A friend was wearing these shoes and said that she loved them so I thought I would try them since my Reefs were getting pretty worn out after 5 years of wear. I read all the reviews and decided to order a 10 although I usually wear a 10.5-11. Quite a few people said they smaller size fit fine. They were too small. So I called Zappos that night at 7pm and exchanged them for a size 11. I got the new pair at 3pm the next day! How easy was that? Zappos is awesome! I will send the size 10 back as soon as I get the return label. Overall these shoes feel extremely comfortable. The arch support is great for flip flops and they aren't too floppy because the strap is a great fit. Some people said the toe area is too long but I think if you have average to longish toes, they will fit fine. They will look great with sorts or a summery dress. Just enough detail to make them semi dressy. I hope to get as many years of use out of these as my Reefs. They were my favorite until they made them more narrow. I wish there was a way to buy the old style. Oh well, I think I love these Keens. Thanks Zappos for great customer service!

I can't believe these shoes get such rave reviews. They are okay, but the toe is positioned wrong. I have long toes, so normally appreciate flip flops having the toe hold far enough back so my toes don't hang off the front, but in these shoes it is so far back that I have an extra 1/4 inch at the front and hang off the back heel if I wear my normal size or even a half size up. Will try an even larger size and see if it feels okay at the front once my heel is in the shoe. But they also "flap-flap-flap" sound when you walk, as the elastic between the toes brings the shoe up to meet you heel with each step. And the arch support is minimal. Yet, the look is versatile and needed in my wardrobe, so I will try one last time with a different size.

I was looking for a black flip flop that wasn't too cheap or casual looking; the forgiving leather sole has padding without being mushy like Reefs or Teva styles. I cut off the little brown coconut decal. I got an 8, they are true to size. super comfortable.

These shoes are wonderful! The more you wear them the better they are. Can wear for casual or dress up. I love them. Going to order more colors.

I'm a bit surprised by some of the rave reviews of this flip. I agree with others that the post is too far back. I have 9 pair of Keens - from sandals to boots, and all are size 9. I had to buy a 10 in these because I had so much length in the toe area, and not enough at the back. I decided not to keep them, because that made them look funny. Also, the arch is fairly nice, but the sole is not very thick - I would prefer a sole that isn't so thin. They're cute though, but look better sitting on the floor than on my feet. Three stars for style (they are cute, but post too far back) three stars for comfort (moderate arch, too thin) and overall, 3 stars - could be improved!

I can't wear heels for any length of time - these are the perfect substitute! I bought them for a summer wedding and they were every bit as elegant as the event. They are extremely comfortable for hours and hours of wear. I also wear them with my causal "little black dresses" and they instantly give flair.

These are really stylish and very comfortable-- the perfect summer sandal. I normally wear and 8 1/2 and ordered that size, but the ankle area swims on me and there's no way to tighten it. (My ankles are narrow, so it might be me rather than the shoe.) Will try swapping for a half size down; hopefully that will solve the issue.

These were really cute shoes, but unfortunately, the didn't fit well at all. I had originally ordered an 8, which I usually fit into, but I was swimming in the shoes. So I exchanged and got a 7.5. However, while my feet fit much better, the ankles were still incredibly large; they barely held on to the back of my feet, which was pretty useless for walking like a normal person. Maybe I have small ankles, I don't know, but I think most women might have trouble fitting into these shoes.