Posted: 2009-11-19 17:52:14
Reviewer: Anonymous from Brooklyn, New York
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
Christmas came early for me. I was up waiting for my Melins since 5 am this morning (Fuchsia and Black combination). These shoes are gorgeous and well made. I normally wear a size 9w, but since Zappos only had a size 9.5 I went ahead and ordered it. I had to have this shoe even if it meant stretching them or wearing them tied around my waist! Yes, they are that pretty. The 9.5 is a little snug, but nothing that a shoe tree can't fix in a couple of hours. The shoe is perfect. Be sure to get a half size larger as the toe box is a little narrow. I am going to get the black and white ones, too. I love you Zappos!
Posted: 2009-12-10 08:25:44
Reviewer: Anonymous from Sacramento, California
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
These shoes are cute and really comfortable. They are slightly inexpensive looking. They don't feel like they're built to last a lifetime. They're quite stylish, especially with some slim legged trousers. I love menswear inspired looks!
Posted: 2009-12-15 21:43:48
Reviewer: Anonymous from Seattle
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
Ah, 'tis not to be. My feet would not fit into the 7.5 and I thought, go up one. 8.5 still runs small, though my size 7.5 feet do fit in them. And there is no 9 for me. The black patent is super shiny, but they are a lovely pair of wingtips.
Posted: 2009-12-24 15:56:52
Reviewer: Sandra J from Anniston AL
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
This shoe is great! I have always loved men's wing tip shoes and now finally one for women! I have ordered from Zappos for years and have never been disappointed in the product or the service; both are five star all the way.
Posted: 2010-01-03 08:53:39
Reviewer: Anonymous from St. Louis, MO
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
I love these menswear look shoes. They run true to size, are comfortable, are well made and very stylish. No problems whatsoever. I will order them in another color.
Posted: 2010-01-03 13:20:59
Reviewer: Alaina from New Hampshire
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
Love this shoe! I have it in black. I normally wear an 8 but have a 7.5 in this. I did not want the back to slip up and down and cause a blister. It\'s snug, but still comfortable and have worn them for up to 9 hours at a time. I\'ve worn them with
skirts,
pants and
dresses.
Posted: 2010-01-04 12:57:33
Reviewer: Anonymous from San Diego
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
Great looking shoe, although I wished it looked just a little less clunky. It is true to form; that is, it looks like a scaled down version of a man's wingtip. It could stand to be a little more narrow to make it look a little more dainty, especially if you wear a large size (I ordered a 10, although I could have gone with a 9.5). I'm usually between a 9.5 and a 10 and since I'll probably be wearing these with thin trouser
socks a 10 is too big. They definitely do not run narrow, I can take them off without unlacing them (size 10). The shoes have a man's 'cut' to them, almost like my little brother's shoes, but scaled down. But because they are scaled down and because the leather is very supple, I'd rather go with a smaller size and wear them in a little; they really are very cute shoes and look really cute with
pants. I like. They are also very comfortable. Only thing I really disliked was the laces; for the price I would have like a better quality lace, but good laces are hard to find.
Posted: 2010-01-08 00:24:33
Reviewer: E. M from Bronx, NY
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
Love this shoe! Ordered them at night: 1/6 and arrived early in the afternoon 1/7. Put them on right away! They do run a little narrow. I am a true 7, and although my toes did not touch the tip, they felt a little tight around the middle. But since they're leather, I know in time they will stretch out some. I bought the black patent. They are to die for. Incidentally, I just ordered the same shoe in the cognac color. Can't wait to get those, too! Recommend the shoe! They are really nice. If you're looking for a men-inspired shoe, this fits the bill! And as for Zappos, I always shop here for shoes and
handbags. Super fast shipping and good customer service!
Posted: 2010-01-13 13:19:45
Reviewer: Anonymous from Hollywood, Florida
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
I saw these in the fuchsia and pink on the Today show just before Christmas and had to have them! None of my local go-to
shoe stores had them, so I ordered them from Zappos. I was nervous that they weren't going to work on my very wide feet, and that they were going to look cheap since I don't associate SM shoes with particularly high quality, but they were even better than I'd hoped. I'm a 7.5W and ordered an eight, which is a bit long in the toe box (though not enough for anyone to notice) but sufficiently wide for my feet. And I can tell that the leather will stretch a little more to make the shoe even more comfy. All in all this is a great shoe in a bold colorway that makes the perfect trend statement for your spring wardrobe. If you're thinking about buying them, don't hesitate! Get 'em now!
Posted: 2010-01-18 06:47:09
Reviewer: Anonymous from CT
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
This shoe looks great with a business suit--especially on the days you don't want to wear a heel. The toe could be a little more pointed versus rounded but other than that it is a classic style. They have a plastic smell to them but I hope that will go away in time. Very comfortable.