To Boot New York

These are pretty comfortable shoes, although I had to get them half a size smaller. They are pretty well made and broke in pretty quickly.

Color me impressed. I normally don't spend this much on sandals but everything about them is consistent with the price. I returned 2 other pairs of high-end sandals before settling on these. I had bought a pair of To Boot sandals in the past and loved the style. But to be honest, they didn't fit me that well which resulted in me not wearing them that often. These things exude quality, style and are really comfortable. These are not normal flip flops. The straps are wider than they look in the pictures which really contributes to the style. I like flip flops but wanted something stylish and age appropriate. Basically, I didn't want to look like a 40-something guy trying to appear to be a casual, stoner surfer. Or, even worse, a post-adolescent, frat guy wannabe. I've got thin feet and these fit perfectly, although I think they would stretch out to accommodate normal feet. The sandals are just wide enough to accommodate most feet. Big thumbs up!

These shoes did not fit. They are very snug fit across top and ankle. Even if they had fit, the shoes were scuffed like someone had worn them. That is disappointing because they were good looking boots.

This is my first pair of To Boot New York shoes, but I would recommend them to anyone. The leather is buttery soft and the overall quality is terrific. Great style, well made and extremely comfortable. Usually I have to break in a pair of shoes for some time, but these were great right out of the box. I recommend sizing down a half to full size however, especially for the loafer if you plan to wear without socks (which you should).

Two words: Straight pimpin'! In all seriousness. I love the look of this shoe. I had some concerns of To Boot in general given that there are multitude of factory sources for the brand. But this specific model did not appear to have any negative reviews through my research. Glad I took a chance on them. I could not find any other oxford that I liked as much as these. I love them and they seem to be holding up well so far.

These shoes are awesome. Look great, very comfortable and Zappos as you already know is great. Best customer service out there.

Wonderfully made and equally comfortable! This fine shoe has become one of my favorites! I am typically a large size 15 or a small size 16, and the size 15 fits like a glove.

High quality shoe that can be worn with a suit or a pair of slacks...this is the type of wing-tip I was looking for, a classy and durable shoe and the price was excellent! Zappos is my "go to" place for buying shoes...excellent service (had to return a pair that I wasn't happy with in order to find these!).

I love boots, and I love To Boot New York boots. I've owned a few over the course of my life. I just bought the Randy in black. It's a decent boot, but maybe just a little too trendy for my style. (The Shane is more my style.) The Randy is intentionally too long in the toe, so that even a pair that fits will have an extra inch of length. Looks just a little too close to clown shoes, like you have fingers for toes. I saw this in the Zappos video, and, unfortunately, that's what the boots look like in real life. Also, the side zip comes down a little too far forward, so it's more visible than it needs to be. Personally, I am not a fan of rubber soles on boots anyway, and the soles on this boot are just a little too thin to look good quality. I'm usually a big fan of To Boot, but I'm sending this pair back.

Great shoe, excellent style and color but just wasn't what I was looking for so back to Zappos! I would recommend this shoe, however.

Like the well broken in baseball glove I had as a kid. I have gotten plenty of compliments every time I wear these, they are modern and stylish and extremely comfortable (once I got them stretched). They were tight in the toe, so I would go up a width if ordering them again - but these shoes are beautifully crafted, extremely comfortable and well worth the price.

This is a beautiful shoe. The reason I purchased this shoe is that it is more versatile than my Bluchers (or any traditional dress shoe) and I could throw these on with a blue suit, slacks and open collar or jeans on a Saturday evening. However, aside from style and versatility, I am disappointed with these shoes. I have multiple pair of Allen Edmonds which I have owned in excess of five years, resoled and recrafted, which maintain better than my TBNY which I have owned for less than one year (I am fastidious about shoe care). Furthermore, the seams on the shoe are extremely sloppy and leather on the outside of the seams is starting to fray in multiple locations. Again, this is a beautiful shoe and perhaps appropriate for a casual Friday or Saturday night, but I think this shoe is priced on its style, and not quality. Certainly everybody has different reasons for and expectations when purchasing a shoe. If you have an eye toward quality before style, I may suggest seeking a different shoemaker. If you have a budget that enables you to purchase stylish/fun shoes at this price, these guys fit the bill (and, yes, I will repeat, they are a great looking shoe for the first few months). If you expect years of wear out of a pair of shoes at this price, as aforementioned, I might suggest looking elsewhere.

This is a beautiful shoe. The reason I purchased this shoe is that it is more versatile than my bluchers (or any traditional dress shoe) and I could throw these on with a blue suit, slacks and open collar or jeans on a Saturday evening. However, aside from style and versatility, I am disappointed with these shoes. I have multiple pair of Allen Edmonds which I have owned in excess of five years, resoled and recrafted, which maintain better than my TBNY which I have owned for less than one year (I am fastidious about shoe care). Furthermore, the seems on the shoe are extremely sloppy and leather on the outside of the seems is starting to fray in multiple locations. Again, this is a beautiful shoe and perhaps appropriate for a casual Friday or Saturday night, but I think this shoe is priced on its style, and not quality. Certainly everybody has different reasons for and expectations when purchasing a shoe. If you have an eye toward quality before style, I may suggest seeking a different shoemaker. If you have a budget that enables you to purchase stylish/fun shoes, these guys fit the bill (and, yes, I will repeat, they are a grey looking shoe for the first few months). If you expect years of wear out of a pricey pair of shoes, as aforementioned, I might suggest looking elsewhere.

One of the most attractive shoes I've had the privilege to wear. The shoes look even nicer and better shaped than in the photos. The last is beautiful, clearly more Euro-inspired but subtle enough to avoid strangeness. The details are a wonderful balance of decorative flair and restrained simplicity. Fit at a 1/2 size down seems correct, a bit snug, but is already conforming to my foot as I break it in. Quality shoe. Construction seems excellent, certainly you won't find anything nicer at this price.

Great looking shoe. I had to size down a full size from what I typically wear but the overall fit is great. Haven't worn them a lot yet so not sure on the comfort level.

Beautiful shoe but the 8 was way too big which I couldn't believe since I am border line 8 8-1/2 with a moderately wide foot. The width was fine, the shoe was roomy but that may have been because it was too big. I wonder if it was the wrong size. With my luck now the 7.5 is out of stock.

Great pair of shoes. Bought these for my wedding and they were amazing. Got a ton of compliments, too, which never hurts.

Great feel, great look. I wear a size 11 and ordered these in 10.5... Perfect fit. I'm glad I took a fellow reviewers advice. Now I have to order these in BROWN. Makes any suit that much better

These are really fashionable and I get a great deal of compliments whenever I wear them. Not a big fan of the creasing at the front of the foot and of the laces. The leather is a bit tough at first, however I've only worn them 4 times til date, so hopefully I just lit gets better over time.

I ordered my regular size 11.5 and had to return it for the 11. It fits well, however I have noticed some rubbing on one of my heels. Overall, very nice looking shoe and comfortable.