I just received these today, and they are exactly what I was expecting. While the leather is a little stiff, it isn't too bad, and I would actually prefer it that way, personally. As you break them in they will be like a pair of raw denim and conform to your leg rather than being a soft leather from the manufacturer. The smell of leather as I opened the box was pretty overpowering. I purchased the black, and they are a very nice black boot with just enough distressing to add some interest. The bottom of the boot looks like it will have enough traction to be stable enough through a slick & Icy Wisconsin winter, which is a must. Which is another reason I chose this boot over the Carmen 14L. They both have similar looks, but the Carmen is Suede, and suede won't hold up well with salt and daily exposure to snow. These will. I love the buckles, very understated but add some interest. These are also very comfortable, and if they are comfortable now, they will be even better in a few months. The most important thing you need to know is that these definitely run large. I normally wear about a 9 and ordered these in a 9 but they were literally slipping right off my foot. I am sizing down to an 8.5, and I think that will be perfect. People who run right between sizes may want to size down a full size. Overall, I love these. I think they are a beautiful, well constructed boot with just enough detail. They will pair well with a lot of different outfits, and I am so excited to wear them!

I absolutely love these boots! I have muscular calves & after trying on several pairs of boots, I have finally found a pair of tall boots that fit well. These are hands down my favorite. I also purchased the Frye Veronica boots, which is a similar look without the heel or shaft height. Both pairs of boots are very well made & comfortable. I ordered my regular size in both styles & found that the Vera fits a little bit looser than the Veronica, but that is easily resolved with a thicker sock. Thank you Zappos for always making shoe shopping a pleasant experience!

I loved these boots. Unfortunately, I had to return them. I have a thin calf and they just didn't look good on my leg. I am heartbroken because they had all the qualities that I was looking for in a boot.

The best boots. They fit great as soon as I put them on. Very comfortable, stylish and timeless. They go with everything - jeans, dresses, skirts, etc. I never spend this much money on footwear, but I know I will wear these forever. High quality Frye craftsmanship - these boots will will last.

Loved the way these boots look. I have large calves and have no problem with the fit. These boots come right up under my knees. They work perfectly with skinny jeans. Overall, the look is very casual- the big rounded toe and the distressed leather give these a rugged feel. These look great with jeans and a long cardigan for fall.