Julie

from nyc

I bought these in black suede, size 10 and loved them so much I ordered a second pair in the oxblood color. Very comfortable to wear all day out of the box. I have a wide foot and wide-ish calf, and they fit me perfectly, so perhaps would be too wide on someone with a narrower foot or calf. The oxblood color is a dark/dull red, kind of brick red. I was pleased as the didn't scream "red" but a more neutral. Very well made.

Anonymous

from Houston, Texas

I love the look of these boots but they were unfortunately too tall for me and a bit too narrow. I'm 5'2" and 140 pounds with about 15 inch calves. The boot shaft fits just fine around my legs, and I love that these don't have a zipper. Sadly, they cut into the back of my knees when I sit. My feet may be a bit wide, so your experience may differ.

Brands I'd also recommend: Old Gringo

Anonymous

from Houston

I had to send these back because my calves are 17" and my feet have high arches. First thing first, I got these on with ease. They are so so comfortable. Beyond words. I am quite certain that these will fit over one with 16" calves. Also these seemed to be a lil more of a clay red color. But still they were beautiful.

Brands I'd also recommend: Frye

Anonymous

from Philadelphia, PA

So wanted to love these, but just can't. I have a high instep and made getting into these boots tricky. Not sure I like the elastic panels either in person and on me as much as I did in the picture. Continuing my search. Thanks, Zappos. Best customer service.

Anonymous

from McLean, VA

I have been searching for just these boots for the past two seasons! The elastic panels on the side hug my calves. These boots are classically simple. They can be worn to work and then out to dinner. They are my go to boot!

Anonymous

from Spokane, WA

I love these boots. I have very narrow feet and have tried others that say they are narrow but end up being too loose. I ordered the boots in narrow width and these boots fit like a glove and are super comfortable!

Boot

Excellent boot! So comfy with the Nike air technology yet the black is dressy enough to wear to work. A+!

Anonymous

from Seattle, WA

Great boot and comfortable right away. It hugs your legs all the way down so the ankles don't look as bunched as some others. It has a nice clean look to it. I'm usually between a 7.5 and an 8 and I got the 7.5. They fit, but rub a little in the toe. I don't think I'd want an 8, though.

Anonymous

from Palo Alto, CA

Finally! A simple, elegant, unadorned boot that fits perfectly. Minimal calf gap for a streamlined look. One of the few styles out there that comes in a wide width too. Goes well with leggings as well as skirts/dresses.

Jane T

from Michigan

Love these boots! They slipped on just like Cinderella's glass slipper! Butter soft and beautiful. I ordered my regular size and they fit perfect. I had originally ordered an Ariat boot, but it was way too big and bulky for me. Of course with Zappos awesome service, I had these the next day!

Sally

from Ithaca

The sole is a little stiff and it doesn't have as much cushioning/support as I'd like, But that being said, these boots look amazing. I mean, the way they hug my ankles and calves is amazing. It's snug and perfect! If you're one of those people who've been disappointed with those awkward flimsy boots that scrunch up at the ankles or those that are way too loose at the calves, these boots are for you! They make my legs look super long and super slim and they're just sexy. I love the simplicity of these boots but the stretch fabric on the sides add to the design and gives it an elegant look. Ahhh, I just love these so much! I'm almost considering getting the other two colors!

Brands I'd also recommend: La Canadienne, Clarks, Cole Haan, Ralph Lauren, Franco Sarto, Vince Camuto

Anonymous

from Auburn, AL

These boots are beautiful and comfortable. They look great with skirts and dresses - they really elongate the leg. However, they are very narrow in the calf so they might not work with people who have larger calves. It also makes them difficult to wear with jeans unless they are ultra skinny skinny jeans.

Anonymous

I am so glad to find a riding boot that fits my big calves and they are stylish. I wear with thin socks but can wear with my jeans tucked in. Thanks Cole Haan!

Anonymous

from Washington, DC

These boots fit great, are super comfy and a lovely color, but a couple complaints - 1) the rubber sole started peeling off of both boots within a week of purchase (and I didn't get them wet); 2) the stretchy sides snag fairly easily.

Brands I'd also recommend: Born

Anonymous

from NJ

Really comfortable. Love the profile and shape. My calves are chunky and I feel like these are slimming. A bit snug to put on, but not tight. They are little stiff, probably because of the elastic inserts (which don't look cheap) but I don't mind that.

Brands I'd also recommend: pliner

Anonymous

Like the looks of these boots, but they were a little narrow for me. Also, difficult to get on and off, since there are no zippers or pulls. My calves measure 14 inches, and this boot fits my calves, but I don't think I could wear them over pants.

Wendy

I don't consider myself to have wide feet as I've always purchased regular sized shoes, but these boots were so very narrow that they hurt two seconds after putting them on, and feet still throbbing after taking them off! Sadly, I have to return them. They look great, but if you have anything wider than a very narrow foot I would pass on these.

Anonymous

from Oregon

Beautiful boots. Just a note if you are a shorter woman...the boot shaft was too tall for me. I am regretfully returning them.

Sarah

from United States

These are great boots, but the stretch part seemed to already have snags in it! I recommend not to pull up on the elastic!

Su

from San Francisco

You know how you're out and hear loud shoes coming down the way? That's these. These boots felt okay, but ot as comfy as La Canadienne or Paul Green boots, and at about the same price. I see these are on sale now, so that makes it better. I put Paul Green on one foot and the Cole Haan Jodhpur on the other and walked down the hall. The Paul Green was much more comfortable and much quieter.

Brands I'd also recommend: Paul Green, La Canadienne

Dana K

from Oakland, CA

Super cute style, but just a tad too tight in the calves (couldn't pull over jeans, just tights), and I'm an 8.5 and it felt a little too tight. Overall-great quality/style, I'm just picky.

Anonymous

Great arch support, but a little drab. Plus, my calves are normal size, but I could barely get them on and off. There's no way I could have worn even skinny jeans tucked in with these.