So disappointed. I ordered my usual 8.5 for Frye and I could not even get my foot into these. Maybe because I have a high arch? They do look like they run smaller than other Frye styles. The redwood is beautiful. I exchanged these for a 9. Keeping my fingers crossed!

I absolutely love Zappos! I ordered these on December 23rd and they arrived before noon on the 24th without a hitch. That being said I ordered both the redwood leather and the black leather that was in my normal half size smaller Frye's size of 8½ with the intention of only keeping one pair. I am walking around the house with one on each foot (tough to get into for my high arches but they are already stretching as I wear them) and I like the black a lot more than I thought I would (no distressing just sold black with wood heel), but I also love the redwood which reminds me of saddle leather. I have tried on a few outfits and they both go with all of them. So I definitely do not need to keep both, but I am going to sleep on it, they may both stay. I love the height, I am 5'10" and often boots are too short, but this pair comes to 3-4 inches below my knee. The heel height is fantastic at about 2 inches. This is a good investment for boots that will last forever.

Love my Fryes. I've been eyeing a pair for years in fear my calves won't fit and just overall comfort is a huge factor. Well, I love my Janes and received the vintage brown. About me, 5'2" so here we go: The Fit: the boot hits about 2 inches below my knee without the top of the boot touching the back of my knee. When you're short, this can be an issue. My calf is average width and the shaft fits perfect. I'm surprised there are no reviews that state that these boots feel like pair of clogs. I'm a huge Dansko clog lover so for a pair of boots to fit like a clog is amazing. I wear either a 7 or 7.5 in most shoes and the 7 fits great. A tad loose in the heel and plenty of room for your toes with thicker socks. The color is gorgeous. The vintage brown has black, brown, and reddish tones that make it easy to mix and match with my wardrobe. Looks great with dresses, skirt, and my new "jeggings" (recommend the Levis - they are tight but comfy and wallet friendly) fit just right tucked in. I did go to a cobbler to get some rubber soles added as leather bottoms tend to get slippery in the rain. Overall, exceptional quality on the craftsmanship and a beautiful investment. These boots are definitely worth the money. Doing a little jig in my Fryes.

Thanks Zappos! I bought these boots on a Saturday and was upgraded to faster delivery courtesy of Zappos and received them on Monday night! I initially bought the Frye Melissa boots, but the shaft of the boot was too tall for me (as I am only 5’2�). I returned those and bought these in redwood and looove them. I just turned 30 and wanted a "grown up, womanly" boot. These are it, I feel chic when wearing them. I am between a 6.5 and a 7 and bought the 6.5 and they are perfect. They look good tucked into skinny jeans and the height of the boot was just perfect. It hit about an inch below my knee. Despite the fact that they have a heel, they were comfortable upon first wear. I did get a scuff already on the toe of the boot and I wish Frye would make a coloured cream so that it could cover the scuff, but that’s my only complaint. As with my other Fryes, they will only get better with age and are an investment piece.

I did a ton of research before I made this purchase. And the other reviews helped me so much; I felt I should leave my own comments too! I am 5'4", size 9 shoe and size 8 (29) jean. With very "athletic" calves I really struggle to find the perfect boot... and I was thinking I would need the extended calf version. (Jane 14L) The Verdict? I am extremely happy with these boots! The regular shaft fits snugly over skinny jeans, they come to about 2 inches below my knee, and the medium heel is very sturdy and provides a welcome little "boost". The leather is beautiful and they look like they will last forever. A perfect balance between an equestrian, cowboy and city boot! Love, love, love. Thanks for the great service Zappos... it took about 4 tries, but finally!