I've never written a review before, but I've read a lot of yours and valued all your information and insight, so here goes. I live in Seattle, so I need a waterproof boot that I can wear comfortably all day all through our rainy winter, and that looks good enough even with skirts that I don't feel I should rush to change as soon as I'm indoors. My criteria for looks good are that they don't suggest I'm trying to make a virtue out of huge and clompy (you have to be much younger than I am to pull that off), that they don't suggest "tough" (as in aging motorcycle mama), and that they don't suggest that after a long, tiring battle the weather has won and I've just given up. These boots look so good you don't even think "sensible." Yet they are amazingly comfortable for their heel height: balanced and stable, with a heel shape that's incredibly flattering. The toe box is roomy, and the suede is supple so you're not bothered by "buckling" of the shaft as you walk. As to sizing: because I'm usually between a 9 and 9.5 I ordered a 9.5, and I am right where I want to be in this boot: a bit roomy with tights and a bit snug with thick socks. My calf measures 13.5 in. at the widest part, and the shaft is 15.5 in. at the top, so although there's a gap for me the shaft tapers in at the top so they don't look like buckets when I wear them with tights. Now for my wish list: I could wish for arch support (only the need to keep balanced on the heel prevents my fallen arches from turning in, but I put in those little sticky gel arch supports to good effect). I could wish the shaft was an inch taller (I'm 5 ft. 7, and I measure the shaft at the back at 15 in.). And I could wish that the heel was a little lower (I measure 3 in. at the back of the heel). But these are minor quibbles, as I am so delighted to find a boot that I can wear all day that will keep my feet dry and comfortable, while also keeping me from looking like something the cat dragged in from the rain!

I love these boots! They fit perfectly, are comfortable and waterproof. Best of all I get compliments every time I wear them, sometimes from total strangers. After one year they look like new, I hope they last forever.

These boots are great -- very comfortable, super stylish and warm. I love them and receive lots of compliments on them. The suede is gorgeous. A little pricey, but totally worth it.

Already have another pair of higher heeled La C. boots from Zappos, which I love! Wanted a slightly lower heel. For a change, first tried grey boot. I am petite with muscular calves, and a skirt wearer. From the back, not only did the grey color make my calves look wider, but the 15.25" shaft was not a flattering length. When you're petite, having the boot end about 1.5" or so below your knee will make your legs look longer. Exchanged the grey with the black. Not only did the black give me a sleeker look, the shaft was 14.5"(like my other La C boots) , much better proportion. Both Kara boots were a size 6. Super comfortable cushioned footbed. Snug fit around my calves and no ankle sagging.

Perfect tall boot for those with slim legs. The shaft is not too wide or too narrow, just the perfect shape and size. The heels are not too high making it super comfortable and at the same time elegant. The suede is soft and supple. One can easily see the quality of the suede. I find it runs true to size. This is true for all of the La Canadienne shoes/boots I have bought. And of course, Zappos is the best!