Available 24/7 at (800) 927-7671

Join Zappos Rewards & Get Expedited Shipping + Earn Points on Every Order!

My Cart

Sam Edelman Petty Reviews

Customer Reviews
4Rated 4 stars
4 out of 5 stars (1292 reviews)
1292 reviews
total

Overall Rating:

65%5Rated 5 stars

16%4Rated 4 stars

11%3Rated 3 stars

5%2Rated 2 stars

3%1Rated 1 stars

Customer Fit Survey:

78%"Felt true to size"

76%"Felt true to width"

71%"Moderate arch support"

Additional 1292 Petty Sam Edelman Reviews

Search
  • Sort by:
  • Most Helpful
  • Newest

« Previous 1 2 3 4 ... 52 Next »

2 people found this review helpful
Aubrey B from Destin, FL
5Rated 5 stars
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:5Rated 5 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
These are too cute for words! These are my favorite buy so far this season. I saw them in a magazine and finally found them at Zappos. They feel great and look great!
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Aubrey B - customer
  • from Destin, FL
  • September 28, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
Toledo Ohio
5Rated 5 stars
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:5Rated 5 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
I haven't actually worn them out yet because it's still been too warm, but they fit fine and seemed comfortable enough in my house. They are incredibly cute in person and that was confirmed by my husband's eye roll when he saw them.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • from Toledo Ohio
  • September 22, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
Deborah K from Leawood, Kansas
5Rated 5 stars
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:5Rated 5 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
These shoes are true to size, very fashionable and comfortable brand new. No breaking in required.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

  • Deborah K - customer
  • from Leawood, Kansas
  • September 18, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
Lauri F from Salt Lake City, Utah
5Rated 5 stars
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:5Rated 5 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
This is a beautiful boot. I ordered it in the moss green color and it is more brownish than green and a very rich looking. The boot runs true to size and well worth the money. I got it the very next day. Zappos you are amazing!
I'd also recommend:
Frye and Munro
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Lauri F - customer
  • from Salt Lake City, Utah
  • September 15, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
Sharon D from Washington, DC
5Rated 5 stars
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:5Rated 5 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
I just received these tonight and I love them. Great quality suede, very comfortable footbed, nice low heel on days I want a break. I got Putty; it's a great neutral. The shoe structure is a little narrow, as compared to the toe on a more rounded, cowboy-style boot. If you're feet are on the wide side, I'd size up a half size. That's what I did and they feel great. I can't wait to wear these shoes with skinny jeans, leggings and skirts.
I'd also recommend:
Dolce Vita
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Sharon D - customer
  • from Washington, DC
  • September 2, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
Midwest
5Rated 5 stars
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:5Rated 5 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
Fabulous, well made boots! I purchased these in the neutral color - go with everything color! Thank you Sam Edelman for making a boot with a decent sized heel - and comfortable! Thank you Zappos for the quick service! Buy these boots! Don't forget to spray them like you would your Uggs! Ten Stars!
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • from Midwest
  • August 30, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
5Rated 5 stars
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:5Rated 5 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
I recently purchased these booties and they are wonderful. I have a longer thin foot and these boots worked well for me. The sides hit just at my ankle bone. The heel gives you a tiny lift. I have already worn the boots many times, and they broke in quickly. I suggest spraying them with a suede protector.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • August 13, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
Minnesota
4Rated 4 stars
Overall:4Rated 4 starsComfort:3Rated 3 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
I like the look of these boots. The soles & heels seem well made, but the boot upper is layers & the suede seems sort of thin. They're not a good walking shoe for me - not enough cushioning or support.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

No arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • from Minnesota
  • January 2, 2012
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
4Rated 4 stars
Overall:4Rated 4 starsComfort:3Rated 3 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
Great shoe. A little uncomfortable (not much arch support) but super cute.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt narrower than marked

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • October 25, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
San Diego, CA
4Rated 4 stars
Overall:4Rated 4 starsComfort:4Rated 4 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
I just received these today in the putty color. It is a great neutral that will go with almost everything. I think these run a little narrow, although my feet are on the wide side. I like that the toe is neither too pointed nor too round. Can't wait to wear these as soon the weather cools off.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt narrower than marked

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • from San Diego, CA
  • September 27, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
4Rated 4 stars
Overall:4Rated 4 starsComfort:4Rated 4 starsStyle:4Rated 4 stars
Was this review helpful?
I really dig these boots. Nice quality construction and soft suede. Cool color too - kind of mossy/olive green. Worried about wearing them in the rain though so I haven't been able to wear them yet. But I'm looking forward to it.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • September 7, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
ES from Los Angeles
3Rated 3 stars
Overall:3Rated 3 starsComfort:4Rated 4 starsStyle:2Rated 2 stars
Was this review helpful?
Got this pair in black. Meh. Boring. Bland. Very cute on the web, very blah in real life.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

  • ES - customer
  • from Los Angeles
  • March 8, 2012
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
Brooklyn, New York
3Rated 3 stars
Overall:3Rated 3 starsComfort:3Rated 3 starsStyle:4Rated 4 stars
Was this review helpful?
These felt really narrow in the heel, and I have narrow feet. No major complaints about the style but I had to send them back.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt narrower than marked

Poor SupportGreat Support

No arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • from Brooklyn, New York
  • October 10, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
NYC
3Rated 3 stars
Overall:3Rated 3 starsComfort:4Rated 4 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
Loved the style and price point, didn't like the putty color in person. On the computer screen, the color looked perfect, but when I received the boot, I didn't like it at all. May be better in black.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt a half size smaller than marked

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • from NYC
  • October 1, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
United States
3Rated 3 stars
Overall:3Rated 3 starsComfort:2Rated 2 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
These boots look good and fit my feet well. Unfortunately the side zipper hurts my foot. Since I plan to wear thin socks with them, I know the zipper will always bother me. So sorry to return.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Excellent arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • from United States
  • September 20, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
Reneeg010 from Hoboken, NJ
2Rated 2 stars
Overall:2Rated 2 starsComfort:1Rated 1 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
Really hard soles, bottom of shoes look really cheaply made. Huge bummer because I love the style and the color and the heel height. Looked great on. But cannot do that to my feet.
I'd also recommend:
Born Crown
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Reneeg010 - customer
  • from Hoboken, NJ
  • January 6, 2012
2 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review helpful
Cleveland, OH
2Rated 2 stars
Overall:2Rated 2 starsComfort:1Rated 1 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
Wish I could love them, but I can't as they hurt my feet just to try on! Very sharp looking, but narrow on the toes, the sides of big toes, ouch! And I don't have a wide foot, average width for a narrow foot this shoe is a must have though. I also got the Sam Edelman leopard flats with studs on the toe, those worked!
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt narrower than marked

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • from Cleveland, OH
  • August 31, 2011
2 people found this review helpful
1 person found this review helpful
Daphne, AL
5Rated 5 stars
Review for Zappos Rewards Points(What's this?)
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:3Rated 3 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
Toe box is too narrow for my foot.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • from Daphne, AL
  • March 28, 2017
1 person found this review helpful
1 person found this review helpful
Susanna from California
5Rated 5 stars
Review for Zappos Rewards Points(What's this?)
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:4Rated 4 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
I love these boots. The leather is buttery soft. I wore them in rain and they cam out looking the same. I usually wear a 7 1/2 or 8. I ordered these in a 7.5. They felt a little bit tight through the instep but good overall. I used a shoe stretcher for just a couple of hours on each boot because the leather is so supple. After that, they were perfect. I love wearing them. They go with everything.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt narrower than marked

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Susanna - customer
  • from California
  • January 19, 2017
1 person found this review helpful
1 person found this review helpful
Sillie P from USA
5Rated 5 stars
Review for Zappos Rewards Points(What's this?)
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:5Rated 5 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
Putting these boots on right out of the box, I was disappointed. I found them difficult to get on and difficult to zip. The leather felt hard and the shoe was uncomfortable, too tight. I was preparing to send them back, looking on Zappos for a replacement. I like the style so much, the next day I put on a pair of medium weight socks and tried the shoes again. This time they were easier to put and zip. I wore them around on the carpet for a while and realized they felt pretty good. I wore them with socks around on the carpet the next day and boy am I glad I did not send them back. I wore the boots for about 5 hours just cooking and doing light chores around the house. They were very comfy, the toe box is roomy enough and I my arches did not ache. The heel height is perfect and the boot did not rub my ankles. They are plain without a lot of embellishment and I like that too. So now after all this, I love the the boot. Can't explain it, don't care. Just know I like them now.
I'd also recommend:
Merrell, Frye, Keen, Clarks
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Sillie P - customer
  • from USA
  • October 30, 2016
1 person found this review helpful
1 person found this review helpful
Nan R from Ann Arbor, MIchigan
5Rated 5 stars
Review for Zappos Rewards Points(What's this?)
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:5Rated 5 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
These booties are lovely. I like a smooth look and these are perfect. I wore them for the first time yesterday to a tailgate party, and they were comfortable all day without any break-in period. Highly recommend!
I'd also recommend:
Munroe
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Nan R - customer
  • from Ann Arbor, MIchigan
  • October 30, 2016
1 person found this review helpful
1 person found this review helpful
Sara H from St. Louis, Missouri
5Rated 5 stars
Review for Zappos Rewards Points(What's this?)
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:4Rated 4 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
Contrary to many women that I know, I don't have oodles of shoes and pick new purchases carefully based on their versatility, comfort, and cuteness. These are quality booties that fit all those standards! They go with just about everything, and the heel height is just enough to give an extra boost. I was able to just start walking 2-3 miles in them very early. Worth mentioning, the toe box is slightly narrow/elongated, and Sam Edelman shoes have very flat insides. I sized down from my normal 9.5 to a 9, but I may have kept the 9.5 if I were to insert Superfeet (which I did with my pair of Sam Edelman Pennys - made a huge difference) . I didn't feel that was necessary for these booties though. Highly recommended!!
I'd also recommend:
Frye
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt a half size larger than marked

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

No arch support

  • Sara H - customer
  • from St. Louis, Missouri
  • October 29, 2016
1 person found this review helpful
1 person found this review helpful
NYC
5Rated 5 stars
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:4Rated 4 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
Adore this bootie! Have in many colors. runs true, I'm size 7M and the 7M is okay, but the ones that were available in a wide I took 7W because it's just more comfy at the toe area. Basically, everyone wrote it all, I just need to tell you guys that I was hesitant to order the "honey" color, because it appeared yellowish (at least on my computer), but I received them today and not yellowish whatsoever! I am so glad, because not only are they not yellow, which I would've used for specific times because unusual, but they are a light tan color. perfectly neutral. They are gorgeous. I am taking off one star, only because the insole is not as padded as I would have liked. They're comfortable, but they could've been even more.
I'd also recommend:
softwalk, clarks, the flexx,
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt narrower than marked

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • from NYC
  • March 1, 2016
1 person found this review helpful
1 person found this review helpful
Charlotte from Orange County, CA
5Rated 5 stars
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:4Rated 4 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
I love these shoes! I was concerned that my usual size would not fit based on some of the reviews, but I ordered it anyway. The first time I tried them on, the shoes were very tight across the ball of my foot, even though I do not have wide feet. However, the length was perfect and it was comfortable around my toes and at my heel. I figured that I would put on thick socks and wear them around the house, and after about two days they fit perfectly. I have worn them every day since, they look great with everything. I bought them in putty and I am ready to order all the other colors. They are not as comfortable as say, sneakers for running around all day, but I have spent many hours walking in them and my feet do not hurt at the end of the day. I'm tall (5'11") and even a 1½" heel is a little out of my comfort zone because I am already the same height as my husband, but I am very pleased with these shoes and the height is insubstantial enough that I barely notice. They are very fashionable, look great with skinny jeans, and pull a whole outfit together while still remaining causal enough for daily wear. I have mo complaints!
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Charlotte - customer
  • from Orange County, CA
  • December 13, 2015
1 person found this review helpful
1 person found this review helpful
Ohio
5Rated 5 stars
Overall:5Rated 5 starsComfort:5Rated 5 starsStyle:5Rated 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
The Petty is even better looking in person! The suede is soft and the Putty color is a great neutral. Looks great with skinny jeans and dresses. I normally wear a 9.5 in most shoes and the 9.5 fit perfectly in this style.
Fit Survey
Runs SmallRuns Large

Felt true to size

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Felt true to width

Poor SupportGreat Support

Moderate arch support

  • Zappos Reviewer
  • from Ohio
  • November 19, 2015
1 person found this review helpful

Shop with Confidence

Cart

Shopping on zappos.com is Safe

Safe Shopping Guarantee
Zappos Family Culture

Learn what inspires Zappos.com to provide the best service!

Zappos Family Core Values:10 Values We Live By »

Customer Testimonials:Customers Connect »

Enjoy Fun and A Little Weirdness:Check out Blogs »

The Zappos.com Experience:Share Your Videos »

Unique Customers:Furry Customers »
Customers In Training »

Become a Part of the Zappos Family Culture:Careers »

Shop With Confidence
Shopping on Zappos.com is Safe and Secure. Guaranteed!

You'll pay nothing if unauthorized charges are made to your credit card as a result of shopping at Zappos.com.

Safe Shopping Guarantee

BBBOnLine Reliability SealBizrate 2010 Circle of Excellence Platinum

All information is encrypted and transmitted without risk using a Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) protocol.

How We Protect Your Personal Data »

Free Shipping
and Free Returns

If, for any reason, you are unsatisfied with your purchase from Zappos Retail, Inc. you may return it in its original condition within 365 days for a refund. We'll even pay for return shipping!

Read our Shipping and Return Policies »

Privacy Policy

Zappos.com respects your privacy. We don't rent or sell your personal information to anyone.

Read our Privacy Policy »

Thank You for Registering!

Now, don't miss out on the good stuff...