I run 9.5-10 and know from experience with
Anne Klein that I'm a 9.5. That's what I ordered, and they fit like a glove. There is surprisingly decent support, for
flats. The calf hair is very subtle, and the lions on the toes are perfectly sized; sometimes details like that on
flats can seem comically large on my big feet, but these are just right. There is only the tiniest bit of toe cleavage (barely worth mentioning) and I think the toe is a little rounder than it looks in the picture. They're subtle enough to wear to work, but also totally appropriate for a LBD. Love them!