I am a size 18 with very big feet - most of the time, an 11 will pinch. I took a chance on these
boots because folks said they ran a bit big, and I am delighted! (
Frye is one of the only companies that makes
boots in an 11.) They fit perfectly, even on my "big" foot (the right one is the one that's huge, the left is probably a true size 11). If you have high arches, you might have trouble pulling them on, but you can loosen the leather strap across the arch and it gives you quite a lot more breathing room, and once they start to loosen up (we're talking about an hour) they come on and off pretty easily. They do feel a bit narrow through the widest part of the foot, as someone else mentioned, but after wearing for just 20 or 30 minutes they were really quite comfortable. If you have very wide feet, these might pinch. I also measured my calf according to the reviews, and was afraid the calves would be snug, but they are actually roomy and comfortable over leggings without being too slouchy. I don't think there will be any problem wearing over skinny
jeans. With very bulky
jeans, it might be an issue. I'm also 5'10" so I was afraid they would not be "tall" on me, but they are perfect, maybe an inch to 2 inches below the knee. I wore them around the house with stockings today to break them in, and will upgrade to thicker
socks every day until they're broken in and loose. Also would like to mention that the picture does not do the tan leather justice! These
boots are so beautiful I literally just about want to cry. They are so soft and the color is darker and more subtle than the photo, absolutely beautiful. The leather is amazingly soft, just gorgeous. I am ecstatically happy with my first-ever pair of
boots!