Customer Reviews Sperry Starfish

What is going on, Sperry? All you do is make and perfect shoes (supposedly). I have worn Sperry's for years with no issues until recently. These are the 2nd pair of shoes that squeak with every step. These I kept because they didn't really start squeaking until I started wearing them out. It's embarrassing. I don't care how cute a shoe is, they should not squeak!

This is my 2nd pair of Sperrys. The 1st pair I loved and still have. They were so comfortable. These I wore for a short period of time and ended up with blisters. I tried putting a heel guard and mole skin adhesive on the inside, but still ended up with blisters the next time I briefly wore them. They don't fit as comfortably as their leather style. So, I'm left without a cute pair of pink shoes just sitting in the closet, unfortunately.

Stiff as a board, very narrow fit, a struggle to get them on.

Disappointed they are running small and were narrow at the tows

I bought these boat shoes because they looked like the old boat shoes I have that are white canvas. But they were gold tweed with gold stripes. Ugh! My old boat shoes are worn and frayed and I still get people, especially young people, ask me where I got my shoes. I would love for Sperry to bring back these classics. I think young and old will buy, buy, buy them. Please!!!!!!!!!!!

Too wide..supposed to be medium width but they were too wide

Very uncomfortable. Feel like plastic not leather. Lumpy sole. Have worn topsiders for years. This is not what I'm used too substandard quality.

These shoes are way too narrow!!! Even the wide sizes are too narrow. It's a shame because they are nice looking shoes.

Bad quality. I got blisters with them in 2 different sides

To help fit this shoe to my narrow feet, in the past w/ this boat shoe I have tightened the rawhide surrounding the shoe. This shoe won't tightened.

I read up on reviews and many said to size up because they tend to be very narrow, so I went a full shoe size up from my usual. When I got them, I could tell by looking they would not work. They were so narrow I only was able to get the balls of my feet in. I did not want to size up too much, because leather will stretch over time and I didn't want them to be too big over time. Immediately returned. Disappointed, Sperry needs to make leather a little more pliable and forgiving, and make the standard shoe wider than a store-bought baguette.

The product came in a very damaged boxes and the stitching is already coming undone after only wearing them twice. I was very disappointed because these shoes are super cute.

It runs very small It It rubbed on the front feet and gave me sores. I tried socks but the shoe was too small to fit them. Very disappointing

I BOUGHT THESE SHOES FOR MY DAUGHTER ALL THRU JUNIOR HIGH AND HIGH SCHOOL. THEY WERE SO NICE. THEY ARE NOW UNBELIEVABLY TERRIBLE. I PURCHASED A PAIR FOR MYSELF. THE MATERIAL IS SO THIN THAT IT IS ACTUALLY SHARP. I PUT THEM ON AND THE TOP CUT INTO MY FOOT. WHAT A DISAPPOINTMENT. THEY ARE LIKE PLASTIC.