Customer Reviews Naturalizer Genie

Nice looking shoes and very comfortable. I might have bought them a bit too big so I am wearing socks with them. But very pleased. And as always, totally impressed with Zappos!

I bought this shoe because was looking for a good travel shoe with the feel of a flat with more arch support. I have been very pleased thus far but will not use it for travel until the fall. It feels as though it will work well on those days when I am doing a lot of walking.

The shoes are really comfy to stand but they flopped off my foot when I walked in them. I wear and 11 but ordered a 10.5 based on reviews. The length was fine but the width wasn't. I had to return these.

I am solidly a 10 in most shoes and these were a full size too big. They were cuter out of the box than I thought they would be for a comfort shoe. I would suggest ordering a full size smaller.

I normally wear a 7.5 or 8. This shoe7.5 is too large my foot lifts out when I walk. Order a half to whole size smaller than you normally where. I don't have slender feet either.

Unbelievably comfortable shoe, with good arch support. Really impressed. However, still deciding whether I'll be able to wear these with a suit... at a minimum, I'll be able to wear them with a skirt at work. Recommend!

These are super cute, not too high, and can be dressed casual or up. Had to order them three times because they were too big. I would order a full size down from your normal size.

Not true to size! These shoes fit wide and long. I couldn't take more than two steps without my heel slipping right out of the back. Too bad because the styling and construction looks so nice. I'd suggest ordering a narrower size.

Comfortable shoe. I have to return it because it runs a little large. There is a gap between my heel and the back of the shoe. I plan on ordering it a 1/2 size smaller. The width is perfect and does not irritate my bunion.

Put them on and promptly walked out of them. Too big especially in the heel. I normally wear a 8.5, read the reviews where some said true to size, others said order down a size. The 8's were too big. I think they would be comfortable for a work shoe. Not any kind of show stopper, but practical.

These are not as cute in person. The leather is stiff and cheap-looking. The heels slip right off even though the length seems good. The padding inside and room in the toe box seem like they would be extraordinarily comfortable, but I will never know since they literally flop off from the heel with the first step. There is no way these are wearable. I will not try a size down to prevent slipping, since the stiff leather will definitely cut in. Disappointing as I though I had finally found a cute, versatile, comfortable shoe...

I loved these shoes as soon as I put them on...unfortunately, by the end of the day they were way too big. They are extremely comfortable, but I would suggest ordering a half size down. I put one of those heel thingies in to make them a little smaller, but it is just not the same. I highly recommend the shoes, just wish I had them in a smaller size.

Since so many here rated this as feeling a half size larger, I ordered a half size down. That was a mistake: the shoe was clearly too short when I put it on. I also found that the heel slipped with every step, even though this was a narrow. Really liked the look, but I can't wear it so back it goes and another return. Naturalizer used to be pretty reliable with widths. I rather doubt my foot has gotten narrower so, either their narrows are wider than they used to be (Americans getting heavier?) or Zappos has been given second-rate merchandise. Frustrating. I keep returning my "narrow" shoes because they are too wide. I will start trying the even more difficult to find slim fit and see if that works better for me. Or save up my dimes and buy Munro -- love those!

They seem very comfy. I'm getting them in half a size smaller. I usually wear 7.5 but this one ran big. Hope the half size down works. Giving it 4 for style because I'm not a fan of really round toe but it just seems to comfy to pass. I teach on my feet all day. I need the comfort more than I want the style.

Love these, but had to return and exchange for a smaller size. I normally wear an 8.5 in heels and either an 8.5 or 9 in flats. The 9 was too long.

Super cute, but they were over 1/2 size too big. I just don't know if a full size smaller will fit, might be too small. I ordered a wide and the width was great for my feet, but the length is way off. I would advise ordering 1/2 to 1 full size smaller but sticking to your usual width. Wanted to love these, sniff sniff.

Great shoes, they slipped right on and I have very wide feet. The toe part hurts a little after a while of wear though - but nothing intolerable.

I love this shoe! Came yesterday. As soon as I tried it on it was love at first step. Have a conference to go to this weekend, so wore them today to be sure they would be comfortable and no worries there.

Bought what I thought were the Red ones but they actually are more of a brown color than red. Was disappointed. They do fit well and are very comfortable though.

These are super comfortable with great support. Another reviewer said they ran a bit big and I agree. I ordered my usual 8N but the 7.5N fit better.

Love the way these look but they run a bit big. I usually need a 9c but with these my feet were slipping right out (sockless). Not sure if I should go to 8.5c or 9b.

This shoe is very pretty, and soft (which I always look for!) but it runs a bit (about half a size) small. It felt a little too tight.

This shoe is extremely wide and I have extremely wide feet so I do not recommend this shoe at all. :(

These run large. I'm between a 9.5 and a 10, but these 10s had a visible gap at the back and I stepped out of them immediately when trying to walk. Go with the smaller size if you're between.

I normally wear a AA width, but these felt wider than that. They slipped at the heel and gapped at the arch. I am sorry, because I liked the style and color.