Customer Reviews Mephisto Tally

Thought they had finally come out with a sandal that had the same super comfortable footbed as the Helena but wth a heel strap, but no...the footbed is hard with no arch support, which is too bad because its a good looking sandal!

Great sandals: soft leather, great support! Is like walking on air. However, narrow for my feet. I am sorry to return them.

This shoe was comfortable right out of the box. I usually choose an ankle strap for extra support but took a chance on this style and was very pleased with the high level of support and comfort of the Tally. I wore the shoes all weekend on a trip to Chicago. The weather was hot - but my feel were cool and comfortable in these shoes. I am a fan of Mephisto shoes but the Tally shines above many other choices. Excellent!

I was looking for a sandal I could wear for hours and hours -- this is the one. It's and good as my Birkis but has a bit more comfort and cushioning. The arch support is excellent and the fit was true. I wear an 8.5 and that "half" is sometimes hard to fit. But I ordered a 39 and the fit is excellent. I am super happy with this sandal -- highly recommend it to anyone looking for comfort and stability. It is not the most stylish sandal in my "repertoire", but it is one of the most comfortable....and sometimes, comfort rules!!

Just received this shoe it and love it so much! Have been looking for the perfect summer sandals from quite some time… I’ve been looking for something that looks dressy enough to wear out to dinner with a sundress but is also comfortable. This has great arch support, a cork footbed and a rubber soul. It is super comfy… Kind of like Birkenstocks but with extra cushion. Size is spot on. I wear on 8m and the 38 fits perfectly. I have a medium to wide foot, so sometimes mediums are too narrow but this one is perfect. I bought the camel color and like it because it will match everything. With the white soul it looks very summery. If you are debating this I would highly recommend trying it!

Bought this shoe since the strap did not cross over my ankle. I have a bone spur that gets aggravated with ankle straps. On a recent trip to Florida I wore them almost constantly and they were great even with my bunion feet. The one issue I have is that they are a bit loose and I can't tighten the back strap enough to accommodate my narrow heel as much as I would like. They do stay on though and are nice looking, but I would not call them stylish due to the higher bulkier sole. Comfortable walking shoes however now have become more important than style so I do recommend the Mephisto Tally. In fact when I came back from my trip I bought the blue ones as well.