Johnston & Murphy Stricklin Moc Lace-Up Reviews
16 reviews
total
Overall Rating:
45%
27%
9%
0%
18%
14 are "Favorable"
Most Helpful Favorable Review
Surprisingly comfortable. Clean lines and an insane insole make this great for daily wear. I hadn't tried J&M in years and these were a pleasant surprise at a low price point. Beats the heck out of a stiff pair of AE's.
vs
2 are "Critical"
Most Helpful Critical Review
I am very disappointed in these shoes. I purchased them less than two months ago and have already had to take them into a shoe repair shop. The dye used does not penetrate deeply into the shoes. If anything touches your foot, it will leave a scuff that requires polish. I shared an elevator with my boss yesterday, he saw my feet and said, "Ha! I think it is time for a new pair of shoes." That is unacceptable for a two month old pair that has been professionally shined and worked on to remove scuffs. Look elsewhere. Will not purchase Johnston & Murphy moving forward.
Additional -4 Stricklin Moc Lace-Up Johnston & Murphy Reviews
- Most Helpful First
- Newest First
1
2 people found this review helpful
July 15, 2010
Anonymous
Purchased these shoes about 4 months ago, and I have no regrets. They\'re probably the most comfortable pair of shoes that I\'ve ever owned, and they look good. They\'ve held up very well to daily use thus far, and they still look good. I\'d definitely buy them again.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt a half size larger than marked
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
2 people found this review helpful
January 31, 2012
Steve B
from St Paul, MN
I am very disappointed in these shoes. I purchased them less than two months ago and have already had to take them into a shoe repair shop. The dye used does not penetrate deeply into the shoes. If anything touches your foot, it will leave a scuff that requires polish. I shared an elevator with my boss yesterday, he saw my feet and said, "Ha! I think it is time for a new pair of shoes." That is unacceptable for a two month old pair that has been professionally shined and worked on to remove scuffs. Look elsewhere. Will not purchase Johnston & Murphy moving forward.
Brands I'd also recommend: Cole Haan
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
1 person found this review helpful
June 17, 2012
Anonymous
from d.c.
I bought these for my husband at Zappos because I can't get him to the store! And he loves these shoes. He says they are the most comfortable dress shoes ever. And he has worn a lot. I was trying to buy a different brand, but got these, and are we ever glad! He has flat feet, wide in places, and is hard to fit. These are so comfortable to his foot. Highly recommend!
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
1 person found this review helpful
June 3, 2012
Steve F
from Poplarville, Ms.
I work in retail and wanted nice looking shoes that were also comfortable and supportive on concrete. These shoes fit the bill. I have worn Johnston & Murphy shoes before so I knew what I was getting. They have good support and are made from quality materials.
Brands I'd also recommend: n/a
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
1 person found this review helpful
May 1, 2012
Greg
from Chicago
J&M makes great shoes and these are no different. Nice color, extremely comfortable right out of the box, good style and they have held up very well. Perfect for business casual.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
January 6, 2013
Jimmy
from Boston
I'm a 14 normally but went with a size down on these. I also have them in 14 and the soles are actually the exact same size and cut but the 13s are a better fit. The leather will stretch and they end up looking better.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt a full size larger than marked
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
December 29, 2012
Dmitry N
from Staten Island, New York
This is a very comfortable business casual shoe to wear to work, perhaps the most comfortable shoe in the price-range that I had ever owned. The shoe does start to show wear early, and is very easy to scuff. I've worn this shoe almost daily to work for five months, and am about to toss this pair and order a new one.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
July 10, 2012
Anonymous
These are good looking shoes for work. They rook a couple days to break in as they were slightly stiff above the toes and in the sole. But they were comfortable after that.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
August 2, 2012
Anonymous
from Fort Lauderdale, FL
I had these shoes for a little over a year. They are very comfortable. Almost too comfortable to the point you think you are wearing sneakers, which may cause you to think you are under-dressed. The problem with them is that the leather easily scratches and makes them look abused pretty easily. Where some other shoes withstand a daily beating (I wore these about twice a week), these did not. However, they are truly comfortable. Your call.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
February 20, 2013
Anonymous
from NYC
Very comfy, but quickly destroyed. Soft leather prone to scuffs and tears. Soles are in great shape but I will have to retire these bc the uppers look shabby, after less than a year later of indoor wear.
Overall
Comfort
Style
Was this review helpful? Yes
Fit Rating
Felt true to size
Runs Small
Runs Large
Felt true to width
Runs Narrow
Runs Wide
