CA825
28 Series Waterproof CA8028
Foreman Waterproof CA3026
Elm Waterproof Plain Toe Logger ST CA9821
Foreman Waterproof Steel Toe CA3526
Elm 8" Waterproof Plain Toe Logger CA435
8" Waterproof Composite Toe Logger CA9852
6" Waterproof Carbon Composite Toe Hiker CA5525
I'm only giving these 4 stars, but I did just order my second pair. I'm 5'9 185 - standard tree guy size. I wear a 10.5 regular width for everything - boots, running shoes, air force 1s - everything, and these were a perfect fit. I took a star away because they chew through laces. Something about the eye lids just roughs up the laces and eventually, when tightening the laces it'll just snap the lace. So keep extra on hand. This was my first pair of Carolinas so maybe it was that 1 pair, or the way I pull laces..? I don't know, but like I said, I ordered my second pair since the fit is too perfect. They also have great support for me. I can't wear flat soles - my feet will hurt, so I need the loggers. These feel great. The water proofing is spectacular too. I'm in some swamp backyards in PA and my feet stay dry as a bone. These lasted me about 5 months, but I was in them for over 60 hrs a week over 6-7 days for the week, so I feel like 5 months is decent.
Paul from Levittown on June 15, 2020
It was a great fit. Needed to break them in a bit.
Zappos Reviewer on May 10, 2020
These boots are well worth the money. The fit was perfect both size and width. I will buy again.
John from MOSCOW Idaho., on April 17, 2020
Shoes were stiff and a bit on the small size. Very little padding for comfort.
Zappos Reviewer from Michigan on April 14, 2020
Dan from MN on March 21, 2020
Solid pair of boots, still braking in. The true test of a work boot is time though. Nice tight heel. Could use some cushion.
Zappos Reviewer on March 12, 2020
Pretty nice at first ....no real break in period needed ....total junk though these boots lasted 2 months ..hardly worth the investment..unless your super light or / and dont have to work to hard . When put to the test these boots failed.
JEFF from RIVERSIDE COUNTY on March 12, 2020
Sizes were correct had to return because were too big, really good quality though getting same pair different size
Zappos Reviewer on January 06, 2020
I work on my feet and needed a non-slip, water resistant, comfortable boot that could endure hours of movement without wearing down. And, of course, I wanted it to look fashionable too. THIS IS IT. I was worried that the tall heel would take away from their comfort or mobility, since I don't usually wear heels -- but they're not bothersome at all. This are genuine leather, so the boots are pretty tight when you first wear them and take days to properly break-in. They are also very heavy, so prepare for that, and WARM. Your feet will be sweating by day's end, but if you work on your feet, then you're probably used to that anyway. If you're planning on wearing thicker socks or prefer more wiggle room for your feet, buy a them half size up -- these guys are snug. I bought true-to-size, and although my boots are officially broken in, my right foot (aka my naturally larger foot) still has to be pulled and pushed a little harder for entry/exit. Aesthetically they're super cute for a work boot- I get compliments all day about them -and I love that the manufacturer left the top few lace notches as optional, so you decide how you want to lace them up. Overall, I'd highly recommend this pair of boots!
Cara from Austin, TX on December 12, 2019
These were a lot of work to get on the first couple of times, but they are already far more comfortable and supportive than my previous, cheap work boots. I am very happy with them and can only assume I will be even more happy as they break in over the next couple of months.
Zappos Reviewer on December 10, 2019
As a line maintenance worker I was going for the waterproof and comfort aspect of this boot. While not being able to experience the waterproof effectiveness I did however come to realize that after a solid 10 days of use, this pair of boots seem to not be broken in . and still hurts my feet. the level of comfort is not there and I cannot go a year (about the time frame my last pair stood up) in these. Also I have to wear 2 pairs of socks to stop the upper ankle support from rubbing hard against my upper ankle. They have really good grip I could say that.
KB from Atlanta on December 03, 2019
Overall like the feel. I little stiff but should be okay once they get worn in. I wish had more arch support and maybe memory foam insole.
Zappos Reviewer on November 28, 2019
Nice style boots. But not for me. They hurt my feet even when trying an orthotic insert.
Greg from Atlanta, GA on November 16, 2019
I have had Carolina work boots before and they were great. These I just couldnt get used to and they were very uncomfortable.
Zappos Reviewer from South side of Atlanta on November 15, 2019
I was skeptical of other reviews that said these run small. But they are definitely right. I'm normally wear a 9M. Ordered a 9 1/2 M. Could barely squeeze my foot in with moderately thick cotton socks. Back they go! But they are super cute for a work boot. They are also heavy (notice the weight). Understandable since they're a heavy duty work boot, but just be aware of that in case that's a factor in your decision.
Zappos Reviewer on November 15, 2019
These boots are going back. The color of the boot which shows as brown on the site leans very much to the orange side of brown. There is a liner in the shoe that's about 1/8 inch thick and that's all that's available for arch support. It's also described as being made of "Crazy Horse leather". I don't know what that is but these boots have a finish that feels and looks sueded. Composite maybe?
Zappos Reviewer on November 12, 2019
Still breaking them in and getting used to wearing work boots again. These appear to be well made.
Zappos Reviewer from residence on October 31, 2019
These are great boots. Just received and am breaking them in. Put on a couple coats of Frye weatherproof cream. Ordered it from Amazon since I could not find it on Zappos. Actually came from Zappos via Amazon.
David from Hudson NY on October 27, 2019
These shoes were just to narrow and tight on a size 9 and felt uncomfortable to wear
Don from Austin,Texas on October 20, 2019
I had to return it for a half size smaller. I received the replacements and they were fine. great looking boot, very sturdy and waterproof. feels good to work with these boots keeps me dry and protected.
Jerome from Upper Chichester on October 13, 2019
Great fit and material is nice and tough
Zappos Reviewer on October 13, 2019
Ever so slightly tight but after wearing for a few days they are already conforming to my feet. I have not wetted them much yet; I know their first soaking will really help them fit perfectly. They are sturdy and stiff, as they should be, and provide tons of ankle support walking through the woods. So far they are waterproof, but I have not truly challenged them. A good looking work boot!
Timber from Vancouver, WA on October 11, 2019
I wear these boots 5 days a week for about 13 hours n I couldn’t ask for a better fitting comfortable pair of boots! Very satisfied
Joe from Wilmington Ohio on September 26, 2019
These shoes are cute comfortable to wear for 10 minutes and the leather is high quality. Toe box runs wide and is almost comparable to EE width for medium width with order size 9.5 D shoes. They seem a bit short, perhaps the same as a size 9 in Irish Setter. Unfortunately upon delivery, I realize that these shoes do not have arch support and the flat insole is sewn into the shoe. It is not possible to remove the insole and install an orthotic device for arch support. It breaks my heart, given the beautiful soft leather exterior, but this pair is going back to Zappos.
Electrical from Columbia, MD on September 22, 2019
Holy cow! I’ll be buying more of these! In fact, these will replace my on clouds as day to day footwear because they are soooo comfortable. Seriously, I just tried them on and ended up taking a nap in them. I wear an 8 wide in Bella Vita, Naturalizer and Sam Edelman heels with extra cussion under the ball of the foot and at the heels to keep them from slipping off. I ordered these Carolinas in 8.5 wide and they fit with a comfortable snuggness in the toe box with some heel slip over my everyday socks. Just like the experts say boots should fit:) I expect they will expand a bit while I break them in which will be perfect for when I want to wear thicker socks but I will probably need to get a bigger size in a few years. I heard feet never stop growing.
Susan from Cordova K on July 23, 2019