Customer Reviews Frye Sully Boat

My husband says they're the most comfortable shoes he ever had. He has a wide foot and has a hard time finding a good fit. He's wearing them out! Highly recommend. Cool color that looks great with jeans or khakis.

These are pretty nice looking. Have received compliments on them. I ordered down a half size as I figured I would be wearing without socks and they would stretch, but i should have just ordered my regular size, as they still feel a little tight after several months of wear.

These are great looking boat shoes. The leather is higher quality than most other brands. Cushioning and support are minimal but probably slightly better than other boat shoe brands. The three eyeholes make it difficult to tie the laces in typical boat shoe knots. I got the whiskey color and really like it. I agree that the size runs about half a size large but I am also guessing that most will wear the shoes without socks so half a size would be recommended anyway.

These were my favorites out of several of the boat shoes (Sperry Gold, Sebago, etc.). The leather was very nice, fit well on my narrow foot, comfortable. BUT - after 2 hours of wearing around the house...the lacing on the side came unglued. Easy enough to fix, but these are definitely Made in China.

Superior materials and good construction, but not built on the usual Frye last. Frye usually has some metatarsal adduction in their shoe design, but these did not. A good analogy - Usual Frye last / Sully Frye last : Nike free last / old Nike last

Blisters. Blood. Sweat. Aesthetic perfection. I've given these shoes about 100 hours of wear time in the last two months, and I've never had as many compliments, nor endured as much pain. I expect a wear-in period where the shoes conform to the foot, but not here. Is it worth it? Yes. I even bought stretchy feminine toe socks to soak up the foot sweat entrenched inside this impermeable leather. It's worth it. Full disclosure: my foot slips around a bit during movement; likely attributing to the blisters. Wish I bought a 12.5. Zappos is fast and great.

Does not have true 360 degree lacing as the guy in the video claims. The lacing around the back is for looks only and does not connect to the lace in front. That was the only reason I bought this shoe. That is my only complaint about Zappos, these guys doing the videos have no idea what they are talking about. They could be showing you a cinder block and they'd tell you it has a soft supple leather upper that is easy to clean. And a padded insole with plenty of "cush.") In short, yes, this shoe is comfy and looks nice; however, it is NOT a functional true boat shoe. If you just want "the look", this shoe is for you.

I originally liked the shoe very much. Kept in shoe trees. Haven't worn them but maybe a dozen times...but then it's begun to stretch and it's begun to come undone from the sides. It's particularly disappointing to spend this kind of money on a boat shoe.