I wear a 7.5, had to order an 8. I stand all day at work. Wore for 5hrs before having to change into something a little more comfortable. Super cute and light weight
Zappos Reviewer on July 10, 2020
Cute although a little Frankenstein-ish, very blocky on me. I would have been ok with it but the ankle strap had no give and was very uncomfortable to walk in.
Zappos Reviewer on July 03, 2020
Pretty sandal and fit is fine for a fairly wide foot. The straps are not too tight or stretched out after a year...... even after mountain biking in them!
Zappos Reviewer from Massachusetts on July 01, 2020
This is a cute shoe, but there was a major discrepancy between the way the left foot fit (tight, would have created rubbing on my toe, not much room around the ankle) to the right (looser, more comfortable, how I would prefer). Also experienced an issue with the zipper on the left (I think the tighter fit inhibited its function). The color is pretty but on me it looked too close to my skin tone to look right. Sadly sending them back. I would consider purchasing in another color if they were available and if the feet fit similarly to one another.
Taryn on July 01, 2020
Very lite and cute. Unfortunately the 6.5 was more of a 7. Aldo the ankle strap had no give so they moved very stiff. I would not be able to wear them even if they were in my size. Pls fix the ankle strap!!
Zappos Reviewer on June 30, 2020
Well made and comfortable as with all other OTBT shoes I’ve owned. Very pleased.
Zappos Reviewer on June 23, 2020
Love these shoes! I have a knee replacement and have trouble finding the perfect pain-free shoe. This is it. Have worn with jeans and long dresses. Very stylish. Receive compliments every time.
Zappos Reviewer on June 18, 2020
L-O-V-E these sandals! Seriously in love with them and I didn't even know I needed them in my life. Super comfortable, but with a little lift in the heel that I need. These are not "hard" like some wedges. I have a somewhat narrower than normal foot. Purchased both a 6 1/2 and a 6. They seem to run about half a size large. Kept the 6's. The white and silver combo looks clean and fresh for Summer, especially when paired with bright and neon colors. In fact, there has been nothing I've tried on with these that don't work with them. Considering them? BUY THEM!
Juraszek on June 16, 2020
The ankle strap is quite thin and very stretchy--too stretchy to feel supportive. To fit my average-size ankles, the Velcro strap hangs halfway past the connection. I'm returning because it just won't do for daily use and ankle or general support.
Zappos Reviewer from DENVER on June 09, 2020
Its very stylish. Well made and very comfortable
Jacqueline from Rutherford on June 08, 2020
The 8.5 felt a little small in the toe area but the straps fit perfectly around the ankle and foot itself making it very secure, I was worried that my toes would hang over the edge or something but they didn’t I’m just used to having a tiny bit more room in a 8.5, I think a 9 would be too big in the ankle and foot straps and not fit as securely. It’s a very easy to walk in shoe, it’s comfortable and the width on it is perfect.
Zappos Reviewer on June 06, 2020
Too small and the 9 was too big. Sending them back!
Kara from Chicago on May 29, 2020
Its beautifully made. Color is perfect
Jackie from RUTHERFORD on May 23, 2020
finally a wedge for my narrow foot - adjustable straps. YAY ! A tad on the tall side (why are all wedges sooo tall?),
Zappos Reviewer on May 21, 2020
didnt work for me since I have a high instep. couldnt get my foot in teh show sadly
Zappos Reviewer on May 21, 2020
I ordered the iridescent color. To me they are more gold than silver. I was hoping for more silver. The other straps on the sandal are gold and neutral. I like the little bit of sparkle in the cork sole. They are very comfortable but made for a wider foot. I have a pretty normal did the foot so I am able to get by with the width. No adjustable straps but for my foot they straps fit fine. Seems like they will be pretty comfortable for periods of long wear but have not had them on that long yet.
Zappos Reviewer on May 21, 2020
I love these shoes! They were expensive but worth it. This is my first pair of OTBT shoes and I'd say they run a tad small. I wear a 9 and my foot almost hangs off of the back but I didn't want to go through returning for a 9.5 because I didn't know if they'd then be a bit too big. They have been fine because they are open shoes but might try ordering a 9.5 in this brand in the future. They are comfortable for cute shoes and I get tons of compliments on them!!
JAfan from California on May 12, 2020
I love these shoes & this is my second pair. They are very comfortable & provide nice arch support. I think they run narrow but that’s why they fit me.
Crystal from Montgomery on May 04, 2020
Normally I wear an 8 - 8.5 in sandals and my foot is normal to slightly wide width. With the 8. My toes were a bit too close to the front edge. I exchanged them for an 8.5 which seem better. The sandals are comfortable, like walking on marshmellos. I like the style, the strap close to the ankle is adjustable with velcro. My only issue is that the straps across the toes are a teeny bit loose and arent adjustable. Too bad OTBT didnt put a velcro adjustment there too. Im still debating on whether to keep them or not but they are cute and comfortable (heel height is manageable)
OZ from phoenix on May 02, 2020
True to size-look so cute-comfortable-great for dress up or down, spring or summer-glad I bit the bullet and just bought! So flexible
Zappos Reviewer on May 02, 2020
These shoes are without a doubt one of the most comfortable pairs of shoes I've ever put on. The foot bed is soft and beautifully formed to the foot and the upper leather straps are as soft as butter - I absolutely love them. The style is really beautiful as well and looks so attractive on the foot. I wish there was a greater selection of colors - I would buy more! Note that I typically wear a size 9 and sometimes have to go up to 9.5, which is what I ordered with this shoe and it fit perfectly, so the half size up was just right for me.
Lisa from Los Angeles on April 30, 2020
I'm so particular about my shoes and really wanted to love these shoes but what was disappointing to me was that the right shoe felt tighter around the toes. I so wish the straps were adjustable. Loved the shoe otherwise. <3
Zappos Reviewer on April 21, 2020
I really liked the shoe but the elastic on one of the shoes was too loose, or seemed to stretch out more. They started flip-flopping which is annoying.
Zappos Reviewer on April 17, 2020
OTBT Islander runs 1/2 size big in length but feels more narrow than other OTBT styles imo. I went with a 7.5 & glad I did because of the narrower width. The elastic material is backed with a stiffer inner liner so it keeps its shape & doesn’t seem like it will stretch out. The platform sole is easy to walk in & not heavy, but the insole is not removable for those who need more arch support. Overall, they are cute but I think overpriced.
Kelz from North TX on April 17, 2020
Besides having no arch support, I found these shoes rather ugly. The sole is slippery and rocks. I almost fell down the stairs when I tried them on. They may be OK for the younger generation but not for me.
Lizzy from Upstate NY on April 16, 2020