Munro American Derby Reviews
41 reviews
total
Overall Rating:
80%
4%
8%
8%
0%
33 are "Favorable"
vs
8 are "Critical"
Most Helpful Critical Review
Very disappointed--cheap dye. Brown shoes looked scuffed and discolored within 2 weeks! Loved the black version (comfortable and nice-looking), so I bought a pair in the brown leather. The finish/dye started wearing off and looking scuffed and scratched after one wearing (normal walking, etc.--I am not rough on shoes). Spent almost a lot on shoes that a week later look 10 years old! Didn't have this problem with the black pair.
Additional 21 Derby Munro American Reviews
- Most Helpful First
- Newest First
2 people found this review helpful
March 6, 2012
Anonymous
from Silver Spring, MD
I love this shoe. It looks great and feels comfortable. I have wide feet so the wide sizes fit. Fabulous shoes!
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
2 people found this review helpful
January 31, 2012
Anonymous
from North Carolina
Lovely shoe. Length is exactly right. I'm a 10.5 (not a 10, not an 11), which is hard to find. Width is just right. Their 2A(N) is just that -- narrow. Too many narrows are still too wide for me. Quality of the leather is good. Shoe is just what I needed, a low heel loafer that fits.
Brands I'd also recommend: Trotters, Sesto Meucci
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
2 people found this review helpful
December 14, 2011
Anonymous
from California
I've been buying Munro American shoes for several years. They are a perfect fit for me and excellent quality. They are well worth the money! The Derby is a good choice for winter weather and also has good arch support.
Brands I'd also recommend: Clarks
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
2 people found this review helpful
December 6, 2011
Kathleen G
from Houston,Tx
I really liked the style and look of this shoe. It's very stylish. The leather is beautiful. I have a high instep and therefore It was too tight once I zipped it. It does have a little elastic on the inside of the shoe but for me it wasn't enough to give me comfort. However if you like this shoe I would highly suggest you give it a try.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
2 people found this review helpful
December 5, 2011
Anonymous
from San Francisco, CA
I love these shoes. They were instantly comfortable and they provide excellent support. Great for keeping the feet dry when it rains. I'm considering purchasing a second pair. Highly recommend this shoe.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
2 people found this review helpful
November 10, 2011
Anonymous
from Massachusetts
This is the second pair of Munro shoes that I have ordered in the past month. The brown color is very rich looking and from the moment I slipped them on, I loved them. They fits like a glove and the leather is supple. I am a 10W and these shoes fit perfectly. They are sharp looking shoes.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
2 people found this review helpful
March 25, 2012
Anonymous
from San Francisco
Very nice shoe. Looks good with opaque tights. Good for office and meetings, but it's not an all-day walking shoe.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
2 people found this review helpful
March 14, 2012
Deb R
from Michigan
For the price, I was expecting alot more. Very tight and binding, support was just okay. Again, not anything special for the price. Back they go.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt a half size smaller than marked
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt narrower than marked
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
2 people found this review helpful
January 18, 2012
Robin r
from Silver Spring, MD
Nice looking and soft leather but is very narrow without the orthotic. Orthotic doesn't begin to fit, unfortunately. I ordered the 11.5, sorry to return.
Brands I'd also recommend: KUMFS
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt a half size smaller than marked
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt narrower than marked
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
1 person found this review helpful
June 6, 2012
Anonymous
from Midwest
I love these shoes! They are silky smooth on the inside, a nice little stacked heel for dressy yet stable. The toe looks pointy, but they feel roomy inside. I have a high instep, and it still fits very comfortably. And my orthotics fit which is another plus, something to wear other than my gym shoes. They are nice and roomy in the toe box. They are stylish. These have it all. Zappos is great, but Munroe is the best!
Brands I'd also recommend: ecco, aetrex
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
1 person found this review helpful
June 5, 2012
Anonymous
from Midwest
I love these shoes! They are silky smooth on the inside, a nice little stacked heel for dressy yet stable. The toe looks pointy, but it feels roomy inside. I have a high instep, and it still fits very comfortably. And my orthotics fit which is another plus, something to wear other than my gym shoes. They are nice and roomy in the toe box. They are stylish. These have it all. Zappos is great, but Munroe is the best!
Brands I'd also recommend: ecco, aetrex
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
1 person found this review helpful
May 12, 2012
Anonymous
from Louisville, KY
The leather is very soft. The shoe is cute, comfortable, and looks great with jeans and dress slacks. My shoe size is a 11SS and the shoe fits prefect. My only complaint is that it is not skid mark proof! I would buy this shoe again another color.
Brands I'd also recommend: Trotters
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
1 person found this review helpful
April 1, 2012
Anonymous
from Santa Barbara
These are fantastic shoes. I bought two pairs! I have some feet issues (neuropathy)and it is hard to find attractive shoes that are comfortable and look good - these fill the bill!
Brands I'd also recommend: Merrell, Cole Hahn
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
1 person found this review helpful
December 22, 2011
Lynn k
from florida
Beautiful shoe/boot. However, the wide was too narrow and the double wide was too wide.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt narrower than marked
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
1 person found this review helpful
April 11, 2012
Anonymous
from Chicago, IL
I bought this style in brown and black, but returned the black pair only because I'd already worn the brown ones. It's really a man's shoe and a rather ugly man's shoe at that. So imagine how it looks on a woman. I'm going to give the brown pair to a male friend if it fits him and he'll take it. It turned out to be an expensive mistake.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt a full size larger than marked
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
1 person found this review helpful
December 16, 2011
Anonymous
First of all, I am usually a big fan of Munro. They have a lot of qualities in their shoes that are actually good for feet. I also do not usually mind paying more for good quality shoes and have owned many, many pairs of Munro over the years. I have to say I was disappointed in these shoes. I bought them because my other dressy loafers had worn out and I used to have several pairs of a similar shoe from Munro called Rio. These shoes really fit the bill. The fit is great, the shoes are comfortable, and they are great with slacks. The disappointment has been in the quality. After wearing them only four times, the leather upper has crackled. The surface is rough and the crackling is very noticeable over the entire front half of both shoes making them look much older than they are. The color has come off the heel from where my shoe contacts my car mat, and one of the gussets has frayed and pulled out of the stitching. The shoes will now have to go to a shoe repair shop. If I did not really need some brown shoes for work, I would have returned them. Munro usually has much better quality than this; I have had shoes of theirs last me for years. I was especially disappointed in the quality of leather.
Brands I'd also recommend: propet, ros hommerson,
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
March 20, 2013
Carol M
from Wheaton, IL.
These are great looking shoes but they run narrow. I order EE width on all my shoes and these were too tight up by the toes.
Brands I'd also recommend: David Tate
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt narrower than marked
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
March 11, 2013
Rhea
from NJ
Love. I haven't worn loafers in over 15 years and decided on these and am so glad. I got the black color. I have wide feet and these shoes don't make me look like I have wide feet at all! The symmetry on the shoe is excellent while still giving me the width I need to be comfortable. The soles are soft but I haven't walked "miles" in them yet so just rated a 4 for now. I have flat feet and I don't need much arch support. These don't really have support. The soles feel really cushy. I like how it provides enough coverage to still wear some thin ankle socks if I want the no-socks-look without the no-socks-feel. I can't fit wool socks in these. Very satisfied. Love that it is made in the USA too.
Brands I'd also recommend: Tieks
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
March 1, 2013
Anonymous
from McAllen, Texas
This is a very comfortable shoe. Professional looking. Goes well with dress pants. Perfect size heel for walking all day. No breaking in. Lightweight.
Brands I'd also recommend: Paul green, Stuart Weitzman, Via Spiga, Donald Pliner
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt narrower than marked
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
November 27, 2012
Ellen
from Wisconsin
I have wide feet and found these shoes to be very comfortable, and they look great with jeans. I wear them all the time. The leather is soft, which means it will get scuffed a little easier, but that is easily fixed with a bit of shoe polish now and then. Very happy with this purchase.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
November 20, 2012
Rosie
from Seattle, WA
I have been wearing these shoes for years! Before Evie they were called "Caprice". They are comfortable, wear very well, and my orthodics fit in them perfectly. I have been searching the internet for a brown pair to replace my old ones.
Brands I'd also recommend: Birkenstock, Naot
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
November 20, 2012
Anonymous
from California
I purchased this pair along with 3 others. All fit perfectly. With a size 11 foot and a number of foot and knee ailments, Munros are the best for my feet. Zappos is the most reliable online retailer I have come across. Easy to return items and everything is delivered in pristine condition.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
November 11, 2012
Anonymous
from New England
This is a very good-looking shoe with slacks. Regarding Zappos' customer service: there was a defect in the elastic gusset which I did not discover until a year after receiving the shoe because I had not worn it much - the gusset had begun to pull away from the leather. Zappos replaced the shoe immediately and graciously.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
Fit Rating
Felt a half size smaller than marked
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt narrower than marked
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide



