Customer Reviews Allen Edmonds Shelton

These are excellent shoes. As the owner of seven pairs of Allen Edmonds shoes, I can say that my brown Sheltons are my favorite. I have a pair of the burgundy and black Sheltons as well. Not surprisingly they're just as comfortable although I find the color scheme to be a touch more restrictive. It's tough to dress the burgundy and black pair down. The brown pair easily transition from wool slacks to jeans.

This is a classic style and a handsome leather color. Allen-Edmonds will last a lifetime.

I needed a new pair of saddle oxfords and these fit the bill. Nice style that goes very well with khakis. I expect to wear these for many years. Surprisingly comfortable given the leather soles, but I'm not on my feet all day either. A little pricey, but they are a high quality shoe made in U.S.A., so I don't mind paying a little extra for that. Buying from Zappos is easy and returns are painless.

I have had the same pair in burgundy and black since April 2007 (almost five years). They are my go-to dress shoes for a navy suit, and also look great with some tan dress pants. I have gotten lots of compliments on these shoes and highly recommend them. They are well worth the cost, and still going strong!

These shoes are stylish and made of top-notch materials. My only knock on them is that they don't seem to be as comfortable as I expected an expensive pair of shoes to be. The interior seems to lack any kind of padding.

Only Allen Edmonds - I've wanted a pair of burgundy and black saddle shoes for decades but the problem has been trying to get a pair in a "B" width. No manufacturer (that I've found) other than Allen Edmonds makes them in a narrow. I finally took the plunge and ordered them from Zappos and they were worth the investment. The shoes fit beautifully, look great and are extremely well made. As a couple of the reviewers have stated, if you take care of these, they should last a lifetime. I'm a repeat customer of Zappos and I have found their service and selection to be top drawer.

Great shoe! A very substantial shoe that fit well. I didn't have the breaking-in issues that other reviewers referred to. In fact, this shoe was comfortable right out of the box for me. Has a professional look that has a subtle difference from the standard brogues you see in the office.

Great look and fit! I love this shoe and love wearing it! Great look and great fit, not to mention a wonderful style! Wish AE would try out this shoe in different colors, like taupe with blue saddle. Somebody before said he wore this shoe barefoot -this is not a good idea, they will stink because the linings and insole will darken and hold sweat. Always wear socks with these or any other AE shoe, except possibly for loafers and sandals.

Beautiful shoe, beautifully made. Nice detailing. Doesn't look like everyone else's shoes that you see every day. I wear them only occasionally, and am always asked about them.

Excellent fit. Fits similar to AE Leeds shoe. About 1/2 size larger (longer and wider) in same size than AE Grayson and Park Avenue. No problems with break in. Comments on first day worn as being very unique and handsome. This is my 6th pair of AE over last 10 years. All 6 still in regular rotation. Great products.

Great Looking Shoe - This is a great looking shoe. I tried others, but after seeing this shoe on line, I just couldn't resist. 3 Stars on comfort is because of the break in period. Otherwise, I think this shoe will match any color trousers I wear.

Cordovan and black dress saddle shoe - This is a hard shoe to find in high quality construction using full leather that can be resoled many times. It is a good value in the long term with superior leather that takes an excellent shine. Comfort is a 4 and not a 5 because there is a 2 day break in for the heavy leather. After that, it is a 5. It is a work (office) shoe for me with gray slacks, open collar white shirt, dark blue blazer, and cordovan belt. Allen Edmonds will also custom make them with true cordovan leather rather than cordovan calfskin... but that is more expensive.

My First AEs - This is my first pair of Allen Edmond shoes and I have only "Great Things" to say about them! The quality of the materials and workmanship is unsurpassed, as well as the look and fit. I have worn these shoes 3-4 days per week for the past 3 months and they only feel better each time. I love the "dress/casual" look, and since they are fully lined with soft leather, I always wear them without socks...very comfortable as my feet stay cool and dry!

Great Classic Shoe - I've had a pair of these for years and usually get a compliment every time I wear them. Allen Edmonds shoes cost more but they will last the rest of your life if you take care of them. I learned that from my Dad and it's true.

Best shoe for my husband's birthday present - I bought the shoes for my husband's birthday present and he loved them! The size is perfect, they feel really comfortable and go with all the clothes he wears.

Couldn't be better! I hadn't had a pair of these since college. They look great and feel great! Love your website--especially the feature that allows me to see only the shoes that are available in my size and width.

Pleased - I have been wearing Allen-Edmond shoes for many years and they continue to maintain a high quality standard and great value.

You get what you pay for! A quality priced item. A quality product received.

Great pair of shoes! I was a little taken back by the price tag of these shoes, however after the first day of wearing them I understand why they cost what they do. Simply put, these are a great pair of shoes. They have broken in nicely and comfortably, they feel great and look great. They have also stood up to the scuffs and scrapes better than any other shoe I have had! These are certainly worth the investment.

This is a super pair of shoes. They have a great look and are very comfortable. These shoes are well-built. They are definitely worth the price. As a young executive appearance is important and these shoes give the desired handsome appearance one needs to be successful.

The finest pair of shoes I've ever owned. Versatile styling. I wear them with suits, dress slacks, and even jeans occasionally. Third paid of AE's. Had the last two resoled and are like new again.

Perfect shoes! Great shoes! This is my 2nd pair of Allen-Edmonds and despite the high price (and the tentativeness of ordering without trying them on first) they are worth every penny. I certainly appreciated the 1-day delivery by Zappos at no charge on my first order.

Great classic shoe - Really nothing but superlatives for the shoe, the service and the free shipping is a nice touch. I may never go to a retail shoe store again!

Collecting Heels and Saving Soles, NW, Indiana - Over the past 22 years I've purchased 9 pair of Allen Edmonds shoes, two of which have been the Shelton model (chile/brown and black shark skin). As a person who averages 5-plus miles of walking per day, I'm pleased to report each pair has proved to be very comfortable, incredibly durable, and unsurpassed manufacturing quality. The first pair of AEs I bought, back in 1981, (a Leeds model in burgandy cordovan leather) still sees regular service while showing virtually no deterioration of the leather upper. Congratulations Zappos on the new product line!

Great style and tough AE's - My 5th pair of Allen Edmunds. Very comfortable and durable as all AE's all. Very understated, but classic style. Many of my older coworkers have told me that these are very "40's style". Different, but not obnoxious.