I have ten or more pairs of NYDJs in a size ten. They all fit well except for Alisha. The ten fits like an 8. Is it mismarked? Don't know. Guess I'll try a 12. Nice print. Such a hassle. NYDJ needs to keep on top of quality control. Lowered my review due to sizing issue.

Okay! For my first pair of snow boots I decided to go with the Caribou. I must say the look good, but they are poorly made! The first pair I ordered had the biggest air pocket in the sole of the left boot so I called Zappos and they immediately send me a second pair. Turns out the second pair had the same problem only a bigger hole in the sole of the left shoe! If you were to go out in the slush and snow with Caribous, I know they will eventually fall apart fall and soak your feet. There are some reviews out there on how flawed the are and even pictures of people pressing the water out of their boots. If you ever decide to get a pair: Look for a small hole on the side of the of the soles of both shoes just to be safe. Also listen for hissing noises coming from your boots. If you notice this immediately contact Sorel and let them know that there is a serious flaw with their boots! Try not to get pissed when talking to customer service because they don't know what's going on; it's the CEOs that need to tighten up!

I bought a pair of Sorel boots like this a while back. On both boots the rubber split and came apart along with the sole coming off one boot. Sorel customer support did not help.

My husband gives these boots a thumbs up! Spent a week in Colordao and warm feet the entire time. You can't go wrong with these boots.

Comfortable, but you'd look like you are wearing two boats.

I purchased a pair of Caribous 22 years ago...they have just worn out. My son has gone through several pairs of snowboots working his Snow Plowing business, complaining that his feet were cold. I told him he should have got Sorels. "But Mom then I would look just like you." Well, surprised him with a pair as a gift. He loves his new Toasty toes inside his Sorel boots. "Should have gotten them sooner." As far as this pair lasting 20+ years like my first pair, we'll have to see if the integrity has remained since Sorel has changed manufacturing from Canada to China.