These are gorgeous! I spent forever researching riding boots, even ordered the Melissas and sent them back. I wanted a boot to hit right below the knee (check), look sleek and fit tightly up my calf (check), and look classic with amazing quality construction (check). I recommend these if that's what you're going for. Simply perfect and they are extremely comfortable. Perhaps a little long in the footbed in my normal size, but I love how they fit. It's always nice when boots have a little room. These can also be dressed up or down easily. The price is definitely scary but they're exactly what I wanted so I'm dealing with it!

Love these boots! I have been looking forever for a really nice boot that is flat (and not a cowboy boot) -- and I'm so happy I finally found it! These boots make my chunky calves look skinny thanks to the vertical panels. Super comfortable, reasonably priced, great quality, made in USA -- Thank you, Frye!

I generally have a hard time finding boots that fit over my calves so I was intrigued by the stretch panels and decided to give them a try. So glad I did, they slipped over beautifully and have a fantastic look. Nice upright shaft with stitched soles and very high quality leather. They do tend to run a bit large but I like to put insoles in my boots so that has turned out to be a good thing. I wear them over jeans and with skirts and dresses and every time I wear them I get lots of compliments.

These boots are absolutely gorgeous! I have been searching for over a year for the 'perfect' riding boot. I found them! I always wear a 9.5 and I got these in 9.5. I had read they ran a little big, but I'm happy with the fit. I little extra room, but may put a liner in them anyway? I was afraid of not being able to get smaller ones on! They are a bit of a struggle at first, but no big deal. LOVE!

These boots are gorgeous and fit my skinny calves perfectly. Zappos sent the wrong size, I called them, and they immediately shipped the correct size. Amazing customer service (thanks Rosita!). Definitely order a size down. I was actually able to squeeze my normally size 9.5 foot into a 6.5 (I just had to try them on even though they were the wrong size). And I have a normal to wide foot.