I think this is a great all-purpose winter boot that manages to combine style with function. I ordered my normal size, a 7.5, and the boots fits great. I have room to wiggle my toes which is important for long days of walking. I am anxious to see how these boots perform in rain and snow. I have been wearing them for two weeks now but we have had minimal rain. I'm hoping they truly are weather resistant. The footbed is very comfortable and provides some arch support. I have worn these for an entire day with a good amount of walking and my feet felt great. A note about the narrow ankle area: They can be a little difficult to get on with the narrow ankle area. I generally wear skinny jeans tucked into these boots. Sometimes I will roll/cuff my skinny jeans once and then put them on so that any extra bulk from the jeans is above the narrow ankle area. Once on, they are completely comfortable around my ankle. I wouldn't let the ankle area discourage you from purchasing these.

Great riding boot! Extremely sturdy and comfortable as I have expected based on previous experience with Merrell. Fits my wide foot, high instep, narrow ankles, and athletic calves. I need wides in most brands, but Merrell medium width works for me.

These are the best boots I have ever owned. Comfortable cushion bottom, fashionable features, and stain and water proof to boot. (Get it?) I highly recommend these boots. Worth the price!

Extremely comfortable shoe, great for walking city blocks, which is what I needed. Like other reviewers have stated, it is a challenge at first to get your foot in the boot, but after two wears, I'm no longer struggling at all, which is great. I have a medium-wide foot, which is probably why I felt that the boot fit true to size (I have plenty of breathing room for my toes, even with a pretty thick sock on). I love the style, and I love that the shaft of the boot has some stretch in it.

They arrived today! And I love them! I have been searching for over a year. I am so glad that Zappos lets you search according to calf size. Back to the boots, they are so comfortable!