Ouch!I usually wear an 8, but an 8 1/2 was still pinching my toes. Also it was too wide in the heel. This toe is awfully pointed so if you need more toe box steer clear.
Lisa on January 18, 2019
These are gorgeous/timeless, very simple and comfortable boots. I bought and returned 5+ pairs of different boots before buying these. I’m normally a 7.5 but purchased an 8 and they fit perfectly. Love them!
Zappos Reviewer from San Francisco on January 14, 2019
Petite, thin-legged women, these are the boots you need! In all my millions of years of fancy boot buying, I’ve never found such a perfect pair in terms of fit, comfort, and style.
Anne from Sausalito on January 14, 2019
Love the boot! I’m normally a true 7.5 and ordered an 8 which fits like a 7.5. I intend to wear thin socks but if I needed a thicker sock would have had to order a full size up. They are snug on the width but I do expect them to stretch a little bit. I have fairly thin ankles and calves and the shaft fits snugly as well. Overall I would say they fit small and medium to narrow.
Zappos Reviewer on January 12, 2019
Expensive, but quite nice
Zappos Reviewer on January 11, 2019
Lovely, elegant shoes. I needed to order a half size larger than my usual size, but then the fit was perfect. Block heel is super comfortable. I have purchased Aquatalia before and they usually come with a shoe bag. Not sure why this pair from Zappos did not have one.
Zappos Reviewer on January 09, 2019
To say I adore these boots is an understatement. They are beautiful, comfortable, and great for work! The workmanship is exquisite. I will say the calf area is relatively tight, but they fit me perfectly. I will wear these for years.
Kathy from Silver Spring, MD on January 08, 2019
Zappos Reviewer on January 07, 2019
Absolutely beautiful. I have 3-4 pairs of other booties and boots from Aquatalia - all 9.5 - and positively love them. Typically they run narrow in the heel compared to other brands which prevents slip. Worth the price as they are lasting and can be worn in any weather (although I've been cautious weather-wise). These ran big - length and width. I tried them on with a mid-weight wool sock which is thick for this shoe brand as they usually run narrow. Highly recommend the shoe but may need to go down a half size.
Zappos Reviewer on December 30, 2018
Very nice shoe. Well made and very comfortable. I had to go up 1/2 a size though.
Zappos Reviewer on December 29, 2018
Hands down - Aquatila rocks the winter boot selection! This shoe is form fitting, waterproof, the perfect height w a rubber heel AND comfortable throughout. The style is fashion forward for even a city girl. ??.
Zappos Reviewer on December 25, 2018
I've looked and looked for a dressier boot to wear with leggings. I must have purchased and returned 5 other boots. Until this one. Just what I was looking for. I should have gone to Aquatalia first because these boots always work for me. A bit pricey, but the quality is worth it.
Zappos Reviewer on December 16, 2018
Love these ankle boots! Comfortable and stylish. The high quality I expect from all Aquatalia footwear. And they are waterproof!
Brenda from Maine on December 13, 2018
Beautiful boot, pretty comfortable for nice looking boots. My only objection is that the toe is already losing some suede, but that wouldn’t keep me from buying them again. The grey color is really sharp.
Zappos Reviewer on December 12, 2018
The fit is true to size, very comfortable, love these shoes
Zappos Reviewer from San Mateo, CA on December 11, 2018
These boots are beautiful. The suede is a rich black. I have a pair of Aquatalia boots from a few years ago that are size 8 1/2 so I ordered that size first. The foot seemed a little big and I could get the shaft zipped over my calves. So I tried an 8 which felt like the correct size, but was unable to zip it up even though the back of the shaft is elastic. I will just add a footbed to the 81/2 boot and return the 8. If you have slender calves, order your regular size.
Zappos Reviewer on December 06, 2018
You need to size up. I have the exact shoes in a patent pink color. The size 7 pink ones fit and these do not. I wore them for a few hours and they blistered the top of my feet. I am disappointed because typically I am obsessed with this brand!
Zappos Reviewer on November 28, 2018
I wanted to love these boots but the toggle laces don't work for tightening to get that custom fit! Because of this, I had to return.
Zappos Reviewer from ohio on November 27, 2018
Extremely pleased with this bootie. I love that it comes up higher on the leg...great for cropped pants. The heel height is perfect for all day wear. Would highly recommend this bootie. I went up a full size as I wanted to wear this bootie with thick wool socks.
Zappos Reviewer on November 26, 2018
Love this boot! Nice intersection between casual/dressy. Like non-lug sole. Definitely ran a half size too big, so just reordered in smaller size. Hoping it is not going to be too narrow. Interior padding nice, but minimal, no arch support for me. Fingers crossed that the half size down is the winner!
KatherineF from Livermore CA on November 16, 2018
Very cute and very soft, however bad design: very shallow. My heel was coming out of the shoes. I wanted to love them, but they are impossible to wear. I am returning them.
Zappos Reviewer on November 14, 2018
Very chic ... great with black leggings and a long black coat for a walk in the park. sShould have ordered directly through Aquatalia though ... they were 15% off!
Zappos Reviewer on November 11, 2018
Looked really cheap and not comfortable at all
Zappos Reviewer on October 31, 2018
Beautiful shoe, color & quality. Narrow toe box didn’t work for me. Sizing up relieved that but was too large for the rest of my foot and my heel slipped. I was so disappointed to feel the need to return these. Previous purchases of Aquatalias have always served me so well.
Karen from Gig Harbor, Washington on October 29, 2018
Crazy pricey but comfortable. If u have a very very tough time finding comfy boots, this could be for u. I still had to put inner soles in bc I like a very soft landing but with this slight adjustment they were keepers for me!
Zappos Reviewer on October 27, 2018