I bought these for a trip while another pair of
boots that I have were being repaired. Let me see if I can bulletpoint.
1. Inexpensive. These
boots were cheap and as such the quality is not that of say
Vasque or
frye. That said the quality is adequate for a city shoe, not a work boot. Leather is a bit thin nut not bad. Zipper sticks a bit but works ok.
2. Comfort. I spent a week walking on cobble stones in brand new
boots without my feet getting sore. These were awesome right out of the box. Really impressive. I was stoked because for my purposes they were perfect.
3. Waterproof. We walked lots in rain and although I wouldn't walk through a pond, my feet stayed dry and warm in 45 deg weather and in the rain.
Overall I would say if you are looking for a city winter boot these are great.