Continue playing Product Showdown

Product Showdown

…aka Shoe-Jitsu, Shoe-mo Wrestling, Shoe Duel, and a number of other witty names we couldn't decide on.

Rachel Kids Whitney (Youth)

Rachel Kids Whitney (Youth)

Battle Stats

  • Total Wins: 11
  • Total Losses: 9
  • Wins vs. Competitor: 1
  • Sales Rank: #20240
  • Video Description View the Video Description for this product! (Please note that the color shown in the video may no longer be available.)
  • She knows just the right style to channel her inner diva with the sleek look of the Whitney sandal.
  • Synthetic upper features intricate strap design and studded vamp.
  • Zipper closure at the heel for easy on and off.
  • Man-made lining and footbed.
  • Flexible rubber outsole for durability.
  • Measurements:
    • Heel Height: 1⁄2 in
    • Weight: 5 oz
  • Product measurements were taken using size 2 Youth, width M. Please note that measurements may vary by size.

Average Customer Ratings (based on 5 reviews)

Overall: (2 Stars) Comfort: (3 Stars) Style: (3 Stars)

Posted: 2012-05-28 06:17:38
Reviewer: Anonymous from Bronx, NY
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
My thirteen year old daughter loves these shoes. She can wear them with skirts/casual dresses and with shorts. She says they are very comfortable. They are a bit wide, but she has small feet.
Posted: 2012-06-06 09:18:26
Reviewer: Stephanie from NYC suburbs
Overall: (2 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
These shoes are adorable and were comfortable for my daughter, but one of the straps broke on the second wearing. Zappos (awesome Zappos!) sent me a replacement pair, but the same thing happened again with the new pair after only a few wearings. Love Zappos, but these shoes were a waste of money.
Posted: 2012-06-19 10:07:52
Reviewer: Johnnie b from concord, n c
Overall: (1 Stars) Comfort: (2 Stars) Style: (2 Stars)
The stitching was already unraveling when I open the box! This isn't good! I'm sending this pair back for a refund and ordering another hope that pair is in good condition.
Posted: 2012-05-16 13:03:08
Reviewer: Anonymous from plymouth, mi
Overall: (1 Stars) Comfort: (1 Stars) Style: (1 Stars)
The straps on these sandals literally snapped after taking 2 steps in them! Very cheaply made. Don't waste your money!
Posted: 2012-07-27 05:32:48
Reviewer: Anonymous from Bronx, NY
Overall: (2 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Sadly, these shoes literally fell apart after only 2 1/2 months. My daughter is not at all hard on her shoes and she loved these so this is a huge disappointment to her.

Frye Shirley Riding Boots

Frye Shirley Riding Boots

Battle Stats

  • Total Wins: 40
  • Total Losses: 30
  • Wins vs. Competitor: 0
  • Sales Rank: #20046
  • Video Description View the Video Description for this product! (Please note that the color shown in the video may no longer be available.)
  • A traditional riding silhouette gets a stylish and modern update in these cute boots.
  • Luxurious hand-antiqued leather with sleek belting and buckle details.
  • Traditional pull-on design.
  • Smooth leather lining.
  • Cushioned leather insole provides lasting comfort.
  • Durable leather outsole.
  • Measurements:
    • Heel Height: 3⁄4 in
    • Weight: 1 lb 6 oz
    • Circumference: 15 1⁄2 in
    • Shaft: 16 1⁄2 in
  • Product measurements were taken using size 7, width B - Medium. Please note that measurements may vary by size.

Average Customer Ratings (based on 13 reviews)

Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (4 Stars)

Posted: 2011-11-03 06:42:04
Reviewer: Julie F from Wheaton, IL
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Fit good. I have a wide foot but are comfortable. Can tuck pants in easily.
Posted: 2010-04-18 14:03:01
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
This is my first pair of leather boots and I'm really pleased with the product. I was a bit surprised at how baggy they were around the ankle and the calf. I have rather small ankles and calves so maybe it's just me. But they are comfortable and pretty much any pair of pants will easily tuck into them. I would recommend buying the leather conditioner straight away as the leather on mine felt a bit dry to start with. Plus, you'll want to weatherproof them.
Posted: 2011-11-16 20:02:59
Reviewer: Melissa R from Chicago
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I found them. After two months of ordering, waiting, trying and returning I finally found the perfect boots. I have larger calves and thought I could only wear zippered boots and be able to tuck in my denim and leggings. After ordering the Frye Melissa Gore boot, I thought I had them but they ran large in the foot and the calf was still tight. Shirley was my last hope for a comfy, classic, flat riding boot to help me through the Chicago winter. I'm relieved and totally satisfied. Buy them!
Posted: 2011-11-10 22:51:58
Reviewer: Anonymous from nyc
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I bought these boots on a Monday night and they arrived the following day which was amazing to begin with. The boots fit me well I ordered my true size and I have a wide foot and a thicker calf (15.5 in) they looked a little foreign right out of the box I had a hard time getting used to them on my feet for the first 6 hours that I wore them they were not uncomfortable just not mine yet. But, by the end of the second day that I wore them I felt like I had had them for years. They molded and conformed to my feet really quickly and they have a cushion right at the ball of your foot that is perfect. I am going to take them to the cobbler to have him put a plastic/rubber barrier sole on the bottom so the surface of NYC doesn't destroy these beautiful soles. I deliberated for a while before I bought them because of the price but now I don't regret it even a little bit. In fact I feel silly for waiting. I bought them in the black.
Posted: 2011-09-24 13:50:15
Reviewer: Tiffany K from Boston, MA
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
These shoes are definitely tight around the ankle so they need time to break in. Overall these are not bad boots. They are comfortable after being broken in and they are very stylish.
Posted: 2010-11-09 18:33:36
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
These boots are great! I have athletic calves and have looked everywhere for boots that are a little larger in the calf area and these fit great in calf, even a little extra room! They were a little snug in the toe box but have stretched after a few times wearing them. They did take a few times wearing the break them in overall. The dark brown is nice casual color easy to wear with lots of different things. They do scuff easily. Also the heel is already wearing down after only a few times wearing. I will need to go get the heel replaced and have a no slip sole put on for the winter.
Posted: 2010-09-09 12:03:08
Reviewer: Anonymous from Boston, MA
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Gorgeous! Love this boot. Get compliments all the time. The boot could have a better insole, but I think with time they will break in nicely. Also, I have pretty narrow feet, and these pinched a little in the toe at first, but they loosened up after a few times wearing them. Highly recommend!
Posted: 2010-04-10 16:10:15
Reviewer: Anonymous from los angeles, ca
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Love these boots! They look great and I always receive compliments. They are exceptionally well made, and worth the price. I also love that they are flat. I can walk all day in them. Great buy!
Posted: 2010-02-01 08:21:50
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I got these boots for Christmas, and wanted to say that I'm an official Frye boot convert. I won't be buying any other brand after these. They're excellent quality, nice smooth leather etc. I will say it's a little hard to get your ankle down into them, but it's possible. It just takes a little bit of wiggling! Once they're on, they're super comfortable! I also wanted to add that I have larger calves from working out/weights, and these boots are perfect...I can even wear skinny jeans down inside of them!
Posted: 2011-11-04 16:04:24
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (3 Stars) Style: (3 Stars)
I am not really sure how to rate these in terms of comfort. I could not even get my foot into these boots! Too bad because they looked really nice.

Battle History

Previous Month May 2013
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31