Customer Reviews Timberland Banfield Tall All Fit Waterproof Boot

These boots are beautiful and I really wished they would've worked! The All Fit stretch was great and the boots fit my calves wonderfully. I ordered a wide size and could barely move my toes.

I can’t believe I FINALLY found tall boots! I have 16.5 inch calves, size 8.5 feet that are wide in the forefoot. I’ve been on a quest for tall leather boots and was about to throw in the towel, but figured I’d give these a shot. I didn’t have high expectations with the reviews of them being so narrow. I tried them on when they arrived and was so surprised, not only are they comfortable in the foot, but they zip with ease! The color is better in person. I tried the Teva De La Vina Dos Tall before these. They fit, but the leather looked so cheap. These are richer looking. I am pleasantly surprised...Operation Tall Boots Muscular Calves: Complete!

Love these boots! Classic style and warm. They look great w jeans, leggings and dresses! The ball of the foot area feels a little narrow but a half size up was perfect. Calf has a bit of room but that doesnt bother me. Ive been searching for black boots I like and finally found them!

The boot bunches a little around the ankle where the inner additional stretch piece is at the bottom part of the zipper. Overall I really thought this was a beautiful boot but at 4’11” /5’ tall it hit me wrong at my knee.

These are great! They look very sturdy and have a slightly squishy insert. Very thick leather, slightly stiff but doesn't hurt walking around the house anyway. Perfect combo of rain, riding, and motorcycle boots. I haven't worn these out yet, but wanted to alert people with wide calves or feet that the normal version is pretty narrow, and I'd be surprised if people with very wide calves found the wider version comfortable. I have (what I thought were) normal width calves (14 1/2" when my muscle is flexed), and the normal squeezed me uncomfortably in calf and across toes (esp. by the ball of the foot), even in 1/2 size larger than my regular. The wider shaft version, however, were indeed wider and fit perfectly in my calf and foot. There is just a tiny bit of extra space on top of shaft, wearing very thin, tight skinny jeans, but it doesn't look weird--only I notice it, and it's comfortable. The buckle has five holes, which is nice. I also got them 1/2 size larger than my regular size. Forgot to mention in my other review for the more narrow version: I'm 5'3" and they just hit my knee but comfortably, and I don't feel dwarfed by them as I do in the fancier riding styles. Very happy with these! Can't wait for sweater weather to wear them--I can see them taking me through fall, winter with wool sox, and chilly damp spring.

Based on the other reviews I ordered a half size up and the fit is perfect - a little extra room in the toe, but wide enough to wear snugly yet comfortably with a thin winter sock. Great looking, well constructed boot - the perfect combo of stylish and functional. I haven't road tested them yet in winter weather but the base of the boot looks really grippy - like you'd be able to wear them out in the city on a wet or slippery day and still feel stylish. I look forward to talking these with me to NYC this holiday season.

I love these boots! They are classic and warm. Ive been seaching for black boots without all the buckles that I liked forever and finally found them. They feel a bit narrow but a half size up fixed that. Im actually looking forward to the cold, wet Seattle winter now that I have these! Oh, and they look great w eveything...jeans, leggings, skirts and dresses ??

A little tight in the foot, but I tried on with thicker socks since I intend these are for winter wear. I ordered these and the standard version--normally I don't have to do a wide-calf, but I couldn't even zip the standard size up. The All-Fit were perfect fit in the calf for me.

I found these for my friend. I usually shop for her because she's getting her Ph.D. and she has two small children and works many hours. She loved them, she has wide calfs, and these were perfect, they look great on her and she says they are comfy and true to size. I like them because sometimes when she gets wide- boots, they look bulky and big, but these hug her leg and are super sexy. I think this might be my best buy yet!

These boots are fabulous. They look beautiful and fit my large calves without being bulky. I've hard such a hard time finding boots that fit my calves and these do not only fit but look great.

I bought three boots with the hope of finding the perfect one and this boot was it! The leather is sturdy yet soft to the touch, it has nice arch support, and I love that it's water resistant! I'm incredibly happy with this purchase! I wear a 7.5-8 shoe and bought this boot in an 8. It fits perfectly. My only caution is that the boot is narrow. I have average-size feet (a little wider than some but not enough to get wide-width shoes). The first two times wearing them they fit a little snug, especially with wool socks. I wore them around the house for a few hours to break them in and was very happy with the result. After only a couple of weeks they fit perfectly!

Really gorgeous boot, especially for being waterproof. Plenty of room in calf and shoe. However, leather is very stiff, and waterproof gusset takes up room in the ankle. As much as I loved them, I traded them in for the non-waterproof but super comfortable Born Mayalls.

While I absolutely love these boots I’ve had issues with sole coming off. I’ve take them twice to the shoe repair shop to cement it with no luck. Really frustrating because they’re very comfortable but they started to come loose almost immediately after buying them.

Was able (barely) to zip over my 18inch calf. I would have kept them hoping it get easier BUT the removable insole is paper thin so would not accommodate my orthotics. Probably wouldn't be all that comfortable either

I’m a little perplexed by this being labeled a wide calf. I have muscular calves, that measure at 15.5”. Since another reviewer said they fit her 16.5” calves I thought these would be a slam dunk. Sadly not =(. They got caught in the muscle midway up my calf so no dice. In a size 7 at least the calf measured closer to 14.5” at the top. Will be returning.

These boots are very stylish I wish they fit right. They arch support is fantastic, but the ankle is a little stiff and narrow so they rub against my ankle bone in a very strange and uncomfortable way (and I have very skinny legs/ankles). They are also very big in the calf. Too big to be cute on me, but if you have wider calves and can deal with the strange ankle stiffness these boots are beautiful!

These boots are very sturdy with good tread. They look nice, too. They are too large for narrow calves. The buckle doesn't allow for much adjusting. And there was a white spot on the leather on one of the boots, so I sent them back. I was sad they didn't work out.

These boots are comfortable and supportive in the footbed, but too wide in the calves. I had to return them.

Did not fit at all even with half size up. Calf part would have probably been more than ample space but I couldn't get my foot even in the boot. Too bad they looked great in person.