Type Z Cathy SKU #7323987(View on Zappos.com Classic)

They are beautiful, but I believed the other reviews that they fit small and went against my better judgment and ordered a half size bigger. They would have been perfect in my own size (I have narrow feet). But with an insole they are great with skirts or trousers, love them. Delivery was speedy, even to Canada, thanks Zappos!

Cute, but not super comfortable. I ordered the brown leather in an 11 wide. Sometimes wides are too wide for me, but these were not really wide enough. They felt pretty comfortable when I first put them on, but as I wore them throughout the day they started to hurt a bit. They aren't the most comfortable shoes I have ever owned, but I'm keeping them since I wore them already. I'm hoping the more I wear them the more they'll stretch out a bit. I would not recommend for a person who only can wear wide shoes. You won't find these comfortable for you.

I really needed a nice pair of black flats, and these certainly fit the bill! They’re quite pointy, so be prepared. Overall, the shoes are well made, comfortable, and stylish. One note of caution, they do seem to run a little narrow, so bear that in mind.

These shoes are too cute. I wear a narrow shoe, but took the chance that an insert would work, and it did. I wear these with shorts, slacks, skirts and dresses. I always get compliments. Good foundation shoe for your wardrobe. Only drawback is there is no arch support at all and your feet ache at the end of a long day.

The feel a bit flimsy and have bent a crease along the pad of my foot just from trying them on in the house. The style shows no toe cleavage. I'm sending them back because they look too conservative/witch-esque. They're super pointy!

I love wearing these shoes, but I am disappointed about the crease at the tip of the toe, which formed pretty much right away. On the advice of other reviewers, I ordered a wide - the only wide shoes I've ever had - and that worked out perfectly. I'm a size 12 and they're very comfortable and any stiffness went away quickly enough that I've forgotten about it. All things considered, it's an excellent entree into pointy shoes!

I agree that the shoe is rather stiff and uncomfortable. The band of trim sewn around the opening looks better in the photograph than it does in person. I'm afraid these are going back. FYI The gold version has a white background with metallic gold spots

Type Z Cathy - Agree with the reviewer who said they were not as refined in appearance as she had hoped, and they're a little stiff, which hopefully will improve with wear.

Cute style...but I wish it came in 1/2 sizes. I ordered these in a 6 and a 7 in the soft gold color and found the 6 to be too narrow and the size 7 to be a bit too long. It is a nice looking rain boot and it appears it would be great in the winter since it has the thermal lining. My only concern is that the warm lining will get easily dirty through use especially when wearing them over skinny jeans. The dye from the darker rinsed jeans would transfer to the cuff detail. I wanted to like them, but they really are not as practical for me considering the price and folded over lined cuff. I prefer to wear the popular Scottish brand instead. As always, Zappos delivered the very next day. What wonderful and expeditious service!