J&M EST. 1850
This is a very handsome shoe, though it looks and feels oversized, both in length and width in the toe box. I would attempt to get a half size down, but there is no 12.5.
Zappos Reviewer on October 09, 2020
Elegant yet sporty. High quality suede and craftsmanship.
Zappos Reviewer on April 07, 2020
Zappos Reviewer on March 23, 2020
9.5 size felt closer to a 10 or 10.5. Very uncomfortable out of the box, although they may be better after break-in. Disappointed in the fit as they appear to be a well-made shoe.
Zappos Reviewer on March 06, 2020
Horrible fit and very stiff shoe. Looks good but feels bad
Zappos Reviewer on February 18, 2020
Very good quality, stylish and comfortable. Definitely I recommend it.
Zappos Reviewer on February 10, 2020
Thankful I took others advice and ordered a half size bigger. Definitely slick on the bottom so have to scuff them in. But it is a great looking boot!
Zappos Reviewer on February 06, 2020
True to size. I like the quality, the looks and the comfort. Buy it and it will be your favorite Boots.
Zappos Reviewer on February 04, 2020
Shoe overall is really nice looking. Color and design gives shoe character. Suede is a little thin and potentially wear off at top of shoe when sliding foot into it. Highly suggest shoe horn be used to minimize friction of foot entry.
Zappos Reviewer on February 01, 2020
I was really excited to try this shoe. It looks nice and feels well made. The fit through the achilles heel was loose for me. I tend to need a tighter fit there... However, I do have wide feet. If I went down a half size the width wouldn't have worked. Zappos was great to deal with.
John from West Des Moines on January 28, 2020
Wow what a fine pair of shoes! Extremely well made in Italy. I wear these with a pair of dark jeans and they look awesome. Highest quality materials and craftsmanship.
CH from Dallas on January 16, 2020
A little on the heavy side, but good leather, well made, and comfortable.
Jeremy from Williston on January 14, 2020
Sweet rides, I love these shows. Comfy out of the box, no break-in, well made, well priced, A+ for me!
Scott K from Greenwich on January 05, 2020
Fit is true to size and width for me (size 11M, normal width D) Soles are leather so beware that until they get stuffed up a little they will be slick. Otherwise a great stylish boot that takes minimal break in time and is comfortable to wear all day.
Zappos Reviewer on January 04, 2020
these shoes are way too small
Lee from San Francisco on December 31, 2019
I find J&M shoes to be very consistent in their fit and sizing, I have been wearing J&M shoes since 2004 and a 9-1/2D is what fits me.
Steve from Fredericksburg on December 14, 2019
As a regular J&M customer, the width and size was perfect. I wear these with my suit on my daily commute to work and it matches well. Comfortable and stylish.
SYT from New York suburbs on November 16, 2019
Best dress shoe I have ever owned! Extremely comfortable and excellent style!
Chris from Waco on October 01, 2019
Excellent shoe. Looks amazing and received a compliment first day I wore them. Works with jeans and slacks and comfortable right out of the box. Will be getting other colors as well.
Zappos Reviewer on September 23, 2019
Decent, but a bit wide
Zappos Reviewer on June 06, 2019
I think the size is spot on. I'm usually between a 7 1/2 and an 8 and these are an 8. I wanted to allow a little extra room to be able to wear a thicker sock in the winter. They were a little stiff the first day but after wearing them a couple times they are very comfortable now. I think the color is great. The picture I think makes them look a bit more red than they actually are. I guess that could be good or bad depending on what you were going for. In reality they are a nice brown, with the toe being slightly darker than the rest of the boot. The only reason I'm not giving these boots a 5 Star rating is I think there should be 4 eyelets instead of 3.
Mike from Madison on May 29, 2019
I always by Johnston & Murphy shoes and this was the first set that runs smaller than the rest. I'm assuming it's the model/type. Unfortunate because it looks like a nice shoe
Zappos Reviewer on April 10, 2019
I wear them to work and am on my feet most of the day....very comfortable.
Zappos Reviewer on February 17, 2019