The shoe fits great. When I wore thick woolen socks it felt like my feet were walking on clouds. Felt warm enough for regular walking; however, didn't keep my toes warm after being outside for over 30 minutes. The sole is very flat, and the ice-pick technology didn't stop me from sliding around on ice. If you like to stuff your pants into the boot, this one doesn't have any room for that. Also, it started fraying a little bit around the edges where it is sewn together. Overall a good boot for running errands in during winter, but not warm enough to play in the snow.

Absolutely love these boots! I bought them for a trip I take my class on every other year to Washington, D.C. and New York. I have made this trip 7 times and had yet to find a pair of shoes that both kept my feet warm and provided the comfort and support of 14 hours of hard walking. This boot finally did it! I talked my other two teachers into getting the same boot and they also love it! I can't say enough about it! I found the fit run small, but one of the other teachers thought they ran large. With Zappos free shipping, you could try both sizes and keep the one that fits.

I was hoping for a more substantial boot - these were a little flimsy and smaller than an 8. I would recommend ordering a size up. These are look good feel good boots...not storm boots.

These are great boots, nice and warm and comfortable to walk in. I wear a size 8. The 8 fit perfectly (in a store), but I purchased the 8-1/2 so I have room for socks.

I bought these to wear for outdoor pictures at my wedding. It hasn't happened yet but wearing them around the house they're really comfortable! So comfortable and warm that the first pair we bought (a whole size too small!) my mother kept for herself! They look good, they're warm, comfortable, light, and flexible. I have yet to check the water "resistant" part.

My son and I both love these shoes! He is 3 years old and can put them on by himself. The best part is that they stay on even when playing hard and running fast. I usually buy Simple brand, but now that they are gone I have had to look other places. This keen boot is a good fit.

I wanted to love this boot, but there is no way to tighten the laces. I like to buy a little big so there is room to grow, but not being able to tighten them means they slip right off.