Customer Reviews Massimo Matteo Penny Keeper

The softness and comfort of this shoe are wonderful, but I ordered the grey and when I received them the color is clearly tan.

Was on the hunt for a new loafer and these fit the bill. I usually wear size 9.5 but after reading some reviews, order both red and yellow in a size 9. The loafers are adorable, the colors are great, BUT still too big (with and without socks) and not much arch support. Had to return both, but plan on ordering 8.5 to replace them. The price point is perfect.

Love them, super comfy... just make sure you get a size smaller they run bit big.

These shoes are beautiful! They are rich in color and they do not look cheap, they are very good quality. I purchased three pairs and they were too big! I wear a size 6 1/2 but these fit as if they were a 7. I will be returning them for a size 6.

These loafers are so adorable. They are comfortable with moderate support. Super cute with skinny jeans and leggings.

Shoe fit perfect but will probably be returning them, as color I choose shows as baby blue and when they arrived, they looked more like a dull gray.

I liked everything about this shoe except it rubbed the back of my foot. It was really cute and I hate to send it back.....I’m still debating!

These loafers are incredibly comfortable. The insides are soft and comfortable without socks. The uppers required no break-in period at all. They look great. I'll get another pair of these!

I love these shoes. I've purchased 3 pairs in different colors. The first two pairs were slightly wide, but fit great when I don't wear any type of stocking/stocking socks. This pair fits true to size in width and length. I love the bright colors, and I love the quality of the materials.

Love, love these Penny keepers. Perfect fit, comfortable and wonderful quality.

This shoe fits perfectly! So glad I ordered a half size smaller like other reviewers suggested, they would have been to big if I’d ordered my usual size. The leather is really soft, there’s been no break in period where I’ve had sore spots on my foot. Even the back of my heels feel fine, which is always a problem area with new flats and loafers. These go great with all my work outfits; they look professional and luxurious

So very pleased with the comfort and look of these loafers! They are the perfect color to coordinate with a Coach "aubergine' bag Ive had for a couple of seasons. I'm pleased with the product and the speed of Zappos order response. Thank you!

Pretty as they look in the picture. I purchased for an upcoming trip to France as can go with jeans and skirts both. Super comfortable, did not require much break in.

I am in love with these loafers. They are practical, classic, and comfortable! I ordered half a size smaller than usual and they fit perfectly.

Wonderful pair of shoes! Extremely comfortable out of the box. True to size and very wearable.

Really nice shoe. I bought 2 pairs, because they sell out so quickly. Ralph Lauren made a similar shoe last year that I preferred, but can't find them this year.

The picture of the hot pink does not tell the story of the true color of this shoe. The hot pink is HOT and extremely vibrant, the texture screams winter. The leather is fine and very soft...bottom line, the shoe is well made, very comfy & very stylish! I own this in the blue, hot pink and I am waiting for my size in the orange.

AMAZING! I get compliments and recommend these to all my friends at work. I bought the pink then also ordered blue. The colors "pop", and the leather is butter soft. The sizing is a shade short in length, but they stretch a bit, so I was true to size. These are elegant, and my colleague thought they were expensive shoes! (I don't own shoes...). These are really good value.

This is the most comfortable pair of penny loafers I have ever worn! Here are the reason why. 1. Beautiful and soft material: I have extremely sensitive feet, my skin gets chafed and blistered easily so I have never been able to wear pair or loafers that did not blister and wound the skin at the back of the heel, or at the instep or the toes. This pair though - I wore it for eight straight hours the very first day of walking and no problems. At all. I did not even need to line with socks. 2. The insoles are so comfortable and cushioned that my high arch feet felt comfy and supported. 3. They are true to size. I ordered the same size as I wear for pumps and sandals and they fit well. Snug not tight, and not loose. I wish they would have more colors in my size though! A word of advice, please Scotchgard them as soon as you take them out of the box. I forgot to do that and I had a drop of water fall on one of the shoes...needless to say the stain is hard to get out of this kind of high quality suede. However, I have protected my other pair. Haven't tested them out in rain - but I kind of don't want! they are too cute and comfy to be made messy!

Pretty shoe, color a little brighter than expected, but definitely not meant for my foot. I was swimming around in it and they flopped off the back with each step. My feet seem to need laces or a strap so if you generally don't have an issue with the style I would just suggest trying a half size smaller.

The posted image of the gray shoe with the tan sole doesn't match the product. The shoes I received have a black sole, and the upper is not a true gray. It's much more grayge see pic with beige floor for reference). Comfort-wise, they seem good right out of the box, I haven't gotten blisters. These shoes run large, I'm a 7.5, ordered a 7 and they are still on the large side. Happy with my purchase, though, they match lots of outfits and the commission good.

The pink was really bright. Not bad as it’s just a bit brighter then the picture. The sizing is too big. I had to return because I needed a smaller size. But definitely comfortable ands really a beautiful shoe

The shoe itself is a very pretty shoe and very comfortable feeling. The leather is very soft. However, I had to send these back. They are much too big. I tried a half size smaller, and then it was too small. There is a similar style though that is offered in the nubuck leather. I ordered that, and with a small shoe insert, they fit perfectly.

I’m a size 7.5. The 7.5 was a little too tight so, I exchanged it for an 8. The 8 is a little too big. I would like to exchange the 8 for a size 7.5 - Samuel Hubbard loafer. They are more money but the fit is true to size.

These were very cute and looked decent quality, but they were just too small. A size 11 fits me well generally, but these were painfully tight in the toe area which was disappointing as the color was so cute.