Customer Reviews TOMS Payton

Nice casual shoe. You wouldn’t want to wear it for long walks, but it’s a nice slip on.

I'm a 5'11" 230lb bartender who consistently moves for up to 16 hours straight, and although I wouldn't recommend these for bartending (landing a full keg on your toes in these is an immediate ER visit), I have been putting these things through one heck of a beating for almost a year now. I bought a pair of keen utility for work, they lasted for about 3 months and I turned to these little guys in desparation. If these things can last for a year behind the bar, they're good for at least 3 years when they are worn casually like they're supposed to be. My hat is off to these light, reliable little shoes.

Shoes have great style. However during the first wearing they cut open my husband's heels after walking only a few blocks. He has other pairs of Tom's shoes & this is the first style that we've had the issue with. Would return them but can't now that they've been worn - very disappointed.

Purchased for my 12 y.o that usually wears a size 8 men’s shoe. Purchased an 8.5 but they were tight so returned and ordered a size 9. Now fits great. Little stiff but hoping after he wears them a few times they will loosen up like other TOMS shoes do. Color is great! He likes that you are able to wear with laces or no laces. My PICKY boy will actually wear these so that’s a bonus!

Excelent shoes, thank you.

These feel true to size, but the elastic band that allows them to be worn without laces makes them a little tight to get on/off the first couple times. They're super comfortable once you've broken them in past that and look quite smart. The gray is a bit tough to keep looking clean.

These are nice shoes for the price! I’m a women’s 9.5 and bought a men’s 8.5, they fit great, although the back is a little stiff and I’m worried I might get a blister. Hoping they’ll wear in!

I really like these. They seem pretty durable, are very lightweight, and for this style of shoe, they have a nice amount of cushioning. And they look cool. Not a fan of the flatter, tougher laces, but oh well. Definitely order up a half size, I’m a true 9.5, and the 10 fits well.

Bought for my son, bought a half size up and they fir fine. he likes them, which is always nice

Such a comfortable shoe -- great the it has a removable insole -- I add a metatarsal pad which I need for right foot.

Nice, comfortable shoes. Almost felt like I was wearing slippers. I advise wearing thicker socks, otherwise you might feel the canvas.

Comfortable right out of the box like all TOMS shoes. Great look with jeans. Don’t hesitate to buy them if you’re looking for casual comfort and style all in the same shoe.

Nice colors, very comfortable and stylish

Excelent shoe, comfy and stylish!

Very comfortable great fit and they were delivered earlier then shipping date

Great looking casual shoe.

Based on reviews, I ordered my son a size 9 (he’s typically an 8 or 8.5 men’s). The 9 is huge on him, but they look good and we were in a pinch for dressy shoes that day for pictures. He said they’re comfortable, so the good news is he will have nicer shoes that fit for a long time!

Fit true to size. Looks good. Good price. But... somewhat difficult to get on/off due to the stiffness of the fabric and construction. Kind of hot/swampy. No arch support means not very comfortable for walking or being on your feet. Overall best use of this shoe is when you like the look but wont be on your feet very much.

Simple pair of shoes that feel comfortable as long as you are not on your feet all day as they don’t really have any arch support. I had to go up a 1/2 size for these to be comfortable.

These shoes are super cute but were just a little too short in length for me (toe bumping up against the inside of the shoe). But they fit my boyfriend just fine, so he's keeping the original pair I bought and I'm buying the next half size up.

Overall great shoes at a good price. They look nice for summer. They are surprisingly not very breathable and I wouldn't want to walk in them for over 10 hours. The rubber sole is slightly higher than expected, which makes them only suitable for casual wear and gives them a slightly platform look, but they are subtle enough in the gray color that they pair with a lot. I'm satisfied with shoes

While I really like these shoes, I found the heel cup a little tight to the point it can cause discomfort on your achilles.

Fit is snug, order a size bigger.

This is a good looking shoe and the quality seems fine, but right shoe gave me a sore above the heel in thirty minutes wear. No issue with left shoe.Will keep them with hope that I can work out problem with right heel.

Seemed a bit cheap, and was tight given the reccomended size. But I still love Zappos!