The 39 was too small and the 40 was too big. The narrow fit didn't help either. Such a cool shoe, I'm disappointed they didn't work out.
Zappos Reviewer on September 25, 2021
Tried 38 and 39. I am normally an 8.5. I would of went with the 38's but they kinda hurt my pinky toe.
Zappos Reviewer on September 24, 2021
These are very cool! But, as I've found out, they run small. Will have to exchange.
Zappos Reviewer on September 23, 2021
I ordered these alongside a few pairs of Dolce Vita sneakers. The DV sneakers were way more comfortable because of the memory foam insoles. These P448 aren’t as comfortable but I liked the style. I wore them around at a regatta and came home with blisters on my right pinky toe and left heel. Bummer. I ordered my normal size, too. My go-to sneaker is Gola (which fits my foot amazingly well) so I should probably stick to those. But I dig the style of these P448 because they are on trend right now.
Jen from Cleveland, OH on September 20, 2021
Super cool shoe but it runs small in the length. The toe box is also on the narrow side. I always order a size 11 sneaker (I like my shoes to fit a little on the bigger side) and it was still too small.
Jen from Cleveland, OH on September 15, 2021
Love my new P448 sneakers! I feel like they do run small. I’m normally a 9-9.5 in shoes, I ordered 10 (40) in these and the fit great!
LC_mama from Charlestown, IN on September 13, 2021
First of all, Zappos is amazing. They got these out to me quicker than I expected and had them for a great price. The shoes, however, are not amazing. I’m an 8.5-9US with a sorta wide toe. These things are barely big enough in a 40. And the toe box is snug, in an uncomfortable way. Also they are so stiff I can barely walk in them! I just got them today so I’m hoping they will get better with a little time. I’m definitely disappointed and glad I got them on sale.
Noliecannolli from Madison, Al on September 09, 2021
39 in these are great (John) size wise 38 in Skate are great size wise. both equally soft and comfy ( supportive ) I returned these as the print was a bit too flashy for me. normally 8- 8.5.
RS from Phoenix on July 11, 2021
Adore these. Pricy, but stylish. I find myself grabbing these before my other similar shoes.
Zappos Reviewer from Central Coast, CA on June 18, 2021
These sneakers insanely comfortable. The footbed is padded with memory foam, and the tongue is lined with a soft terry cloth. They are also really cute. I agree with the previous reviewer about the sizing. These run 1/2 size small. I consistently wear a 9 1/2 US (40 EU), so I ordered these in the 40. My big toe was right up against the front of the sneaker even with no socks on. Since they are so comfy and cute, I am reordering the 41 and hoping that they won't be too long or wide.
Zappos Reviewer on June 08, 2021
Be specific about your likes and dislikes. How was the fit and size? What does the material feel like? How awesome (or not) do you feel wearing them?
Zappos Reviewer on May 05, 2021
Fit is way off. Full size too small. The fur on the right shoe is longer than the left. Ordered a second pair to try and make a match but the second pair had the same defect! Tried to order a size larger but Zappos is out of that size. Went to Nordstrom.com &they had the correct size AND $100 less! Wow Zappos........
Zappos Reviewer on March 24, 2021
I am so happy with my purchase. I love golden goose shoes so I thought I would give these a try and I like them even more! So comfortable right away and no waiting to break them in. I’ll be buying more of these
Britt from Nebraska on March 22, 2021
These were not comfortable to my flat foot! Love the look but they felt a little like bowling shoes after walking around in them for a few minutes..
Zappos Reviewer on March 17, 2021
I usually wear a 4.5, when reviews said run small, thought a 5 would work. Still too big
Zappos Reviewer on March 10, 2021
These are really cute shoes but run VERY small. I wear size 11 and the 11’s were WAY too small. Big bummer!
Zappos Reviewer on March 03, 2021
I wear a size 41-42 for most euro sizes. Most US shoes women's 11 just because 10.5 is rare and 10's are usually too small. For this shoe, I bought the 41 to give it a try. I have another P448 style in a 42. The John is at least 1/2 to a full size smaller than a true womens us 11. I wish a size 42 was offered. It would have been perfect. My feet do slide forward a bit and they do hit the front. They may work if i tied them to keep my heel back but then that would ruin the look. I'm very sad.
NT from Chicago on February 16, 2021
Beautiful shoes but they run very small in length. I would recommend ordering one or even two sizes up.
Zappos Reviewer on January 26, 2021
I wear a solid 10 in women's shoes and the size 41 was the most comfortable fit. The 40 felt like a 9.5. Very stylish but stiff and flat as you might expect for a lifestyle fashion sneaker. The toe box is short in height, meaning my toenails hit the top of the shoe. But I love them! Super stylish. I have 2 pairs. Not an all day sneaker, but comfortable enough.
Audrey from Memphis on January 05, 2021
I have been wanting a pair for a long time and I am so glad I got these. The leather is so nice and the insides are perfect. I love these so much I’ll be getting more!
Zappos Reviewer on January 01, 2021
Thank You Zappos for carrying this line. It gave me the chance to see what the hype was about. Not just up my alley on style but comfort and ease of on/off. Normally 38.5 or 39 in Euro sizes..8-8.5 and these in 38 fit like a glove. I have thin flat feet and they just HUG in all the right places. None of my casual sneaks compare to these- closest are some Stevens or Orchid II Golas. But no comparison. Think I found my new obsession!!! They’re squishy soft supportive and love that they are leather not some cheap plastic. Glad I snagged em on sale !
RS from Phoenix on December 22, 2020
Flower/Pink is very cute. The sizing is an issue for me as always when made in Italy. I am an 8, can fit in 7.5, never an 8.5 but with these the 8/38 was too small. My toes hit at the very tip of the shoe. Sized up and have room. The 38 seems like a 7.5 and the 39 seems like an 8.5. The show is very stiff as well but they are such a nice looking sneaker. Good luck.
Zappos Reviewer from NJ on December 19, 2020
These were the most comfy sneakers! I actually loved them and would’ve kept had I not purchased some Golden Goose. The glitter is not overwhelming when paired with a conservative outfit. Highly recommend!
Zappos Reviewer on July 25, 2020
Such a great shoe! Easy to get on and off. They are perfect...and oh so fun!
Amy on June 27, 2020
I am in LOVE with these shoes. They’re so beautiful and comfy and I couldn’t be more excited to wear them! I am usually an 8.5 but after 2 pregnancies I guess I’m a solid 9. I ordered the EU40/US10 thinking they would be way too big, but they fit like a glove! DEFINITELY size up in these, not sure why reviews on other sites say that these run big?
Renee from Illinois on June 22, 2020