Customer Reviews Naturalizer Hanover

I bought these last year (2013) in the yellow and wore them all spring and summer. They are very, very comfortable and I received tons of random compliments from strangers on the fun color. I wear them without socks and they are as comfortable as slippers. The only issue is that I wore them so much that the bright yellow has become very dirty and faded - I even used leather cleaner to try to bring it back a bit. As they have become worn in they don't look quite as tailored and I can't really wear them as a preppy fashion statement, but they are still as comfortable as ever. And I really did wear them a lot to get them to this point.

Very cute - super comfy. I am normally a 7.5 with wider feet. I ordered a 7.5 and it was way too big so I exchanged for a 6.5 because I was afraid the 7 would still be too big. The 6.5 fit well enough to keep but the 7 would have been the best. Either way I like them. Soft leather, cute and well made.

I ordered these a half size smaller based on reviews and am glad that I did. One problem with the shoe, and I have two pairs, is that the insole liner has come loose on both. This makes the shoe uncomfortable. The manufacturer should check into this as I feel that it is a quality problem as it happened the first time that I wore them.

Comfortable; nice leather; casual but well-bred style. Gray/beige/white color turned out to be more tan than beige, but still very attractive. Felt at least 1/2 size larger. I might try ordering another size, but I'm a bit demoralized because of the inconsistent sizing of all the manufacturers who've outsourced and unsure if I want to go to the bother.

Too big! I should have listened to others who said the same thing. It was not narrow enough and I could have used a size smaller. Cute shoe, though.

I am a true 9 in all shoes, boots, sandals...however, in these a 9 was too big. With that said, had the shoe fit I believe they would be comfortable. As far as the color goes, I ordered the T-bird Turquoise with white leather. It is a cute spring time color and would jazz up any casual outfit. I am going to try these in an 8.5 because I really like the style and color. Overall I would recommend this cute boat shoe.

I like the shoe, but it definitely requires a little breaking in. It looks stylish and I think comfortable as long as you are not walking long distances. I wore these in St. Martin and by the end of the day my feet were screaming to be free, but all in all they are cute and worth the price. I would recommend them as casual loafers for moderate walking!

Adorable loafer. The color is perfect for spring. Pretty comfortable right out the box, although they can use a little breaking-in

Very fun shoe because of the color, but it hit a place on the side of my foot by my little toes that made it uncomfortable. I think it was the stitching. I wear a narrow so the fit in the instep has to be right. Wish it had worked because the leather is so soft and I love the yellow color for spring.

I loved this shoe but it was just too flat and not enough support for my high arches. I have plantar fasciitis. Too bad, as the materials are great and it's really cute on.

I bought these to sightsee on a vacation and although they are butter soft and very cute, they have no arch support. After a day of walking about a city I had the worst case of shin splints I've ever had. I think if I had had better arch support this wouldn't have happened. I now wear them for shorter events only. I ordered 1/2 size down as well.

I had high hopes for these shoes because of the fantastic reviews. Upon receiving the shoes, the first thing that I noticed was that they were just as pictured and overall really nice looking. I immediately tried them on without socks and I felt my big toe touch something. I thought there was something in my shoe and after further inspection, it was because the footbed was larger than it should have been and there was extra fabric folded over and was rubbing against my toe on both shoes. Suffice to say, the extra fabric from the footbed bothers my toes and the shoes are going back. I assume my pair was a lemon because no one else mentioned this problem. I find Naturalizer shoes do run a little big, but not too big where I would need to go a size down. That might be because they do nit make a size smaller than size 4, though. That does give me the option of wearing their shoes with or without socks, though.

Last return was because shoe 10M was too long and much too wide which you replaced with a size 9 1/2 N which is is still too wide - also the left shoe seemed larger than the right shoe. Thanks

Very narrow! The wide was nowhere near wide enough for my feet. Otherwise, a really cute shoe, great color, nice materials. Very sorry the wide isn't a true wide. (I hate to imagine how narrow the regular width is!)

I love the style of these boat shoes...but the sizing is way off. I normally wear an 8 1/2 and in these I actually need a 7! I haven't worn a 7 since I was the age 7! Order at least a size down.

Loved the look and super comfortable but after wearing twice the insole came up and made the shoe too uncomfortable to wear. Returned and Zappos was great as always

I love the shoes but had to return them. I wear a 7N but these felt more like a 7 1/2 M. Have reordered a 6 1/2 N and will see how that goes.

This was a cute shoe, the leather was soft and it was comfortable. Unfortunately, it ran 1/2 size too big and wide. I ordered a narrow which usually fits in this brand. Sadly, I will be returning them.

I was looking forward to using these on an upcoming vacation, but after only one day of wearing the inside lining started to come loose. I went on a short walk and my calves were burning from these shoes. Now I'm not sure when I will be able to use these. Style was good but nothing else about these shoes was.

Disappointed! Left foot fits great - right one is too big. Labeled the same size but they feel & look different. Bad quality control. I think I would LOVE these shoes if they were the same size for each foot!