Customer Reviews TOMS Paxton Water-Resistant Slip-Ons

Super cute. Comfortable and trendy with the furr look

Cute style.. not good for high arches! There is an elastic under the tongue which is tight. I ended up cutting this elastic because I really liked the feel of the shoe otherwise. Fits better now.

Slightly narrow barefoot. Cute, but not what I was looking for.

I saw a woman wearing the grey faux fur lined version and knew I had to have them. Since they have the lining, I ordered a 1/2 size larger than I usually would in Toms. I tried them on and the sole was extremely rigid. There was no arch support. It was like walking barefoot on concrete. I almost packed them back up. Then I remembered one reviewer saying she’d swapped out the Toms insoles for shearling insoles. Brilliant! Oddly enough, I happened to have shearling insoles lying around. Completely changed the feel of the shoe. The shearling insoles added cushion to the rigid soles and conform to the shape of my feet. Plus, make the shoe very warm! I am in love with these shoes now. Since I ordered 1/2 size up, I don’t have any difficulty putting them on or issues with tightness over the forefoot. Someone give the woman who mentioned shearling insoles a prize!

Felt very true to size, doesn’t slip off foot and no heel rubbing. Great shoe.

Too narrow, yet too long. Felt wonderful to put on and I was disappointed because I loved them.

These are cute and pretty easy to get on but flat as a pancake and not very comfortable. Definitely returned.

Retuning this, way narrow and tight

Love the style but the shoe looked huge.

That is the narrowest wide shoe I've ever seen in my life! Couldn't even get my foot into them. Can't wait to return them, sorry.

Want to return but website makes this impossible

I ordered 6.5 because 7.0 was out of stock, hoping it would fit but alas, it did not. I loved the shoe, I hope to find it somewhere in a 7.

These shoes are a really nice price for a well made shoe. They are super snuggly and warm with the fleece lined interior but still feel like a sneaker. Love them- great for the winter months.

Cozy and perfect for the ‘tween season: late winter early spring. TTS, a bit narrow at first. Grey is more a steely blue grey.

I'm very happy with the shoes. They are cute and comfy. I did need to exchange them for a half of size larger than I usually wear.

This is my third pair of these boots! I have them in 3 colors; they are warm but not hot and comfortable and can be worn all day. No breaking in needed, soft inner sole, great support. Wear size 8, bought an 8

The fit is comfy, even with a med thin sock. I have narrow feet, and these fit me well (which makes me think they run a bit narrow). The fur is cozy, they're easy to slip on and off, and they are stylish and sleek (don't look clunky at all).

These are so comfortable and I will wear them all winter.

Love these!

I have a narrow foot but was unable to find a waterproof bootie in a true narrow. This shoe feels more narrow than a regular medium, and think when I wear them with a thick sock it will make them a bit more snug. Like the tan color and will wear them in November when visiting Scotland.

Too narrow for my feet!

I really love these shoes. They are cute and very comfortable. They felt tight at first but are stretching the more I wear them. I’m usually a 7 but get TOMS in a 7.5. I agree with other reviewers that they are difficult to put on at first since the opening is tight and there are no zippers but overall a cute and comfortable shoe.

I had bought these in my usual size 8, but returned them for a 7.5. My right one felt a bit narrow, but I decided to keep them. They're a cute style and exactly what I was looking for. I've only worn them once, but they felt ok. Hoping after wearing them a bit, they may stretch a touch.

I love the style of these. I wanted to wear them without socks, since they had the fur inside. My usual size felt big, even when I added the socks. I then ordered a half size smaller. They fit better, but feel a touch narrow. I returned my usual size and I'm still undecided if I will keep the smaller ones

I typically wear a 6.5. After reading reviews on these boots, I ordered a 7. They fit perfect. I still have some room if I need to wear thick socks. But they are very warm with just normal socks. I like that they are warm and great for cold Midwest days but are too bulky like a snow boot.