Unfortunately have to return these since the front edge digs into the top of my foot. Very cute and wish they fit better. Also, they flop off my heel. Rated them as half size larger because of the length.

This was the cutest shoe but, unfortunately, I had to return them. I wear a size 8 wide and they were perfect but they hit on my big toe bone and were just not comfortable. I kept them for 4 days thinking I could get comfortable but never did. I suggest that if you wear a regular medium width, they may be too big so move down a size.

Cute, but the stripes on the fabric on the two shoes went at different angles, and the shoes feel cheap -- like they might fall apart in a few wearings. I am returning.

Very comfortable shoes! Great service from Zappos...had to exchange for size, they made it easy!

I really want to like these shoes. They don't look cheap like another reviewer may have indicated, though when you wear them they kind of feel like they are made of a stiff cardboard. They still look really cute and I'm finding wearing them through the breaking in stage (2 or 3 one to two hour periods) really helps improve comfort.

I have been coveting these boots for close to a year and finally decided to invest the cash in them. They are definitely worth it. Nice thick leather, well constructed, they feel indestructible. Which means that yes, they feel stiff and heavy and tough to get on right out of the box. I opened the buckle, slid my foot in as far as it would go (wearing nylons, a plastic bag over the foot would work too), then pulled up on the back of the boot while rocking my foot back and forth until it popped in the rest of the way. They are going to require some breaking in, but you kind of want that in a boot- it means the leather will not break down and get too stretched out. Despite how stiff they are right now, I can tell they are going to be comfortable once they are broken in. They have good heel and arch support, the calf openings are not too tight or too loose, nothing is rubbing on my toes, etc. I had been torn between these and the Veronicas, so if you are too, here are the differences I saw: the Veronicas are a much thinner, softer leather, and a thinner sole/lower heel- more of a riding boot than a real engineer boot. I did not like how floppy the leather on the Veronicas is, it actually looks kinda cheesey to me, which is not what I want in such expensive boots. The engineer just seemed much more substantial. The other decision I struggled with was the color: gaucho or smoke? I went with the smoke, but I am not sure how I feel about it. The overall color is awesome; a grayish brown, with a weathered look- but the weathered look is maybe a little too manufactured. Mostly over the toes- there is a definite line of demarcation between the color of the toe and the rest of the boot that I do not think I am crazy about, so I am going to think about it for a day before I decide if I, going to exchange them for the gaucho. Other than that, I am very happy with this purchase and I cannot wait to wear these to death!

These are my 5th pair of Frye's and I am never disappointed with the quality. These run true to size but are difficult to get on. But once they are on, very comfortable and stylish. Can't say enough good things about my Frye's!

Great boots! I've had them about a week and have worn them every day- am very happy with this purchase. They felt just a bit tight on my wide, flat feet at first, but after 2 days of walking (around the office, grocery store) they were perfect. I ordered the 8R Engineer boots at the same time to compare, and am glad I did. The 8R boots weren't comfortable at all - had some stiff material rubbing on the back of my leg and top of my foot. But other people have said the opposite thing about the 8 and 12R, so I think it depends on your foot. Get them both and return one, Zappos makes it easy.

I ordered these boots half a size up because my normal size, 8, was out of stock. I am so glad that I did. I always have trouble getting my feet into boots because of a high arch, and these boots were no exception. With thin socks, however, I am able to get my feet in. I have only had them one day and it is already easier and easier. That being said, I am in love with these boots. They are adorable and so much cuter than the Veronica Shortie boots, which I tried on in a department store and hated. These boots are a must buy but I would recommend going a size up if you have difficulty getting into boots.

I work in retail, and I'm on my feet for 12 hours a day, sometimes longer. I received these boots for my birthday and told my husband he could get me another pair in a different color for Christmas, when the time comes. I love them! I normally take an 8 and they fit perfectly. The only problem is the seam that runs up the back on the right leg is a little rough, and rubs on my leg if I don't wear my jeans tucked into them - but I wear a higher sock, with the hope that this will soften up with the wear and age of the boots. I have had many compliments on them every time I wear them, and I would definitely take the chance on another pair in the future. Made in U.S.A.!