I wanted a durable, water and dirt resistant boot for Northwest-living. I've been wearing them for over a month now and I am VERY happy with them. Words cannot explain how hard I am on my footwear but I expect them to last me at least two years and I wear them almost every day. They are nearly water proof, warm, and easy to clean even though I walk through mud and puddles daily. The faux leather is very soft and expensive looking but scuffs and scratches pretty easy. However, the distressed quality of the fabric hides most of it. The bottom has treads but I slipped and almost fell the other day on some ice. Usually sheaths are a bit snug around my calf and when I bought them I barely zipped them up with leggings but they've stretched now to the point where I can tuck straight leg jeans into them easily. If you're in between sizes I would go for the smaller one. I'm 5'5 and it hits me perfectly right below the knee. The heel is a bit unattractive and out-of-place with the rest of the boot and I thought that would bother me but I don't even notice it now.

Great casual looking boot, love the cut out in the back for a little extra detail. Does seem larger in size than normal, maybe order 1/2 size smaller than normal. I'm completely happy with this purchase!

These boots are the perfect gray color. I normally wear a 10 and these were more than big enough and they stretched out the more I wore them. Would recommend going a half size smaller. Downside - I had these boots less than a month and the zipper broke on them. Zappos awesome customer service had me a replacement within a day. Got a 9.5 and they're perfect.

I really like these boots; however, the zippers keep scratching the opposite legs. With only one wear, I've got four pretty serious scratches/tears.

Relatively comfortable but too cheap looking to pay this much. You could tell they were vinyl from 10 feet away - if I was 20 years old and going for an edgy/cheap club look, sure. But I'm in my 30's and would like to at least look like I can afford better than this. Also, the cushioning was barely existent.

I have these in mint green and I love them, because they don't leak, since they are one molded piece! They are great for mud season. I usually wear an 8-9, but ordered a 9, since I would probably be wearing heavy socks and I didn't want them to be too tight. I've had narrow (leaky) rain boots in the past and these have plenty of room and are very comfortable.

Love these! After coveting them for years & almost buying a few different colors, I ended up getting the Flame color and I'm so happy. Beware - these are bright! But coral is my absolute favorite color & it helps when I'm homesick for Florida in the Chicago snow. I bought these after returning a pair of beautiful Sorel's (they wore a hole in my Achilles, so uncomfortable) and I was worried they wouldn't keep me warm in the snow. I added a pair of Hunter welly socks and they are every bit as warm as my Sorels were. Bonus - they go up higher, so no matter how much the snow piles up or how deep the slush puddle is, my pants stay dry and clean. Love these boots & can't wait to wear them in the rain when it's warmer. If you have muscular calves, they're hard to take on and off with the welly socks. They're fine with just jeans or leggings, but I have to pull with the socks. Otherwise they fit true to size, don't order up or down.

I love Hunters, but I will never buy another pair. I have been through three pairs in as many years. Each year the boots crack and fail at the part where the boot flexes (on the sides of the ball of your foot). I have had cheapo rubber K-Mart boots that lasted 10 years so I would think for the price these guys could do better. Too bad as they are the best fitting and most comfy rubber boots I have found. Still, buying then is just throwing away money if you plan to wear them more than every once in a great while.

Love the boots but like so many have said they are really narrow around the calves. I think I have pretty average sized calves and they just fit, that's without jeans or leggings. The boot itself actually runs a little big, which I expected with rain boots but coupled with it being so tight around the calf and it makes it difficult to walk. The color pictured (I ordered chartreuse) is much different in person. Online it's looks like a yellow but in person it's more of a 'spring green' I do plan to return these, but only because of how tight they are on my leg. I'm going to try a shorter pair.

I was so excited to finally get a pair of Hunter rain boots; I'd been coveting them for a while! These are perfect! They're not too tight in the calf, which I was worried about, and they're the perfect size to wear with socks (I usually wear a 7.5 or 8; I ordered the 8). The color is really nice, a pretty coral: bright, but not as orange as it looked on my computer.