Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Guess What - Original Collection

These definitely run 1/2 size larger, or so. I usually wear a size 7 1/2 but needed to swap my first pair for a size 7. I still need to wear silicone heel grippers in them to take up a tad more space to keep my heel from slipping up & down. Size 6 1/2 would be too small. Shoe has zero arch support. Innersole is removable so I can use my own orthotics. Very cute shoe and feels well-made.

Great comfort and length to the shoe. Very nice cushiony insert that would be comfortable if you were doing a lot of walking. For me, the heel fit was a bit too wide and they slid off as I walked

Super cute and comfy shoe! I felt it was true to size....not big as some of the reviews have mentioned. I bought the nude color and really love the color. Very well made shoe and CUTE! Win Win for sure!

Love these shoes! Fun and stylish and comfortable - all rolled into one pair of shoes. However, I have narrow feet and the heels flopped up and down when I walked. Had to return them.

I love the look and style of these shoes! They fit perfectly, bit they are not very cushiony. Will probably have to get inserts for more arch support.

These are sooo cute in a masuline, funky kind of way. They definitely run 1/2 size larger, or so. I first ordered them in my usual 7 1/2 M size and needed to swap them for a 7 M and will still need to put some silicone heel grippers in to make them fit just right. Size 6 1/2 would be too small. The innersole is made to look like it has arch support but from what I can tell there is zero support. Since it’s removable I can easily put in my own orthotics and that will also help to snug up the shoe for me. The shoe feels well-made and I’m happy with my purchase.

I think this shoe is really cute and seems like it would be super comfortable. It's just a little too narrow across the widest part of my foot and i could feel pressure on the bunion area. Unfortunately going a half size up won't work because the shoe feels loose at the heel.

SO. COMFORTABLE. The second I slipped them on I was in love. Plus the style is awesome. I wore them with wide-leg cropped jeans and a tweed boy blazer and got sooo many compliments on my style. But the best part was that my feet didn’t hurt at the end of the day! You won’t regret getting these.

These are the kind of shoes that look so smart, you're willing to tolerate a less-than-perfect fit. In my case, that means the heels slip in the back. Hoping to remedy by adding an O-T-C adhesive heel wedge in back to better grip my socks. I found them to run quite large; at first I ordered my usual size in this kind of shoe, intending to wear with socks, but even with burly socks they were too large. I reordered a half-size smaller and they more or less work. I'm willing to put in another insole or fuss with the heel wedge because they just look so great!

Too small and too heavy

Extremely uncomfortable! My feet get exhausted being in these shoes for only and hour. They also run large.