Customer Reviews Trotters Petra

This shoe is super cute and pretty comfortable, but I found the sizing to be pretty wonky. I am a pretty consistent 8.5M in size, sometimes a 9, with my left foot ever-so-slightly larger than my right. I ordered these in an 8.5M and they were WAY too tight across the footbed. The length seemed fine and my heel was pretty much comfortable, but my toes were very pinched and I felt like I was walking on the seam where the side and bottom of the shoe meet. I returned and ordered both an 8.5W (which I have never worn a Wide size in my life) and a 9M. The 8.5W felt perfect on my left foot, but on my right foot, my toes were sort of jammed up against the side. In the 9, they're slightly too long, but a better fit for my toes. I'm going to stick with the 9s and add a gel cushion which keep my foot back in the shoe, which should in turn prevent the heel from slipping so much. In any event, now that I have the sizing dialed in, I love these. Wish they came in charcoal grey suede, too!

Worth the money! This shoe is so sharp and stylish. It can be worn well suits, dresses, pants, capris and jeans. The pointed toe is so classy and makes my legs and ankles look long and slender. This shoe is also very comfortable even with the pointy toe. I think they fit true to size. I normally wear an 8 and the 8 was good. I bought both the brown and black pair.

This is a GREAT shoe. Comfort and style. Compliments overtime I wear it. Really nice red too! Extra padding in the heel makes it nice to walk in.

Beautiful shoe even nicer than the photo and comfortable. Trotters shoes are well made and true to size.

More beautiful in person. Very stylish I love these shoes.

Very comfortable and cute!

Love it! I don't know how Trotters does it but they have the only heels that are comfortable for me - after years of thinking I had to go with Ferragamo's or Stuart Weitzman. Petra is a great dress-up shoe for those of us downtown girls who usually pick flats for walking to work, appointments,etc. Plus the toe box works. A great shoe.

This shoe is one of my favorites for fit, style, and just fabulous with leggings or straight legged cigarette pants. Definitely adds to a fashionable look!

I have a wide foot and love pointy toed pumps. This shoe gave me both. The heel is a little matronly, but what counts for me is the pointy toe peeking out of the slacks I wear to work. Not sexy enough to wear with a skirt, but great with dress pants. These felt good right out of the box.

I love these pumps. I wear an 8.5WW normally, and I'm developing a bunion on my right foot. I'm fond of pointy pumps, the pointier, the better. These have an excellent point, and they are perfect for wearing with dress slacks. The heel is a little frumpy, so I wouldn't bust these out to wear with a skirt. They are cut generously wide, which is awesome because it exaggerates the pointy toe. Even better, my bunion isn't splitting the through the edge of shoe at the widest part of my foot - I have had this problem with Fitzwell and RSVP. I'm a 46-year-old lawyer who dresses business casual during the week. These are my go-to pumps.

Beautiful shoes! Very soft leather. I receive compliments every time I wear them.

The shoe is elegant and the fit was perfect. I wore them right out of the box to a wedding and they were completely comfortable.

Great shoes for work! Heel is low enough to work in all day and high enough to help pant legs look good.

Really cute and comfortable!!! Love the color for the holidays. True to size.

The Perfect Kitten. I was looking for a kitten heeled shoe and was a little hesitant about ordering it because of the skinny toe. The shoe fits perfectly. Once them three times in the 1st week. Go with everything.

Bought this shoe in black suede, and it looks sharp at work. The downside is that after a month of wear, it stretched out quite a bit. What started out as a very good, comfortable fit is now wearable, but not as comfortable or stable. Glad I opted to wear it for a month instead of rushing out to buy it in other colors. I still wear them, just not as often. And the kitten heel, while cute, loves to find it's way into cracks of all sorts - sidewalks, etc.

Cute shoes. Love the kitten heel and strap. They were the right width but too long for the size and sadly looked like I was a child wearing her mother's heels.

This is the cutest shoe, and I really did try to get it to work. The 7 was too small, and I always wear a 7. Then I ordered the 7.5 and it was too big. I feel like Goldilocks! Maybe what I needed was a 7 wide even though I don't usually take a wide, but they were out, so back they go. Sigh.

Pointy shoes just aren't for me but this is about as good as it gets. I usually wear an 11B but I got an 11W and the length was good and the width was good. My toes still wish they could spread out but for an event these will stay on my feet and look pretty.

I've been looking forever for a pointy toe dressy low-heeled pump. Finally found it! Narrow heel (great) and narrow footbed (darn). Had to go up a half-size to fit my toes, so now is a bit too long. No blisters the first two times wearing after significant walking. I wouldn't plan on walking a mile in these, but they are great for a nice night out or to wear at work.

I ordered three different brands of low-heeled black suede shoes for an upcoming cruise. I cannot wear high heels, but the kitten height works. These were the most comfortable and well made of the three. They are a bit tight but the others slipped off my heels and were not as well made.

These are such pretty shoes. I love pointy toed heels for work but being on my feet a lot means I need lower heels. I love the brand. They seem very comfortable.

It was only because ultimately I didn't need black heels that I returned this item. If I HAD needed a black shoe, I would have kept this one. It was not a walk around all day in shoe (support not there) but nothing hurt, the strap kept the shoe secure, and it's lovely.

When I took these shoes out of the box I was surprised at how long they looked. Although I wear a 9AA, the shoes looked about two sizes bigger. I am a fan of Trotters other pointed shoes such as the Paulina and Prima. This shoe has a more exaggerated point than the other Trotters mentioned. The shoe did fit well for a narrow fit. But the extreme point gave it a Halloween like appearance, I was not going for.

Loved the appearance of this shoe, and the heel height is very comfortable. However, for some reason, the right shoe dug into my foot. Too bad, because these are really stylish and would have been perfect for work.