Posted: 2011-09-30 05:11:11
Reviewer: JUSTJFER from Largo, FL
Overall: 
Comfort:
Style:
I have always bought drugstore liner thinking there couldn't be a difference with the higher priced ones. Boy, was I wrong. This stuff glides on like silk and doesn't tug on my eyelid at all when I am trying to put on. Beautiful color and stays put. Lesson learned.
Posted: 2011-03-26 11:26:19
Reviewer: Majmz from San Jose Ca
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
I really like the color! It's not too dramatic with a sparkle on it. Plus, it stays on all day and no smudges!
Posted: 2010-04-30 17:28:44
Reviewer: Anonymous from Long Island, NY
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
Best eyeliner ever. I use
Stila smudge pots for years in brown. I tried the eyeliner pencil in lionfish. It is brown with a goldish metallic. It looks great on my blue eyes and it is waterproof. I was in Miami and went to beach for 4 hours and I do go swimming and dive into ocean waves. Much to my amazement my eyeliner was still on when I went back to condo. I couldn't believe it. Washes off with soap and water. Love this product for summer. Looks great with tan. Will be buying again.
Posted: 2011-03-08 14:18:59
Reviewer: KB from Las Vegas
Overall: 
Comfort:
Style:
KILLS CONTACT LENSES! If you wear contacts STEER CLEAR of this item!! This eyeliner left a waxy film over my lenses, and destroyed 2 pairs of contacts in literally a blink of an eye (ok, maybe it was two blinks...)! My coworker also bought this (she didn't use the one I bought) and tried it with her contacts and the same waxy film showed up! Needless to say "HATED IT"! Otherwise, if you don't wear contacts, this eyeliner is great! Runs/bleeds a little, but I'd use it if I had naturally perfect vision!
Posted: 2012-02-10 21:52:31
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
I love Zappos! This eye liner was delivered the day after I ordered it and I now use it everyday! It draws a smooth, boldly black line and is long lasting.
Posted: 2012-02-08 12:25:09
Reviewer: Vivian from Las Vegas, NV
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
This eyeliner is amazing; after you apply it let it set for a few seconds and it won't move at all. Great quality. Love these eyeliners as much as my Urban Decay ones.
Posted: 2012-02-02 14:50:10
Reviewer: Anonymous from San Francisco, CA
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
I love this eyeliner. I have oily lids, but I don't have the problem of smearing I normally have with other
brands. I saw someone state in an earlier review that it ruins contact lens, but I haven't experienced that issue in the 2 years I've been using this. This item is always sold out at Sephora, so I am very happy it is readily available here at Zappos!
Posted: 2012-01-24 07:38:28
Reviewer: Katie from Crofton, MD
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
Best eyeliner I have ever used. I received a free sample of this through a
beauty sample box and was amazed at how it stayed on all day, so I had to buy it. I usually spend a dismal amount on eyeliner, so this was a big deal for me but way worth it. I wear contacts and most makeup smudges off throughout the day if I put eye drops in or anything. This didn't hurt my eyes/contacts at all or leave a film as others mentioned.
Posted: 2012-01-07 07:30:00
Reviewer: Anonymous from Albuquerque, NM
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
The products from
Stila are always of excellence quality. This eye liner remains in place without smearing or
running. I can apply it on in the morning and it remains just as perfect until I remove it at night. When you combine the convenience of purchasing and delivery there is no other way to shop.
Posted: 2011-09-19 15:32:11
Reviewer: Nicole B from Chesterfield, Virginia.
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
I have been searching for an eyeliner that was waterproof,smudgeless, and fade-proof. Also one that was very pigmented. I put this eyeliner on and I knew right then that I would never use any other eyeliner ever again. I have very watery eyes, as well as contacts. I put this stuff on my waterline and I had absolutely no irritation. It is by far the only eyeliner I have ever used that has kept its promise.
Stila is not only an amazing brand, but every product that I have bought from them has done exactly what it claims it will do. It is very common for the
beauty industry to lie about certain products, but still is a straight up honest brand you can trust.
