Customer Reviews TOMS Carmel

So... I typically wear a size 5, particularly in TOMS. Originally, I bought these in a size 5 but I have a slightly wide foot and I have bunions and the size 5 were just too tight across the top of my foot where the top seam is- the shoe fit every where else. I have been looking for a casual "tennis shoe" and these are just so cute with every thing that I decided to return the 5 and order the 5.5- BEST DECISION EVER! There is a slight gap around my heel but I just have to tie the laces a little tighter or wear with no-show socks and it's not at all a problem. The shoe doesn't slip off my heel when I walk and they're perfectly comfortable across the top of my foot. So glad I went with the half-size! These are so comfortable to walk in- I wouldn't run a marathon or anything but for a day out, they're just what I was looking for!

They are comfortable and fit well. May be a little tight on a wider foot.

Do not listen to the reviews about sizing up. I ordered both my normal 6.5 and a half size bigger, and my normal size fits very well. If you order half size up, it's going to be a tad too big (too much room in the toe area, too long). I'm wearing my normal size and I also wear the sock liners, which fits perfectly!

These shoes are the perfect spring shoe. They’re very light weight. Arch support is perfect. They seem like a shoe you don’t wear socks with or ones you wear no-show socks with. These feel like I could walk in them all day. Let’s see if they hold up! For the price, totally worth it!

I have not worn these yet. They are super cute. I am usually a size 8 and needed to go up to a size 8.5 in this shoe. I purchased the camel color which are like a corduroy with faux velvet laces. I love them.

I loved these shoes. THEY ARE TRUE TO SIZE! Don’t listen to reviews saying they run small (like I did and now I have to do a return.). I have SEVERAL different styles of toms, including the originals, sneakers, sandals and heels. Their sizing is SO consistent that I am an 8 in every single different style. It’s like they know to make the sneakers large enough to accommodate socks, I don’t know. BUT, I unfortunately ordered these have a size larger based on some misleading reviews and they were too long. I have a narrowish foot, and the width felt comfortable. So if you already own a pair of Toms, I suggest ordering these in the same size.

I needed a few dressier pairs of tennis shoes that could be worn to work. These were on sale and look a little dressy so I got them in the rusty red color and the multi color on a light sand background. I figure I can wear both with light colored khakis.I tend to struggle with shoes because my toes are permanently humped up (many years of ballet, dance, and gymnastics as a child) and never lie flat. This means the top of the knuckles on my toes rub the inside of most shoes, especially if they are inflexible materials, like a lot of true dress shoes. This can become very uncomfortable and leads to blisters. These shoes do not have this issue! The canvas is very flexible and allows my toes to touch the fabric to box without being confined or rubbing. Yay!These also feel pretty true to size. I wear a 9 in nearly all shoes, got these in 9, and they fit without being too short or too long. They do run a little narrow though (think Keds from the 90s), so if you tend to need wide width shoes these might not work out for you. But the canvas might also stretch enough (like it did for my wonky toes) so who knows?

Love the material and the ortholite cushion inside. I’m classically a size 6 and they do feel a tinge small. Altogether love them!

I love them...

I worked all day on my feet with these shoes and they were great. I received a ton of compliments. I was worried that wearing socks was going to be an issue after reading the reviews but It wasn’t. Very happy.

Love these shoes. They are cute and comfortable.

These are cute-around-town-sneakers that feel just fine not stand-on-your-feet-all-day sneakers.

These are happy shoes. They fit well and put a spring in your step just because they look happy. I haven't worn them long enough to know how they last but they look well made.

Adorable! retro look is so cute, and they are very comfortable

Love it. Comfort is amazing, cute, stylish, and got lots of compliments at work and even walking down the streets. Must have to spice up your style.

Nice shoes

These are very cute, classically stylish and make my feet look smaller

I would order a half size up just in case. I am usually an 8 and got a 8.5 and it fits perfectly!

Love them, but had to buy half a size larger than the rest of my Toms.

I could have used and 11.5 or a rounder toe. I am a AA width and these would have worked with some real arch support added if they were just a little bit longer. 12 would be too big. Come on, manufacturers, make some size 11.5 shoes for a change.

Normal fit and feel. I got the yellow, which tends toward the cool/green range, kind of a neon. Thought the yellow would be more cheery. It got really dingy really quickly, which made them less fun to wear, but they are comfortable, even without socks.

Teal corduroy makes for an attractive shoe. Moderate workmanship that is consistent with price. The shoe is flat, so support may be necessary.

Cute shoe! Runs a half size small if you plan on wearing socks...

Size: I wear 7.5 in the classic toms but never wear those with socks. should have ordered an 8 in these so that I could wear them with socks. they are too small as is and i have to send them back Like: flexible sole, padded well, corduroy fabric (i got "spice"), the price!, Like less: the laces (flat and velvet on one side) i would replace these for sure if i was keeping. quality: felt more robust than standard Toms (which i always wear holes in). not sure of long term quality bc the size wasn't right. Overall: undecided if I order them in the right size but the answer is probably yes!

They are a very cute retro style and golden yellow color. However, the back of the heel was too high and painfully rubbed my ankle. Returning.