Allen-Edmonds

Allen-Edmonds Cascade
Posted: Dec 17, 2009 7:36:11 AM
Reviewer: Anonymous from Chicago

Overall:

I like the Allen Edmonds product line because the footwear is American-made, high quality, sturdy, most styles come in narrows and there are factory "recrafting" options from just new heels through total rebuilding with proportionate pricing. So I can afford to buy a great pair of shoes/boots because they'll last forever or can be rebuilt for a reasonable charge if needed. Cascades are a new purchase and they're rugged, very comfortable and a good look during a Chicago winter. I've had them about two weeks and they've become my everyday winter footwear. No polishing required, just an occasional oiling keeps them sharp. I have other Allen Edmonds boots including Stanford that are as comfortable as gloves, but these are nearly as comfortable and a more durable pick for regular wear in snow and mixed precip. Sizing is always true.

Allen-Edmonds Delray
Posted: Dec 15, 2009 10:01:11 AM
Reviewer: Dave W from San Francisco, CA

Overall:

To the point of the pre-9/11 "rules" review above, Allen-Edmonds used fiberglass/composite shanks long before 9/11. In fact, it was always a selling point that you didn't have to even take your shoes off when you hit the metal detector. This fact has nothing to do with new TSA rules because, as all true frequent travelers know, you have to remove your shoes in 99.9% of domestic locations regardless. To the point of construction (above), I've owned Alden and other metal shank shoes and A-Es hold up just as well. The only thing you get with Aldens (for example) that you don't get with A-Es is a bunch more weight. Please enjoy if lugging around extra lbs is your kind of thing. Maybe wear a set of ankle weights while you're at it. To the point of the Delrays in particular, they do have a more narrow toe-box than most A-Es. They aren't as traditional as some of the sleeker or cap-toed styles. Still, they work well for most of my travels and hold up quite well.

Allen-Edmonds McAllister
Posted: Dec 13, 2009 5:16:15 AM
Reviewer: Anonymous from Atlanta, Georgia

Overall:

Note that the leather on these shoes appears to be treated or dimpled such that they do not provide a bright lustrous shine, but only a dull shine. As with all shoes, I have found these to fit more loosely during the first week or two or wearing them as the leather stretches. While the fit and feel of these shoes seems to be very good thus far, I cannot say that they are much more comfortable than, say, the Johnston & Murphy shoes that I own. \r\n\r\nZappos continues to impress me, by processing my return of one size of this shoes that did not fit with surprising speed. I wish that more internet retailers would follow Zappos\' lead in exceptional customer service.\r\n

Allen-Edmonds Back Bay
Posted: Dec 6, 2009 6:10:01 AM
Reviewer: Anonymous from

Overall:

The shoe has a great sole (good for cushioning impact) and a nice style. Alas, I am having a problem with fit in one of the shoes unlike any other shoe I've had, and I didn't detect it until after wearing the shoe outside and scuffing up the sole so I can't return it. The top of the left shoe cuts into the lower outside ankle. If you have adequate carpeting, I'd suggest wearing it around the house for two or three hours before you wear it outside. The Zappos website suggests buying the shoe a half-size small, but for size 9 I consider it true to size.

Allen-Edmonds Stowe
Posted: Nov 28, 2009 5:35:50 PM
Reviewer: David M from Boston, MA

Overall:

Very comfortable, good looking shoe. Only time will tell how well they wear, but I am encouraged by the construction of these shoes and Allen Edmonds reputation for quality. Important Point: When you buy loafers, purchase one-half size smaller than what you ordinarily wear. Otherwise, they will flop around on your feet as they stretch-out over time.

Allen-Edmonds Back Bay
Posted: Nov 19, 2009 7:38:44 AM
Reviewer: Anonymous from Arizona

Overall:

We are 70. We are very busy, still work full-time. We have been Zappos customers for several years. Recently I ordered a couple pairs of Allen-Edmonds shoes for my husband. He wears a 3E and Allen-Edmonds is the only company that I have found to have a wide selection of men's dress shoes in 3E. On this particular occasion one of the shoes I ordered was Allen-Edmonds Back Bay in Burgundy. By the time it arrived I just knew the burgundy would look "pink" and he would hate it. I was prepared to ship it right back. However, it is absolutely gorgeous addition to his shoe wardrobe. Basically, I buy all of our shoes at Zappos.

Allen-Edmonds Cody
Posted: Nov 18, 2009 11:44:25 AM
Reviewer: Darren R from Houston, Texas

Overall:

This is hands down the most comfortable and best looking dress shoe I have ever worn. I have worn several different brands before including Cole Haan, Bostonian, and Johnston & Murphy. While I have have enjoyed them all, especially J & M, this eclipses them all. You can see and feel the quality the moment they come out of the box. Allen Edmonds will be my shoe brand from now on. They are a little expensive, but you get what you pay for! Try them, you won't be sorry. On a side note, Zappos has the best customer service of any company I have ever seen. I work with the public, and they give the kind of service that is so important today. Awesome shoe! Awesome company!

Allen-Edmonds Park Avenue
Posted: Nov 13, 2009 5:04:14 PM
Reviewer: Anonymous from san diego

Overall:

Bought these for my husband; he loved them and got compliments the first time he wore them. Very well made, and love the fact that they can be refurbished again and again. High quality.

Allen-Edmonds Maxfield
Posted: Nov 9, 2009 6:39:41 PM
Reviewer: Charles K from Maryland

Overall:

I purchased a pair of these shoes. Very snug fit, but very comfortable. First time I wore them on business trip, the heel fell off. I called the Allen Edmonds and asked for a store in Manhattan, NYC to exchange the shoes. Their reply was I could only send them back to the company, no retail stores in Manhattan, NYC. I got home walking, with great difficulty, to Washington DC with one heel broken off. Sent shoes back and then the company told me that this shoe did not fit my size 8D and that I should buy another, quite a bit more expensive. I did purchase the shoes and two years later the the shoes were so painful that I tossed them into my closet never to be worn again. A lot of money down the tubes.

Allen-Edmonds Back Bay
Posted: Nov 5, 2009 5:14:48 AM
Reviewer: M M from VA

Overall:

Wore these right out of the box and they were comfortable. I seldom wear dress shoes, but found these attractive and true to size. I wear a wide shoe and it is hard to find such quality and style. And they arrived in one day so I had them to wear for a presentation I was making the next day.

Allen-Edmonds Maxfield
Posted: Nov 4, 2009 7:14:43 AM
Reviewer: Glenn M from Chicago

Overall:

Superb construction, classic styling. Obviously pricey, but it is a high end shoe. Fairly true to size, but might be a bit narrow to some people. Ordered it in 3E and they fit well, but still snug. For those needing wider widths, I would recommend going all the way to the widest available.

Allen-Edmonds Shelton
Posted: Nov 3, 2009 6:09:19 PM
Reviewer: Anonymous from Reston, VA

Overall:

Nicely styled show, but I have to question the quality on this one, especially compared to other Allen Edmonds I own. The leather is very stiff (not in a good way) and produces large permanent creases at every spot the shoe bends. Definitely sub-par leather compared to my other AE shoes. In addition, the sidce heights around the ankle are different heights between the left shoe and right shoe. The left outside edge is a half inch higher and actually hits the bottom of my ankle. Poor quality control. Hard to believe these were made in the same factory as my other AE shoes which are all of top quality. Overall can not recommend due to overall poor quality, especially at this price point! Although the style itself is great and gets compliments. Wish I would have returned them before wearing.

Allen-Edmonds Manchester
Posted: Nov 3, 2009 1:48:42 PM
Reviewer: Frederick M from Ohio

Overall:

Product was as advertised. Good quality shoe. Shipping was as advertised and product arrived in good condition. Best thing, no sales tax. Would purchase again via this website.

Allen-Edmonds Park Avenue
Posted: Oct 31, 2009 5:25:05 AM
Reviewer: Anonymous from Reston, VA

Overall:

Excellent dress shoe. Top quality, comfortable. Goes with a wider variety of business attire without the wingtip detailing. My favorite all around dress shoe for business an interviews. Minimal arch support compared to some competing brands but very comfortable nonetheless

Allen-Edmonds McAllister
Posted: Oct 30, 2009 5:58:30 AM
Reviewer: Kevin M from California

Overall:

Allen Edmonds has achieved a perfect Price/Quality/Style formula designed heavily with the consumer in mind. A win win win! More importantly is the Zappos Customer Service team and the way they execute quickly to support the needs of their customer base. In advance of Zappos receiving a returned item physically they (Zappos CS team) applied the advanced returned credit to my replacement purchase immediately. 5 stars to the Zappos organization! Refreshing!

Allen-Edmonds McClain
Posted: Oct 28, 2009 10:37:15 AM
Reviewer: Forrest K from New York City

Overall:

Beautifully constructed, with a nice overall shape. I am looking forward to many years of use from this classic piece of my wardrobe. It is an absolutely beautiful shoe.

Allen-Edmonds McClain
Posted: Oct 28, 2009 9:28:50 AM
Reviewer: Anonymous from San Jose CA

Overall:

Excellent online catalog; very clear and detailed and easy to use. Very good prices; comparable with the best available online retail prices. Amazingly fast delivery. Very simple return or exchange process also. My wife and I now tend to look at Zappos first for many clothing needs.

Allen-Edmonds Wilbert
Posted: Oct 22, 2009 5:45:13 AM
Reviewer: from Duluth, Minnesota

Overall:

Excellent!This shoe is dressy enough for my work, teaching, and is exceptionally comfortable. I take a narrow width so finding comfortable shoes was difficult.

Allen-Edmonds Winhall
Posted: Oct 21, 2009 7:30:36 AM
Reviewer: Yvette G from Washington state

Overall:

My husband bought these shoes for our son's wedding. He has bought the Allen Edmonds brand on several occasions and has always been pleased with the style and craftsmanship of this manufacturer. He wore these shoes at the wedding for the first time. After being on his feet most of the day and evening, including dancing for a few hours, he felt his feet were as comfortable in the shoes as when he first put them on.

Allen-Edmonds Ashton
Posted: Oct 17, 2009 7:30:36 AM
Reviewer: from San Diego, CA

Overall:

For years I have bought shoes under a $100, but they never lasted very long. I have read many reviews of the shoes here on Zappos as well as others. At first I was skeptical spending this much for a pair of shoes, but I am very happy with these shoes so far. I purchased both the brown (chili) and black versions of this shoe. I love the brown one so I ordered the black one as well. I have gotten many compliments at the office wearing the brown shoe. The shoes look sharp and go well with chinos and dress pants. The shoes are very comfortable with the removable orthotic insert and the vibram non- slip outsole. When you are on your feet all or most of the day, you will appreciate the comfort.

Allen-Edmonds Presidio
Posted: Oct 15, 2009 5:57:13 AM
Reviewer: Robert S. from Maine

Overall:

Great shoes! I always buy Allen Edmond's but have noticed that all models with non leather soles are slightly bigger than usual, I chose my usual size of 9D and with lightweight socks they are not as snug as I like them , fortunately the shoes are for those times that a heavier sock is indicated.

Allen-Edmonds Wide Basic Dress
Posted: Oct 8, 2009 7:01:20 AM
Reviewer: Aaron from New York, NY

Overall:

Needed a belt in a hurry and Zappos came thru. Only issue is that these run a bit small in size. Great belt. Greater company!

Allen-Edmonds Bel Air
Posted: Oct 5, 2009 7:28:00 PM
Reviewer: Anonymous from new jersey

Overall:

I purchased the two tone Bel Air. I get nothing but compliments when I wear them. I have been searching for the longest time for a two tone mens dress shoe. They were either too "flashy" or cheap looking. This two tone has style and class. Very comfortable, too.

Allen-Edmonds Back Bay
Posted: Oct 4, 2009 8:19:19 AM
Reviewer: Robin H from Pewaukee,Wisconsin

Overall:

I bought these shoes for my son and he loves them. He says they are the most comfortable shoes he owns. I did buy them a half size smaller than he normally wears.

Allen-Edmonds Bucktown
Posted: Oct 3, 2009 3:40:55 PM
Reviewer: Steven w from chicago, il

Overall:

Shoes look great. They have very long toe box so I\'d recommend ordering a half size smaller than normal. My right shoe bends at a weird place and digs into my big toe. It\'s only on one shoe and I\'m hoping it softens up as I wear them in. Overall, good looking shoes, not the most comfortable I\'ve ever worn.