Customer Reviews Jack Rogers Georgica Sandal

These shoes are really pretty, but they were so uncomfortable. The leather was pretty tough and painful on my feet, which are more sensitive than most. I ordered several Jack Rogers shoes in various styles, and they all felt the same way, so back they went. If the leather had been softer, I would have kept them.

Great fit and style, a little rub/irritation from the leather thong between toes. Hoping that goes away as I start to break them in.

Super narrow sandals! Normally I wear a size 7.5 in a sandal so I ordered the 8 in these. Length-wise they were the correct fit. I have a pretty high arch so I could barely even get these on - the fit was way too tight from top to bottom. My foot runs between medium and medium/wide width so the footbed was way too narrow for me, at the toes and all the way back to the heel. Looks like Jack Rogers isn't going to be a brand that I can wear.

So cute but soooo uncomfortable.

Runs very narrow; Jack Rogers used to have leather sole, but this one has plastic sole which isn't as nice

These sandals are really pretty but they are very uncomfortable! The cork-like material is very stiff and the toe strap hurts. Coming out of the box I really wanted these to work, but unfortunately, they are going back.

Cute shoe, but really strange fit. Side straps are positioned closer to the front than in the photo, toe thong very uncomfortable. Also, the sole of the shoe is very narrow throughout, extending down through the narrow heel. I thought the leather looked cheap for the money.

This shoe is not the same color as the 8.5 and 9.5 in platinum - it is really Silver with no gold in the color so I am returning it.

Size and fit were correct but they are SO UNCOMFORTABLE. They kill my feet after walking for just a few blocks. Worse than heels. Today I was walking and they just snapped! I was out and had to buy new sandals! UGH I'm so upset because they're so cute.

just got them today, the middle tore. haven’t even wore them out yet. not happy

I thought these sandals were so cute but ran small and offered little to no support

These are beautiful shoes but they are very narrow. I ordered an 8 and while they fit my foot did not fit on the base. It seems like the top of the shoe was designed to slant to the middle so it directs your foot to the inside line of the base. With a thong sandal, that means my large toe was off the base. Neither comfortable nor practical - after all, a shoe is to protect your foot. They were also very uncomfortable at the thong. I understand there is a break in time, but if a shoe is that uncomfortable new then it just does not fit right.

Very disappointed! They are uncomfortable, especially the thong between my toes. Also, the woven "patch" is in an awkward spot...it doesn't sit on top of my foot. I sized up a half size and they are still a bit small. I was hoping that they were going to work out because I love the contrast of metallic and cork, but I am returning them.

I have two other Jack Rogers and they have worn very well. Shoe repair man commented on how well they were made. Unfortunately, this new style has not held up at all. There are cracks around the toe piece and the soles on both shoes cracked within months. I don't think the workmanship is the same on this style.

Narrow and very cheap looking. Looks nothing like the image online. I have several Jack Rogers and love them; however, this shoe is not of the quality that I am used to seeing in a Jack Rogers Shoe.

Thought these were super-cute, but the soles split the second time I wore them! I also always wear an 8, and had to buy an 8.5 in these. I own 2 other Jack Rogers sandals, and have never had this problem with quality before.

Wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong. No wonder they were on sale. I wanted them to work, but unfortunately they did not so I’m back to searching for a cute black sandal. Way too small and narrow and ugly to boot. I guess size 8 is now the new 6. Stop people!!! Make cute comfortable sandals, we’ll pay the price.

run one full size small

I put this shoe on to wear for the first time and both sandals broke where the thong part attached to the round part. I didn't even make it to the car before they broke. So disappointed!!!!

Got these hoping they would be comparable to my Tory Burch sandals that look similar. Highly disappointed- these shoes are very uncomfortable, no cushioning at all, and the sole has an odd shape that looks awkward. They are so hard that they barely bend and they flop loudly when I walk. Going back.